APA, FARGO and the death of 8 ball.....

The SL9 made mistakes in execution, but that was not the problem. He never employed the correct strategy. He knew what the correct strategy was, he just went into brain lock. I'd be curious to know what was said, when his teammate came out. Even as a lesser player, I would have reminded him how many times he had beaten a 2, and how he did it. Told him to start playing like he knew how, and knock off the clown show. I bet there is a good chance he would have snapped out of it, and won.
 
I watched this and actually was very invested in the match as to what would happen. Not because I was out to see some top level play, but how the players and match would turn out to be. Does a low level fold under pressure? How would the luck factor hamper the better player (SL2 misses, but the good player has no shot, crapped in balls, etc..)? Can the higher level maintain the needed play to keep the worse player in check?
I watched it just now, if that guy is a 9 then I'm a 19, his understanding of strategy is poor at best, maybe he is really an 8 ball player, when you play a safety and you leave your opponent an open shot you won't win many games, it doesn't look this guy has played much 9 ball.
 
APA sucks it seems.

I guess I'm not the only who was rejected by teams because I was too high.

"Hey I'm interested in joining your team."

Idiot: "You're too high. I've seen you play over there at the big tables."

"Perfect. I can help us win."

Idiot: "We want a very low level player>"

"L-O-L"

To be honest people playing in this league are playing because they don't want to go home. This is like social hour for them or how they socialize. Same players every year but no improvement. They prey on the new players or people who have never held a cue and promise them glory. There is no glory. Teams barely break even all in the name of having fun. Nobody looks to have fun and always moping and crying about what we are talking about here and that is rating. It's the modern day shuffle board league.

League operators making easy money since the leagues practically run themselves. Sometimes you have to pick up the phone and tell them where to play. Some administrative work and once a year you give them trophies for them to feel good about themselves.

Ask yourself this what is their mission objective?
You paint with a very broad brush. We have a vibrant division here, 10-14 teams most sessions. Both 8 and 9 ball nights. (There are two nights of TAP in this room as well, meaning four nights in a row full because of league pool.) People ARE having fun (except for me when I play like a bonehead, sigh) most of us know each other pretty well by now. Is there a social aspect to it, certainly. But people take it seriously enough, and are usually pretty good sports, too.

I make it a point to keep score as much as I can. I'm not a very good player, but I watch all of the players, and have for years. I know who is under-handicapped, for our league. Most folks are pretty close to where they should be. For our league. Comparing one players ability versus others. Once in a while there is someone who is pretty obviously below where he/she should be. I like to make sure to score those folks matches, so all the defensive shots get marked. Yes, many folks don't do that. But its a general, league-wise phenomenon, no matter how many times it gets explained. Meaning its pretty consistent that those keeping score aren't marking defenses when they should, for both teams.

In 95% of these instances, the players aren't trying to pad their innings to sandbag. There are a few folks that I can tell are doing it. But a small number. So its not "rampant" here. Of course, it could be elsewhere. Your mileage may vary.

I enjoy my league nights. Obviously lots of others do too, else why would the APA continue to thrive, given all the bellyaching we see here. It serves its customer base, and serves it well. It sure isn't for everyone. And that's OK. Stop making it out to be awful just cuz it ain't for you. Many pool rooms would be in tough shape without league, APA and others.
 
League operators making easy money since the leagues practically run themselves. Sometimes you have to pick up the phone and tell them where to play. Some administrative work and once a year you give them trophies for them to feel good about themselves.

Ask yourself this what is their mission objective?
If it's such easy money, maybe you should give it a try, if you can get through the vetting process. Try it first, then come back here and tell us how easy it is. Many of us are like ducks, we look calm and peaceful to everyone else but underneath we're pumping like crazy just to stay afloat. We do have many tools to help us but those have been developed over the 44 years APA has been around, so good for us that we can accomplish more than we used to and don't break down after a hundred teams or so.

Want the mission statement? Here it is. “To create VERY satisfied and loyal Members, Teams and Host Locations who recommend us to others”. I'll give you a clue - you don't do that by sitting around doing nothing.
 
You paint with a very broad brush. We have a vibrant division here, 10-14 teams most sessions. Both 8 and 9 ball nights. (There are two nights of TAP in this room as well, meaning four nights in a row full because of league pool.) People ARE having fun (except for me when I play like a bonehead, sigh) most of us know each other pretty well by now. Is there a social aspect to it, certainly. But people take it seriously enough, and are usually pretty good sports, too.

