If we're talking barbox here, the following are generally true:
- 8-ball is easier at the start (more choices), and gets progressively harder as you take balls (your category) off the table. Unless you play your patterns PERFECTLY, the most difficult shots on the table are when you have one ball left, or are on the 8-ball. This is especially true if all or most of your opponent's ball category is still on the table.
- 9-ball is harder at the start (you have to shoot at the lowest-numbered ball on the table, and with all balls on the table, there are many potential blockers), but gets progressively easier as you take balls off the table.
Most failed runouts or strategy-play in 8-ball (and thus losses) stem from one not paying attention to the differences between it and short-rack rotation games like 9-ball. They are VERY DIFFERENT games. Even your average bar-banger will whoop an accomplished short-rack rotation player's petutie if the short-rack rotation player doesn't acknowledge the difference in game play.
On a barbox especially, when you have all or most of the 15-ball rack on the table, accurate position play is crucial. Whereas you can probably get away with zinging your cue ball around the table in short-rack rotation, do this in 8-ball, and it's a recipe for a loss.
In fact, I'd dare say that 8-ball on a barbox is trickier than 8-ball on a 9-footer, for the "congestion" reason.
Ask yourself these questions:
- When you lose your 8-ball matches, what preceded that loss, other than your opponent running out on you? What did you do?
- Did you have a specific pattern in mind when running your ball category, and try to accurately stick to it? Did you accurately envision the ENTIRE PATTERN, and not just one or two balls ahead?
- Or, did you just bring out your heavy artillery, and fire in shots ("fire in the hole!!"), going from ball to ball (only seeing one ball ahead), perhaps as the way you play in 9-ball? (This is a recipe for disaster.)
- If, in the middle of a safety battle, did you let your pride for your shot-making ability get in the way, and attempt low-percentage shots, rather than put your OPPONENT in the position of a low-percentage shot?
There are many such questions like these, but I think you get the general idea.
Suggestions:
- Other than the obvious tips inferred by the questions above, try playing 8-ball with more experienced players as part of your practice. Don't just throw balls up on the table and "click your 9-ball run 'em out in rotation" switch.
- Play some 14.1 -- if you can. Straight pool will sharpen your 8-ball patterns dramatically. (On a barbox that doesn't have its side opened up to bypass having to take coins to retrieve the balls, this might prove difficult.)
- Get a good book on the subject, like any of Phil Capelle's works, or R. Givens' The 8-ball Bible.
Hope this helps!
-Sean