YOUR THOUGHTS ON THE REFS RULING SNOOKER

EDIT: I believe that at the time of the video, the rules of snooker didn't have a good rule for what to do in that case. Regardless, I think that ref did the wrong thing.

The current applicable rule in snooker now is in Section 3 of the rules:

(b) In a situation where a moving ball is intentionally moved or picked up, the referee shall make the best possible decision in the interest of fair play.​

I think it's clear that by this rule at least Selby would have had ball in hand in the D, and maybe the ref would have penalized Dott in addition. I believe that this is a fairly new rule -- I had not seen it before I looked just now. There is also an apparently new rule that if the player touches a ball in play at the end of a frame to indicate a concession, and the opponent accepts the concession, no penalty points are awarded for touching a ball.
 
Last edited:
EDIT: I believe that at the time of the video, the rules of snooker didn't have a good rule for what to do in that case. Regardless, I think that ref did the wrong thing.

The current applicable rule in snooker now is in Section 3 of the rules:

(b) In a situation where a moving ball is intentionally moved or picked up, the referee shall make the best possible decision in the interest of fair play.​

I think it's clear that by this rule at least Selby would have had ball in hand in the D, and maybe the ref would have penalized Dott in addition. I believe that this is a fairly new rule -- I had not seen it before I looked just now. There is also an apparently new rule that if the player touches a ball in play at the end of a frame to indicate a concession, and the opponent accepts the concession, no penalty points are awarded for touching a ball.
thanks bob
 
Back
Top