No. Actually, the accusations have been flying from the "jumpers" that people who don't like jump cues simply don't like them because they can't use them very well. You have Shane saying get rid of the short cue. Efren hates them. Earl hates them. In the recent Bergman challenge to Boyes, he's asked for no jump cues.
Here's my problem with jump cues. Sometimes, a really good safety should EARN ball in hand. That's just a fact of the game. However, someone decided that we shouldn't reward decent safety play, so they made a jump cue that basically is a "get out of jail free" card. A safe can be made in such a way that kicking at the ball only allows a certain number of contact points on the object ball. The jump cue brings many more points of contact into play.
The great players will want the jump cue gone, because it evens the playing field for people that play a marginal kicking game, because they can mask their deficiencies in a game by investing about 2 hours and $100, and learning how to jump.
Equating jump cues to chalk and leather tips is comical. I can play with any leather tip, and make the same shots I could with a soft or hard leather tip. I may have to adjust to how they spin the ball, but I don't go from an APA 7 to an APA 2 because I switch from a Le Pro to a Moori S. The phenolic tip has no function other than to make the cueball jump, or to make a break shot slightly faster. For me, that is a "shot specific" product, and goes against the integrity and spirit of the game. As such, they should be ruled as illegal.
Do I like the short stick? I think it looks ridiculous. It's "Honey, I shrunk the cue". The minimum length of 40" for a cue serves what purpose? Is there a wall or pole at certain events that require using a shorty cue so that you don't bang the butt into the wall? Are players incredibly short, and need something that short to play?
Argue "innovation" all you want. There is no other sport I can think of that has a "shot specific" piece of equipment, aside from pool. You don't see players changing hockey sticks for slap shots. You don't see soccer players changing into their "bend it" shoes. Baseball players don't change bats while they're at the plate. I cannot think of one game/sport aside from pool that has a piece of shot specific equipment. At least the mace could be used for all shots. Chalk can be used on all pool shots. Leather tips can be used for all shots. The short abomination with the resin tip only does one thing well - make the cueball bounce over another ball. You can't run a rack with it. I could play the rack with my break cue, if I needed to. Shot specific products have no place in the "game" of pool. Artistic billiards - that's where they belong. Along with paper bag trick shots, jumps through the triangle, and any other putt putt creation that can be imagined.