Wrong. Any young US player would basically force an already less talented Team USA to play with one hand behind its back. Just throwing out a young guy would be the height of follyI'm also not up to date with the younger American players, but I have no issue with one of them being on the team, even if they haven't "earned a spot"
There's no upside to selecting the same players over and over again.
I've suggested a similar idea.What I would do if I were MR, is make the wildcard pick (for both teams) a player under 25 that's never played in the MC before.
This year, MR has little choice. I do expect some changes in the future.But I imagine MR will just maintain the status quo and make Billy or Sky the final pick.
I disagree.. we need players not a hype man. Banks aside, Billy is an average pro IMOIf I had my pick for the wildcard, it would be Billy Thorpe because he gets along well with the others and brings enthusiasm and excitement to the team.
He's got the experience of playing on the big stage, and I think he can bring it on. He's hitting 'em strong as of late and attending a lot of events.
View attachment 941455
I remember when wildcards with Matchroom were promoter's choice.Wild cards have to be selected from eligible players. Those are the rules for 2026. Maybe MR will change them next year, but I can't imagine they suddenly are going to change them now.
Billy is a little more than hype man. He can play some. Better than most, IMO. What is his Fargo? Just curious.I disagree.. we need players not a hype man. Banks aside, Billy is an average pro IMO
... as are almost all the 750-799 players, but winning at the Mosconi is not about occasional brilliance, it's about sustained excellence. Finally, Bergman played nothing but eight ball for years, while the top players play it once or twice a year. Are we really to read much into those results? Let me know if they switch the Mosconi Cup to 8ball. Of course, I want Bergman on my team if that happens.Bergman beat Filler and Wojiech in the World Eight Ball in April.
He is capable of beating the top Europeans.
IMO his Fargo is irrelevant. I could be wrong, but has he ever won a significant tournament?Billy is a little more than hype man. He can play some. Better than most, IMO. What is his Fargo? Just curious.
Well, we'll have to momentarily throw out the participation requirements that would make them eligible, but if you'll allow me that: 1) Lukas Verner, 2) Lazaro Martinez, 3) Sam Henderson, 4) Nathan Childress, 5) Eric Roberts, 6) Landon Hollingsworth and 7) Payne McBride.Do you have any suggestions on who those younger picks would be? Which younger players have put in the time and effort and winning pedigree? I watch a lot of pool, maybe not as much as some, but I can't come up with any names that would fit the bill... can you help me out a little here?
No, he isn't, but I might entertain "slight upgrade." To my knowledge, neither has ever won a major championship at 9ball or 10ball.Justin is a clear upgrade over Billy, but nowhere near enough. Team Europe is still a strong favorite.
I'm a Billy Thorpe fan, but there is no evidence of any kind that he makes those around him play better. His enthusiasm and excitement has not translated to better performance for either him or his teammates.If I had my pick for the wildcard, it would be Billy Thorpe because he gets along well with the others and brings enthusiasm and excitement to the team.
He's got the experience of playing on the big stage, and I think he can bring it on. He's hitting 'em strong as of late and attending a lot of events.
View attachment 941455
I agree, and I’ll repeat myself that we need players not hype men.I'm a Billy Thorpe fan, but there is no evidence of any kind that he makes those around him play better. His enthusiasm and excitement has not translated to better performance for either him or his teammates.
Good post. I agree with most of it. We understand that Tea USA will, perforce, have some guys on it that had very weak campaigns in 2026, but that does not mean that they don't deserve their spots.I think Bergman is a clear upgrade. Thorpe is less strategic than Bergman, and Team USA needs players who are more strategic.
That said, he is not the key. The key is for SVB and Gorst to play like two of the five best players in the world.
Team USA has enough talent to keep it close and even win, but yes, Team Europe would probably have to play below their standard. We know it happens in all sports. So there is always hope!
He is living on past glory. Matchroom making him a captain the past two years was a grave mistake.
The qualification process is too tight. Young players in particular don't have the financial means to travel to many many big events globally.
I think one solution could be adding a sixth player, basically an apprentice. Shaw has argued for six-man teams to give teams depth in case of injury, illness, a player feeling stress. The sixth player could be a young and promising player who plays a limited role, but gets to experience it.
We've gone over this before. Young US players have no reason to be suspicious. Nobody who is young has earned a spot.
Lukas was on the verge of doing so until he got hurt. One could argue he deserved a spot last year, but if he did, it was marginally so. He had no real big wins to speak of.
A few years ago, Shane Wolford got on the team and did OK. Then he basically dropped off the Matchroom map.
The only other young player who met the criteria this year was Nathan Childress. He did nothing to earn a spot.
Justin is a clear upgrade over Billy, but nowhere near enough. Team Europe is still a strong favorite.
That’s true, but we still need the best Americans we can and Justin is one of them.team europe is a massive favorite no matter who they pick
Very thin gruel. Very thin.Well, we'll have to momentarily throw out the participation requirements that would make them eligible, but if you'll allow me that: 1) Lukas Verner, 2) LazaMartinez, 3) Sam Henderson, 4) Nathan Childress, 5) Eric Roberts, 6) Landon Hollingsworth and 7) Payne McBride.
Ok, maybe I do recognize all of those names, but which one(s) will be able to hold their own against any of the picked Americans, much less he Euro's? Outside of an upset, I don't think they can. Or are you just saying you want them to get the experience too?Well, we'll have to momentarily throw out the participation requirements that would make them eligible, but if you'll allow me that: 1) Lukas Verner, 2) Lazaro Martinez, 3) Sam Henderson, 4) Nathan Childress, 5) Eric Roberts, 6) Landon Hollingsworth and 7) Payne McBride.
That’s true, but we still need the best Americans we can and Justin is one of them.
I think anyone is eligible for a wild card, regardless of what Billy was "told". We might even see Earl.I remember when wildcards with Matchroom were promoter's choice.
I do not agree with your statement, but that's okay. We can have different opinions. Most people do.I'm a Billy Thorpe fan, but there is no evidence of any kind that he makes those around him play better. His enthusiasm and excitement has not translated to better performance for either him or his teammates.