If a gun was put to your head to choose one player to pocket a difficult shot for you, who would you choose?

paolo2144 said:
Depends are we talking 9 ball or 8 ball pool on US tables or blackball on UK pool table or Chinese 8 ball or even snooker.

My answer would vary every time depending on what cue sport.

If we are talking 9 ball pool then probably Effren, if talking UK pol then could pick number of candidates but Mick Hill or Chris Melling would be up there and as for snooker eother peak Hendry or Ronnie as under pressure both amazingly consistent potters.

Chinese 8 ball then Gareth potts would be in with a shot at his best.
Click to expand...
fjk said:
It's close between:
  • Filler
  • Shaw
  • Earl
  • Worst (from the stories I've read)
  • Trump
  • Dennis Orcollo
Also, I have an Earl story. One time I was watching a young Earl (21-22) practice before a match. For some unknown reason, he started shooting out of a corner jaw to a ball in the middle of the table exactly straight into the far corner. He was jacking up way more than he needed to and hitting it as hard as a break shot. I don't know why he was doing that. He probably shot that shot 20 times and probably made 17 or 18. It was scary weird to watch someone shoot that hard and that straight while jacked up out of the corner and be that accurate.
Click to expand...

the guy puts a gun to your head and you do all this reasoning and digressions? you already know that he is crazy, with this niche pool shooting request
 
smoochie said:
This question has been asked alot, basically if the player makes the ball he'll spare your life, if he misses you're gone.

In this thread you can choose any player from any ERA. The shot is long tough shot.

One thing, just write ONE name, you can't choose multiple, or go "if not this then i'll choose that player instead" JUST ONE NAME, ONE PLAYER.

Also no wall of text explanation, just one name and be done with it, maybe one sentence is fine about the player.
Click to expand...
Myself.
Gotta add Louie to the mix.
 
Last edited:
to qualify things

louie certainly if any cut was involved
eddie taylor if any bank

eddie kelly if it was any random difficult shot.

anyone else named would choke under enough pressure.
 
hello said:
Depends on the safety vs. the shot and I wasn't saying that other parts of the game should not be merited but that was not the question.Could Mosconi/Greenleaf make the most difficult long range shots consistenly?We don't know and thats why neither me nor you would have chosen them for the task.

But the question was who is the greatest shotmaker under pressure and Efren is not mentioned among the best ball pocketers,
Parica undoubtedly would be ranked above him and most likely Sigel too.
Click to expand...

vintagecollectibles831 said:
The equipment was so different too, right? The cue balls were really heavy, right? I imagine doing a draw shot, or using any kind of English on the cue ball was probably impossible on the equipment from that Era.

I guess that they were just really great at cue ball control, and reading the rack, and really great at knowing exactly how the balls would break out. And, they played perfect on that really slow cloth, with a really heavy cue ball.

Way off topic, but I would like to see the top players of today attempt to play on those conditions.
Click to expand...
I fully agree.
 
the top players would all adjust over a short time period. except those that couldn't increase their stroke power.
 
Frank Taberski….Greenleaf couldn’t beat him when Frank was in stroke.

And on long thin cuts along the short rail….I’d take Parica over St Louis Louie …and Jose didn’t need extra help.
 
Last edited:
smoochie said:
This question has been asked alot, basically if the player makes the ball he'll spare your life, if he misses you're gone.

In this thread you can choose any player from any ERA. The shot is long tough shot.

One thing, just write ONE name, you can't choose multiple, or go "if not this then i'll choose that player instead" JUST ONE NAME, ONE PLAYER.

Also no wall of text explanation, just one name and be done with it, maybe one sentence is fine about the player.
Click to expand...
Corn Bread Red....
 
Years ago playing push out you were often forced to shoot low percentage shots. It is amazing what you can make when you have to. Richle Ambrose would push out to impossible cuts. You say shoot again and he would make it.

We also played a lot of pill pool and ring games. When it was your turn you better be able to come with a shot be it a bank, combo, tough cut whatever. 5 handed ring 9 ball you may go several games and not shoot.

There was a popular game called " One shot Harrigan", designed for shot makers. Mosconi said if Ponzi got in he could make anything. He would end the game.
 
smoochie said:
This question has been asked alot, basically if the player makes the ball he'll spare your life, if he misses you're gone.

In this thread you can choose any player from any ERA. The shot is long tough shot.

One thing, just write ONE name, you can't choose multiple, or go "if not this then i'll choose that player instead" JUST ONE NAME, ONE PLAYER.

Also no wall of text explanation, just one name and be done with it, maybe one sentence is fine about the player.
Click to expand...
A Smith & Wesson .38 is my answer.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top