Best pool player? Best at what game is one of the questions or Best all around. There are to many different games so the question has to be more specific. .
If it's the best all around player ever I'd put him in the top 5. As the best all around player currently playing today I put him #1.
Hmm, are you aware of what Josh has accomplished?. I'd be interested in hearing who has a more complete set of championships across the disciplines.
One Pocket
Few would dispute that the hardest one pocket event in the world to win is the Buffalo Billiards annual event, where the winner usually walks away with $50,000+. Filler has won it.
Straight Pool
In Josh' career, the two hardest titles to capture were the European 14.1 Championships and the American 14.1 Championships. Josh has won both of them. While never really focusing on straight pool alone, he ran over 290 when he was 14 years old and has the highest run ever at the Derby city 14.1 event.
8ball
Josh has won the World 8ball Championship. Yes, the World 8ball only dates back to 2004, so it's hard to compare today's player's to those of the 1990s or earlier, when there was a PBT 8ball event but no true world championship in the discipline.
Bank Pool
Surely, the hardest bank pool event to win is the Derby City Classic 9ball banks event. Josh has won it.
9ball
Josh has won the World 9ball and the US Open 9ball, countless other nine ball majors all over the world and double digit Eurotour titles. He's the best 9ball player I've seen in my 51 years around the game.
10ball
Though having a silver and a bronze at the World 10ball but no gold yet, Josh has won a whole lot of 10ball majors.
Like Efren, Josh has routinely found the top rung of the ladder in virtually every discipline that he has ever tried and has a shockingly compete set of major titles across all the disciplines at the age of 29. Unless you include Harold Worst, an all-time great at both pool and three cushion billiards, it's not clear that anyone rates higher. Reyes, Pagulayan, Lassiter, Varner, SVB and Sigel are at a similar level to Josh in all-around play, but unlike the others, Josh has conquered all of the disciplines by the age of 29. Fedor Gorst is also mind-blowingly great as an all-around cueist and, to this point, he has outachieved Josh at Derby City at both banks and one pocket, with Filler dominant in the 9ball. Any all-around match between Josh and Fedor could go either way.
It's always going to be an interesting comparison between these all-time greats, but I think few realize just how successful Josh has been across the disciplines.