Blown call and lack of sportsmanship
- By JPB2
- Main Forum
- 69 Replies
Yeah, it’s a hard question of what a player’s obligation is when there is a ref. You have a ref to avoid disputes but expecting/ allowing players to override a call can create more disputes. It can also hurt a player’s reputation if people expect the player to override a bad call. Most times it’s closer than this one, but it is still possible the player didn’t notice the foul. It also shows up the ref. A good ref won’t blow as many calls but might still wonder why he should bother when the players just overrule the call anywayIf a pool player over-rides the official's call and admits to a foul, does it matter?
It doesn't in other sports. In tennis, where botched linesman calls were once common, the official's call was all that mattered. Many years ago, some players who were the beneficiaries of obvious bad calls would hit the next point into the net on purpose to even out the bad call. This would draw applause from the crowd, but with time the players preferred to just keep playing their best, as in the long run, bad calls even-out.
Perhaps pool should have a centralized officiating office (like the NHL), where any tight call can undergo video review.
There was the recent UPL situation with Tyler Steyer and he took a deliberate to give up bih after a bad call. People applauded it, but the ref who blew the call also failed to call him for the loss of game foul under the ( horrible IMO) UPL rules. So it became a no win for everyone.
There will never be a centralized officiating office for pool. Thank goodness. But look how hard it is for the NFL with all the cameras and money to get it right. They have spent years tinkering with replay rules and such and it is a work in progress. Not easy.