I make it a point to keep score as much as I can. I'm not a very good player, but I watch all of the players, and have for years. I know who is under-handicapped, for our league. Most folks are pretty close to where they should be. For our league. Comparing one players ability versus others. Once in a while there is someone who is pretty obviously below where he/she should be. I like to make sure to score those folks matches, so all the defensive shots get marked. Yes, many folks don't do that. But its a general, league-wise phenomenon, no matter how many times it gets explained. Meaning its pretty consistent that those keeping score aren't marking defenses when they should, for both teams.

In 95% of these instances, the players aren't trying to pad their innings to sandbag. There are a few folks that I can tell are doing it. But a small number. So its not "rampant" here. Of course, it could be elsewhere. Your mileage may vary.

I enjoy my league nights. Obviously lots of others do too, else why would the APA continue to thrive, given all the bellyaching we see here. It serves its customer base, and serves it well. It sure isn't for everyone. And that's OK. Stop making it out to be awful just cuz it ain't for you. Many pool rooms would be in tough shape without league, APA and others.
You're probably right and I'm painting a very broad brush but this is from what I've seen.

Nobody has ever said anything good about them while some praise other leagues.

These are the same conversations in every thread that involves them. Rating, teams and sandbagging.

I apologize for generalizing other APA leagues to what I've witnessed in my area.
 
You're probably right and I'm painting a very broad brush but this is from what I've seen.

Nobody has ever said anything good about them while some praise other leagues.

These are the same conversations in every thread that involves them. Rating, teams and sandbagging.
Yup. And some of it is true.

Its funny tho, folks rarely post about when something is going well, only when they want to complain about stuff. Depending on who you ask and whose numbers you believe, APA has over 200,00 people playing, often quoted as over 250, 000. Maybe its not all of that number, but its gotta be a very large number. So its obviously doing something right for some folks. Or right enough.

And I don't for a minute doubt that there are areas where it's not run well, and the experience isn't as good. Again, with that many people involved, it's a given that there will be a wide range of experiences.
 
Granted, the pressure is high BUT you/he should be able to fade at least some of that. Didn't he and his team go through tri-cups, and at least five rounds of play in Vega$ to get there?? Still, that does not explain his choices/strategy. Did he get his team to finals on pure luck?? I think NOT. Even a "good" SL2 is not going to make a table length cut shot more than 33% of the time. I play a SL2, I'm either potting balls in my pattern, playing SAFE, or at a minimum leaving whitey on the rail for them.
I watched the best players do stupid shit under pressure. I watched Alex dog an easy 9 to win the world championships and he’s a pro so pressure could do all kinds of crazy shit to your brain to an average guy who’s never been in that big of a situation.
 
APA sucks it seems.

I guess I'm not the only who was rejected by teams because I was too high.

"Hey I'm interested in joining your team."

Idiot: "You're too high. I've seen you play over there at the big tables."

"Perfect. I can help us win."

Idiot: "We want a very low level player>"

"L-O-L"

To be honest people playing in this league are playing because they don't want to go home. This is like social hour for them or how they socialize. Same players every year but no improvement. They prey on the new players or people who have never held a cue and promise them glory. There is no glory. Teams barely break even all in the name of having fun. Nobody looks to have fun and always moping and crying about what we are talking about here and that is rating. It's the modern day shuffle board league.

League operators making easy money since the leagues practically run themselves. Sometimes you have to pick up the phone and tell them where to play. Some administrative work and once a year you give them trophies for them to feel good about themselves.

Ask yourself this what is their mission objective?
Don’t want to go home? I’ve never met anyone in apa leagues that didn’t love to play. Stop talking about things you have no idea. Those people love the game. Some of them may not be great at it but they love playing and have more respect for the game then you apparently do. Not everyone can be a world champion but that doesn’t mean they don’t love the game as much as you and I.
 
Don’t want to go home? I’ve never met anyone in apa leagues that didn’t love to play. Stop talking about things you have no idea. Those people love the game. Some of them may not be great at it but they love playing and have more respect for the game then you apparently do. Not everyone can be a world champion but that doesn’t mean they don’t love the game as much as you and I.
You're probably right as well.

