Blown call and lack of sportsmanship

If a pool player over-rides the official's call and admits to a foul, does it matter?

It doesn't in other sports. In tennis, where botched linesman calls were once common, the official's call was all that mattered. Many years ago, some players who were the beneficiaries of obvious bad calls would hit the next point into the net on purpose to even out the bad call. This would draw applause from the crowd, but with time the players preferred to just keep playing their best, as in the long run, bad calls even-out.

Perhaps pool should have a centralized officiating office (like the NHL), where any tight call can undergo video review.
Yeah, it’s a hard question of what a player’s obligation is when there is a ref. You have a ref to avoid disputes but expecting/ allowing players to override a call can create more disputes. It can also hurt a player’s reputation if people expect the player to override a bad call. Most times it’s closer than this one, but it is still possible the player didn’t notice the foul. It also shows up the ref. A good ref won’t blow as many calls but might still wonder why he should bother when the players just overrule the call anyway

There was the recent UPL situation with Tyler Steyer and he took a deliberate to give up bih after a bad call. People applauded it, but the ref who blew the call also failed to call him for the loss of game foul under the ( horrible IMO) UPL rules. So it became a no win for everyone.

There will never be a centralized officiating office for pool. Thank goodness. But look how hard it is for the NFL with all the cameras and money to get it right. They have spent years tinkering with replay rules and such and it is a work in progress. Not easy.

Thorsten hohmann drops out of mosconi

When Sky's name first started showing up I would look on Youtube for his matches. One of his early ones was him playing Thorsten, it was so funny. Here was big, muscular tight shirt Thorsten playing young young Sky Woorward. I believe Sky won, it was on a bar box? Years later I was at Griff's, I think it was a Predator event. Thorsten was playing Sky again, Sky was winning. I was in the bathroom, Thorsten was in there, washing his hands and face, definitely feeling the pressure. Sky won again. Would have been great seeing that go full circle and seeing them on a team together.

Phillipines Open

Jason Shaw has been looking kind of erratic for months compared to the high he was on.. but thats the up and down of pool. It’s what makes svb’s long run amazing.

Shaw almost looks unserious to me at times. When I watch him play I keep waiting for him to do something that seems careless to blow a set.

SVB seems to have two speeds. His peak speed looks almost unbeatable. He gets out in close to impossible racks. But sometimes he seems mentally "off" and screws up key racks where he should have gotten out.

Blown call and lack of sportsmanship

Obvious foul. Awful call.



I do the same thing in league. When someone gets called to watch a hit, it's an absolute coin flip whether or not they make the right call. I've had many erroneously go against me. So therefore if someone makes a bad call in my favor I also accept it. That's the established rules of the game.

If I'm calling it, I'm as honest and accurate as possible.

I saw one where a player correctly asked someone to watch a hit before a shot and asked a trustworthy player to watch it. The chosen ref blew the call and the requesting player argued it with the opponent not the impromptu ref and got their way. Granted the call was mistaken, but when you ask someone to watch a hit and they make a bad call, you have to live with it without complaint IMO.

There have been a bunch of bad ref calls we’ve posted about on here. Any group using refs needs to have a rule about what can be done in a bad call situation. Like a simple rule about allowing video review if available and a rule about whether a player can override a bad call by going to the opponent- those type of things.

AZB forum issue

So I found in the crazy screen I had a style option list. I clicked from default to "slightly grey" that made it kind of dark and weird, but it fixed the site. Then i was able to log in. upon logging in it went nuts again. I fount the list and chose slightly grey again and it fixed the site.
Now I have an ugly grey site but it works. WTF?
Screenshot 2026-10-24 at 11-03-19 AZB forum issue AzBilliards Forums.png

Keilwood shaft order

I saw this video of Crossroad cues with Douglas Moore whom I have never heard of (sorry if I should have), but his marinated kielwood sounds interesting

Filter

Back
Top