Here is a comparison of Shane Van Boening's Cup record with the records during the past 11 years of everyone else (15 other players) who has played on the team with Shane (2007-2017). Methods A and B are defined in post #1.
In other words, 7 of the 15 teammates Shane has had on Cup teams also played on the team in one or more years prior to Shane's first year. The following stats for those 7 players (Archer, Morris, Deuel, Strickland, Jones, Putnam, and Schmidt) exclude those years prior to 2007 (and, so, are different from what is shown in post #1 above). The stats for the 8 teammates of Shane who have never played without him are the same as in post #1 above.
• Shane Van Boening (11 yrs. -- 2007-2017) ..... 11-16 s, 11-17 d, 4-7 t, 26-40 total A (39%), 17.3-25.9 total B (40%)
• Johnny Archer (7 years -- 2007-2013) ..... 6-4 s, 12-10 d, 3-4 t, 21-18 total A (winning percentage of 54%), 12.6-9.8 total B (winning percentage of 56%)
• Rodney Morris (6 yrs. -- 2007-2008, 2010-2011, 2013, 2016) ..... 3-8 s, 5-14 d, 1-5 t, 9-27 total A (25%), 5.7-16.0 total B (26%)
• Corey Deuel (5 yrs. -- 2007, 2009-2010, 2014-2015) ..... 2-4 s, 6-9 d, 3-2 t, 11-15 total A (42%), 5.6-8.9 total B (39%)
• Dennis Hatch (5 yrs. -- 2009-2010, 2012-2013, 2017) ..... 4-5 s, 7-7 d, 2-3 t, 13-15 total A (46%), 7.9-9.1 total B (46%)
• Mike Dechaine (4 yrs. -- 2011-2012, 2015-2016) ..... 1-6 s, 2-8 d, 2-2 t, 5-16 total A (24%), 2.4-10.4 total B (19%)
• Justin Bergman (3 yrs. -- 2014-2016) ..... 1-5 s, 4-3 d, 1-2 t, 6-10 total A (38%), 3.2-6.9 total B (32%)
• Earl Strickland (3 yrs. -- 2007-2008, 2013) ..... 2-3 s, 4-4 d, 1-2 t, 7-9 total A (44%), 4.2-5.4 total B (44%)
• Skyler Woodward (3 yrs. -- 2015-2017) ..... 0-4 s, 3-6 d, 1-2 t, 4-12 total A (25%), 1.7-7.4 total B (19%)
• Oscar Dominguez (2 yr. -- 2009, 2017) ..... 0-3 s, 3-3 d, 1-1 t, 4-7 total A (36%), 1.7-4.7 total B (27%)
• Justin Hall (1 yr. -- 2014) ..... 1-0 s, 2-1 d, 0-1 t, 3-2 total A (60%), 2.0-0.7 total B (74%)
• Jeremy Jones (1 yr. -- 2008) ..... 0-2 s, 1-2 d, 0-1 t, 1-5 total A (17%), 0.5-3.2 total B (14%)
• Shawn Putnam (1 yr. -- 2011) ..... 0-1 s, 2-1 d, 0-1 t, 2-3 total A (40%), 1.0-1.7 total B (37%)
• John Schmidt (1 yr. -- 2014) ..... 1-0 s, 0-3 d, 0-1 t, 1-4 total A (20%), 1.0-1.7 total B (37%)
• Brandon Shuff (1 yr. -- 2012) ..... 0-3 s, 1-2 d, 1-0 t, 2-5 total A (29%), 0.7-4.0 total B (15%)
• Billy Thorpe (1 yr. -- 2017) ..... 1-0 s, 1-2 d, 0-1 t, 2-3 total A (40%), 1.5-1.2 total B (56%)
____________________________________________________________________________________________
• Total all 16 players (11 years -- 2007-2017) ..... 33-64 s, 64-92 d, 20-35 t, 117-191 total A (38%), 69-117 total B (37%)
•
Total excluding Shane Van Boening ..... 22-48 s, 53-75 d , 16-28 t, 91-151 total A (38%), 51.7-91.1 total B (36%)
•
Shane Van Boening ..... 11-16 s, 11-17 d, 4-7 t, 26-40 total A (39%), 17.3-25.9 total B (40%)
____________________________________________________________________________________________
The above stats for players other than Shane include the doubles and teams matches they played with him. If we exclude those and compare the matches in which Shane played vs. those in which he did not play, we have:
Shane's record (Method A)
- singles -- 11-16 (41%)
doubles -- 11-17 (39%)
Team USA's match record (Method A) excluding Shane's matches:
- singles -- 22-48 (31%)
doubles -- 21-29 (42%)
So Shane has done better in singles (41% vs. 31%) than his teammates and slightly worse in doubles (39% vs. 42%). And, on the contribution method (Method B), as shown above, Shane's winning percentage is 40% vs. his teammates' 36%).