I find that as I get older and older I don't play enough as I should or want to. It is still fun but I may have lost my passion for the game. A lot of that has to do with reaching a certain point in my game where I hit that plateau and have no time to practice at least 4 hours a day.

It is pretty sad that I have sort of given up on the game. I still play but losing doesn't bother me anymore when it did years ago. I would have nightmares of missed shots but no longer.

I was sneaking into pool halls illegally at 16 so nobody can deny my once love for the game. Anyone breaking any laws to play pool? I don't think so.
 
If it's such easy money, maybe you should give it a try, if you can get through the vetting process. Try it first, then come back here and tell us how easy it is. Many of us are like ducks, we look calm and peaceful to everyone else but underneath we're pumping like crazy just to stay afloat. We do have many tools to help us but those have been developed over the 44 years APA has been around, so good for us that we can accomplish more than we used to and don't break down after a hundred teams or so.

Want the mission statement? Here it is. “To create VERY satisfied and loyal Members, Teams and Host Locations who recommend us to others”. I'll give you a clue - you don't do that by sitting around doing nothing.
When I hear people complaining about all the money our LO must be making, I have a lot of fun with them. First thing I start with is if it's so easy, why aren't you doing it?

Let's see... the amount of money you need to put up to get the territory rights? So that means the LO has some skin in the game, right? They have a right to actually expect to make a living, given their investment in their business, and in their customer base, right?

Then the actual work involved. Then actually dealing with and managing a very large group of people. Many of whom like to whine a little ;)

When you explain the actual scope of things, some of them come around. There will always be those who think it's easy. They just want to bitch and whine.
 
I watched the best players do stupid shit under pressure. I watched Alex dog an easy 9 to win the world championships and he’s a pro so pressure could do all kinds of crazy shit to your brain to an average guy who’s never been in that big of a situation.
Totally agree, and if you have not been there recently the APA's Championship Arena has come a long way...Table surrounded by elevated stands on 3 sides and an elevated commentators booth on the other. Bright lights, table conditions slightly different from what you played on all week leading up the final (and not allowed to hit balls on table at all before the match), and about 4-5 tv cameras.

It has almost a "Mosconi Cup" type of feel to it for an Amateur player. I can tell you from firsthand experience that I don't care how many regional tours you've won or placed in, playing in that arena is just different and if you've never done it before, you will definitely feel the nerves big time.
 
Totally agree, and if you have not been there recently the APA's Championship Arena has come a long way...Table surrounded by elevated stands on 3 sides and an elevated commentators booth on the other. Bright lights, table conditions slightly different from what you played on all week leading up the final (and not allowed to hit balls on table at all before the match), and about 4-5 tv cameras.

It has almost a "Mosconi Cup" type of feel to it for an Amateur player. I can tell you from firsthand experience that I don't care how many regional tours you've won or placed in, playing in that arena is just different and if you've never done it before, you will definitely feel the nerves big time.
You have a lot of basement champions who act like it would be no big deal. They would just play like they play with no one watching. Lol
 
When I hear people complaining about all the money our LO must be making, I have a lot of fun with them. First thing I start with is if it's so easy, why aren't you doing it?

Let's see... the amount of money you need to put up to get the territory rights? So that means the LO has some skin in the game, right? They have a right to actually expect to make a living, given their investment in their business, and in their customer base, right?

Then the actual work involved. Then actually dealing with and managing a very large group of people. Many of whom like to whine a little ;)

When you explain the actual scope of things, some of them come around. There will always be those who think it's easy. They just want to bitch and whine.
Easy or not that is subjective. As a whole, the league can pretty much run itself because adults can still act like adults. They can still meet and play, keep track of score and leave the scoresheet in drop box or at the bar.

The lucrative part about being an LO is how much a bar is going to pay me to hold matches there. The commission a league operator gets from drinks bought by their players must be accounted for. Bars and pool halls pay LO's to hold matches there. This is what you guys don't see. How I know? They told me so. We sat their talking shop and I mentioned all of what I explained and they tell me they already do this. (*I MAY OR MAY NOT BE TELLING THE TRUTH; IT MAY OR MAY NOT HAVE HAPPENED)

The APA teams and players are an asset to an operator but many don't know this nor does it want to be made out in public.

If an LO isn't already doing this then I can understand the struggles financially.
 
