I'm curious, is there a difference between actual hypnosis and just a kind of relaxed, focused, positive mindset? I know hypnosis isn't like in the movies where you can trance people into squawking like a chicken, then snap your fingers and they wake up and forget everything. I've read that it's sort of a directed focused state where other things fall away and the person is more susceptible to suggestion.
I guess what I'm asking... are the people who are saying "hypnosis helped me"... were really getting hypnotized in any medical sense? IS there formal medical criteria for being considered hypnotized? What if they're just getting effectively relaxed and focused through some exercise or a tape?
If that's not the same thing but the results are good either way, I guess I can't knock it. I'm a little cynical though. I wonder if people selling "hypnosis" aren't just giving the patient a reason to use focus and positive thinking... something they could have just activated on their own if they bothered.
PS to edd, that is not meant to offend you. I know the value of therapy in general and I'm not so closeminded as to suggest you're selling snake oil or whatever. What I'm getting at is... how can you tell when someone is improving because of hypnosis vs. improving because they think they're going to, and therefore put a little extra into it? AKA the placebo effect?
I guess what I'm asking... are the people who are saying "hypnosis helped me"... were really getting hypnotized in any medical sense? IS there formal medical criteria for being considered hypnotized? What if they're just getting effectively relaxed and focused through some exercise or a tape?
If that's not the same thing but the results are good either way, I guess I can't knock it. I'm a little cynical though. I wonder if people selling "hypnosis" aren't just giving the patient a reason to use focus and positive thinking... something they could have just activated on their own if they bothered.
PS to edd, that is not meant to offend you. I know the value of therapy in general and I'm not so closeminded as to suggest you're selling snake oil or whatever. What I'm getting at is... how can you tell when someone is improving because of hypnosis vs. improving because they think they're going to, and therefore put a little extra into it? AKA the placebo effect?