I think this is a silly thread. Every cue maker has made a dud or two during their career. I mean all of them. I’ve shot with some Szambotis that were magical and others I could not make a ball with.
Dave Kikel told me a story of a guy that loved a cue he made him. The guy feel on hard times and sold it. Got back on his feet and could not buy that cue back for any amount.
So Dave built him an exact copy, completely identical. The guy received the cue and told Dave it was nothing like the other one he loved so much..
Cues are funny, and as Dan James told me God makes the wood, we just put it together. Sometimes the stars all align and perfection happens.
As to the cue makers that come and go their work cannot be compared to cue makers that have been producing cues for over 20 years or so.
Doing business with them is filled with uncertainty, look at their background and apprenticeship for answers…