Rusty Melton needs be added to your list IMHO, PLUS Dennis Swift who is always forgotten for some reason. Dennis has been at this Case made in the USA a very long time, and is a lot of bang for the buck IMHO.
Outside the USA I would have to say Roger with Volturi cases. Great guy with unlimited resources to make anything you would want and surely will be the guy to take over in Jack Justis footsteps in the future.
IMHO you forgot John of JB Cases who is always trying new ideas, and never sit still with what he has achieved in the past.
I have had my JB rugged 3x6 now for about a month and belive the search is over.
Barton is NOT a case maker. He has never made cases. He might be a case designer or case company owner but that's it. I wouldn't recommend investing in any case company in which the owner is involved so much drama. Its not healthy for resale value. JMHO...... You or anyone else doesn't have to agree or argue with my opinion.It is the same opinion to many other players, cuemakers and collectors worldwide.....
So true CC. Always looking to goto the next level.IMHO you forgot John of JB Cases who is always trying new ideas, and never sit still with what he has achieved in the past.
I found it in 1987, It was A Swift 2 x 4 black with lots of great tooling
It has been to hundreds of pool rooms and many tournaments and been tossed under thousands of tablesall over the US.
The leather has cracked a few places {I have never treated it with anything or it would probably still be like new.}
I have gotten compliments from all over the country, If this one ever wears out , I will buy another immediately.
Or are you still Seeking Utopia?
Dennis Swift is IMHO the forgotten Pool Cue Case Maker, think he has been at it the longest, but I could be wrong. His work has evolved, and Dennis even has his latest creations on "FACEBOOK",
Made in the USA, build to last a life time, and Dennis is just a nice guy not to be forgotten!
Every so often I look at a Whitten or something pretty and sleek and leather, then go "why?, my case holds my cues from my car to the pool hall, why spend an extra $200 to walk 50 feet with it?".