Last edited:
You're probably right as well.

I find that as I get older and older I don't play enough as I should or want to. It is still fun but I may have lost my passion for the game. A lot of that has to do with reaching a certain point in my game where I hit that plateau and have no time to practice at least 4 hours a day.

It is pretty sad that I have sort of given up on the game. I still play but losing doesn't bother me anymore when it did years ago. I would have nightmares of missed shots but no longer.

I was sneaking into pool halls illegally at 16 so nobody can deny my once love for the game. Anyone breaking any laws to play pool? I don't think so.
If I didn’t have a diamond in my garage I wouldn’t be playing every day lol I’m beat by the end of the work day. No one way I would have the energy to goto the pool hall or around here bar every night to play. Some people don’t have the drive or maybe even the natural ability to get really good at the game but that doesn’t mean they don’t love it . I see golfers all the time who are terrible. It they are out their every week for the love of the game. They are supporting and spending money like the rest of us and god bless the for it lol
 
"No wonder USA is falling behind.... we are a bunch of cheaters and bangers with little motivation to get better...."

As much as I would like my handicap to be a notch lower for league play, I just can't make myself sandbag, I have too much desire to win. Also, there isn't a whole lot of money pay back difference between winning a league and coming in lower. My reward is improving as a player, this is where I get my satisfaction from. Sandbaggers ruin leagues for participants.
 
You don't become a 600+ in Fargo by accident, and that is so far over a 5 that even the APA officials should see that clearly and disqualify the team. Seeing how he was playing is useless because a team captain that got a team to the APA national final table would not be stupid enough to run racks out in public in Vegas, more than is absolutely needed to stay ahead a few points. What you need to do is see how he plays when he thinks no one can do anything about it. Which is how you get a 5 with a 630 Fargo. Sandbagging is easy even without a loss or with people watching, just miss a few times playing two way shots leaving the other player hooked. A 600 Fargo can do that easily. And a 5 may be able to run out every so often, so just do that every 10 racks or so and chalk it up to "luck" or "I got a hot streak".
Oh, people cheat in APA but those same people don't cheat in Fargo? Excuse me, I forgot about the magic word. I didn't realize they suddenly all became honest in Fargo. Perhaps the way to cheat in Fargo is to keep your own rating down while keeping others up. What, that's a natural consequence of beating someone 5-4 instead of 5-0 like you can, or reporting 5-0 wins as 5-4 (what's the vetting process for reporting to Fargo anyway)? Maybe he's really a 500 or maybe the players he plays are really 700+ and maybe top Fargo players should be much higher. If I had a Fargo, it might be somewhere around 500, and top players are way more than 16-1 against me. That would be 400 points in Fargo, making top Fargo more than 900. So either they're too low or I'm too high, most likely both. Cheating in Fargo compresses the entire range between players. It's easy to do - just play in a league that reports to Fargo. You don't even have to lose any matches - just make sure it's reported to Fargo as hill-hill, whether it was or not. Take the blinders off - a cheater is a cheater. And those 2-way shots should be scored as defense.

I used my own eyes to look up his name after the person in the chat brought up that fact. I have also talked recently to several players on a team in TN that have told me they dumped matches to drop down levels after they went up. Like an APA 3 was running 5-6-7 balls in rotation every time at the table, and another 5 was even better, he said he went up to a 6 and then had to dump a bunch of games to drop back to a 5. I mean what kind of APA 3 is upset because they did not run out a rack every game? One that is not a real 3, a 3 will be happy to run 3 balls in a row, and if they get to 4 it's a once in a blue moon occurance with random position and speed.
So you didn't actually see the guy play but you're sure he's cheating. And that team in Tennessee - did you report what they said to the LO there? If nobody did and if nobody ever keeps score properly, what is it, exactly, that you expect the LO to do? Do you even know if what they said was true?

Pretending the APA does not have a major cheating problem needs as much ignoring of reality as the arguments flat earthers put out. Easily 25% of players are a level or two under their skill, on purpose. Every pool hall I have been has a known set of teams that sandbag and plan who will lose. People say things like "I don't want to be a 5" like it's something they control instead of just playing and getting a rating based on that whatever it may end up being.
25% might have been close 25 years ago. Not now that we have the internet. And saying things like "I don't want to be a 5" is quite different than "I'm trying to become a 4". The former implies no foul play at all, and a good response to that is "And what are you doing about that?". And the latter is often an excuse for losing.

