I don't like the rule that 8 on the break wins, because it's inconsistent with the rules of 8-ball, that you have to make all of your group and then the 8.
The rule that 9 on the break wins is fine because it's consistent with the rules of 9 ball. I see lots of restrictions, like about which pocket the 9 can go in on the break. Again, inconsistent with the rules of the game.
It is consistent with the rule that the rack must be frozen as tightly as possible. Particular gaps in the rack make the 9 go directly into one of the bottom corners. The rules of 9 ball did not intend a win based on poor racking.
Something to consider...
KMRUNOUT
Sent from my iPhone using AzBilliards Forums