Everyone is trying to buy a game, you should try lessons and practice.
I replied once, but thought I could do much better, so after some consideration.
"Everyone is trying to buy a game."
This can't be more true, if we were playing golf it would stand out far more (imho).
I've been away from the game for 20 years, but even back then, there were novel ideas in 'technology' with regards to billiards.
- Bridge attachements
- Graphite everything
- Gizmos to help your aim; game; etc.
I've even tried a graphite snooker cue, and instantly hated it.
It could be me. I'm not a hammer breaking the balls up in 9 ball, but do recall you don't need to.
(i.e., Hit the white so it lands center table, make one ball, run the rest.). No hammer needed. Old school.
There is a beautiful finesse to the game when it is played well. It's poetic; dancelike; hypnotic; spiritual; melodic, and meditative. None of these can be modified by money. To your next point. Learn to play the game well. This applies to all games and sports.
"you should try lessons and practice."
So, true. When I started, I consumed all materials I could, and from any source. Books; Videos, and instruction. By instruction, I also mean discovering the hustlers that could quietly put my game to shame so well it was palpable. Watching others play well and digesting what they were doing, helps, just as the lessons I paid for from Don Feeney. I had the great privilege to meet and learn a few games from him. (carom, pool, and snooker.). This experience can't be compounded enough in a statement, but what I labored to expand on, you said in one concise statement. An important undeniable truth. Be as student of the game.
Now then, back to tips and chalk.
I've got old equipment, which I love. The newly acquired Ray Schuler, one of the cues I regret selling back in a time where I could visit Ray at his shop and chat with him around a billiard about cues. A mild mannered kind and highly intelligent conversationalist If ever I met one. The cue is warped but I found someone that is willing to take on the repair for a fair price. My next cue, will be a Mike Bender, of which I should also never have parted with so many years ago. I'm on a wait list for one of his great cues.
I've got 4 shafts that need re-tipping, and I only recall a few tips I used back in the day, my shafts actually have them on still. I was reading in this forum about Dennis Searing, and am fascinated by hand made products, and his tips certainly do qualify. After reading about Dennis and his attention to detail and perfection, I'm sensing a common theme, so relevant and important to keep alive in our time moving forward. Hand made, means so very much, and we should promote that. (Granted, his tips are layered, a kind of newer tech., but it works.).
Moving forward to Chalk, and close this post out.
I have had a relationship with Master Chalk dating 30 years. I have a vacuum sealed container of 48 cubes, somewhere. It boggles my mind because that container is 20 years old. I'm going to pause for effect here. So, when I see any product, like ROKU from Kamui, I'm kind of enticed to give it a try. After watching some reviews that can sway one either direction., one thing stood out to me. How long the chalk lasts. Not on your tip, because habitually one should garnish your tip every shot if not lightly just for good measure, and practice. The sheer life span of the chalk. I love the idea of one piece of chalk that can last 6 months maybe a year.
I think we over apply chalk to a nauseating degree, and much of it is left on the cue ball, as well the table. I don't mind splurging $30 personally for chalk, and $10 each per tip that will probably last me a good season of play. Now those $10 tips (Precision Layered from Dennis Searing) Give the man a plug here. Those are for my standard shafts and carom. The snooker shaft on the other hand is going to be an oddball trial of a tip made by a company not known for billiards. As a matter of fact, it's so other side of the spectrum, I'm confused as to why 80% plus of the world's pro snooker players use those tips. They are pig skin, and assumably last a very-very long time. They don't split. I have to try this non-new tech product. The company is Cuesoul, and I was able to buy them in a bag of 5 for $25 on Amazon. I got the super soft (SS) edition, and can't wait to give them a try.
So, my appeal here, forgive the long windedness, is to promote the old technology and hand made forms of the game, as well embrace where one can, some of the newer technology, at least when it benefits our enjoyment and longevity of the game. The less one has to replace a tip, or piece of chalk, the better. Efficiency and fluidity, in my opinion is the goal. One doesn't simply stop dancing in order to change their shoes because the song is different... That's my way of saying, I don't need or want a break stick. Two cues for me. One for carom and pool, and one specifically made for snooker.
If you managed to get this far without falling asleep. You must be an introvert like me, and we should be friends.
Cheers!
-M