I guess I am showing my ignorance of term usage again. I thought because it was so thin, and penetrated the surface more than most other epoxies, it was considered a penetrating epoxy. It definitely can soak up into wood and phenolic and leave nothing much on the surface. I consider the Hot Stuff super glue to be a penetrating glue also and use it to harden wood surfaces at times. But maybe I am using the wrong term. Can you suggest a better term to describe West System's thin characteristics? I have not tried Smith's so what do you think the results of using Smith's on the surface of cues for a sealer would be? Would it penetrate the surface enough to harden the surface of the wood and eliminate the need for a finish, kind of like a shallow dymond wood surface?
I wouldn't say West is thin, but that is just me. Smith's is like water and what I consider thin. I have some Loctite 5 min that i would consider thick. We never thinned West to use on boats, but sometimes used Smith's if we weren't laying cloth and just wanted to protect then paint or in repairs. To be honest, I don't know how it would work in a cue application as a sealer. I guess I could try. I do know that West claims it is better than Smith's if it is thinned.
Someone must have tried this already.......I would think..
I also can't comment on it's ability to NOT yellow. I believe West has some that is designed to resist yellowing, but I have heard mixed results. I CAN tell you that regular West is guaranteed to yellow.
All this is coming from someone who has worked on wood boats for the last 20 years, not a cuemaker. What some might consider penetrating epoxy I wood not, so I wouldn't say your statement is really ignorant.
If you pour Smith's on a flat piece of wood it will completely soak in, West would level and harden with only light penetration. Smith's might be used before layup of cloth on bare would, then mat, west, cloth, west, ect. It would all depend on what yah were doing.
If I have screwed up any of this, please feel free to chime in.
Sorry for the long reply.