Heck, like 10 years ago I went to a new pool hall for me in my area, the very first person I played there was in the APA and when I asked him his skill level after seeing how he played he said "5" with a shrug and laugh about that skill level with a "oh well, you know..." comment LOL. He was pretty much as good as I was and I would be maxed out in the APA by what everyone tells me. People know, and people know they know and others know, but it stops at the point of actually doing something about it.
At the point of who actually doing something about it? In my experience, that bottleneck is in reporting it and learning to keep score properly. For some reason folks don't want to rat out cheaters or do their part to make it harder. They just want to complain about cheating in general, without any specifics. And how do you know that guy 10 years ago wasn't really a 7 trying to get some action from you?

For the record, catching sandbaggers IS part of my job (and a part I take very seriously), but so is distinguishing between what info upon which I rely and what info is just hearsay and speculation.
 
Easy or not that is subjective. As a whole, the league can pretty much run itself because adults can still act like adults. They can still meet and play, keep track of score and leave the scoresheet in drop box or at the bar.
That part is even easier now with the Scorekeeper app. It's easier for the LO AND easier for the players. One of those tools that was developed over the years. But the part that has to happen in between, that part is the work the LO puts in "under the water", so to speak. It doesn't magically get done by itself.

The lucrative part about being an LO is how much a bar is going to pay me to hold matches there. The commission a league operator gets from drinks bought by their players must be accounted for. Bars and pool halls pay LO's to hold matches there. This is what you guys don't see. How I know? They told me so. We sat their talking shop and I mentioned all of what I explained and they tell me they already do this. (*I MAY OR MAY NOT BE TELLING THE TRUTH; IT MAY OR MAY NOT HAVE HAPPENED)

The APA teams and players are an asset to an operator but many don't know this nor does it want to be made out in public.

If an LO isn't already doing this then I can understand the struggles financially.
Very few, if any, LOs do anything like this. I've heard of LOs who bid their tournaments out, but that's as far as it goes. A location's business is their business, we don't want any part of it. They earn their money as much as we earn ours. There's a lot more to making money on drinks than just opening the doors to leagues.
 
At the point of who actually doing something about it? In my experience, that bottleneck is in reporting it and learning to keep score properly. For some reason folks don't want to rat out cheaters or do their part to make it harder. They just want to complain about cheating in general, without any specifics. And how do you know that guy 10 years ago wasn't really a 7 trying to get some action from you?

For the record, catching sandbaggers IS part of my job (and a part I take very seriously), but so is distinguishing between what info upon which I rely and what info is just hearsay and speculation.

The metro area APA divisions may be more spiteful than the more rural areas as far as “complaining” about sandbagging/cheaters. The rural area divisions are just scared to death about breaking up teams and having no one to come fill in the gaps.
 
The lucrative part about being an LO is how much a bar is going to pay me to hold matches there. The commission a league operator gets from drinks bought by their players must be accounted for. Bars and pool halls pay LO's to hold matches there. This is what you guys don't see. How I know? They told me so. We sat their talking shop and I mentioned all of what I explained and they tell me they already do this. (*I MAY OR MAY NOT BE TELLING THE TRUTH; IT MAY OR MAY NOT HAVE HAPPENED)

The APA teams and players are an asset to an operator but many don't know this nor does it want to be made out in public.

If an LO isn't already doing this then I can understand the struggles financially.
As I understand it, there is no payouts from the bars here... its an exchange. The league gets to play there, and the players aremn't charged table time (beyond a small greens fee), and i exchange the bar gets to sell more food and drinks. The bar doesn't get to rent those tables during the time league is going on, thus the trade-off, they do it to sell the food and drink. Gets more people into their rooms, during the week, and maybe they'll come back again on a non league time as well.
 
As I understand it, there is no payouts from the bars here... its an exchange. The league gets to play there, and the players aremn't charged table time (beyond a small greens fee), and i exchange the bar gets to sell more food and drinks. The bar doesn't get to rent those tables during the time league is going on, thus the trade-off, they do it to sell the food and drink. Gets more people into their rooms, during the week, and maybe they'll come back again on a non league time as well.
In theory you are correct.

In shenanigan theory there are things we don't even know.
 
Back
Top