Crazy ending! What should the ruling be?

TX Poolnut

TX Poolnut

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I guess you have to hit three balls past the center string of the table? He didn't do that.
 
Z

Z-Nole

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I don’t know what the correct ruling is, but I’ve always been taught that if you’re gonna be dumb you’d better be tough. Corey needs to toughen up.
 
A

asbani

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Saturated Fats said:
On this match, Corey made a ball on the 16th break, but didn't notice it. Apparently neither did Shane. Shane then came to the table and finished the rack for the match.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tnVVjoWWl2o

Should Shane have been awarded the win?
Click to expand...

You said corey made a ball and didn't notice it? you think pro's would not notice the corner ball going in? hehe, no my friend, it was just an illegal break, they both very much noticed the 3 ball going in. :)

Some tournys use the rule that either 3 balls should be pocketed or go past the kitchen line, or a combo of either but total of 3 should be accomplished, and in that break, he just made the 3ball he needed 2 more balls to either pocket or go past the kitchen, which didn't happen.

Oh and to answer your final question, yes Shane won, the break was illegal, he should have broken harder.
 
Last edited:
Cornerman

Cornerman

Cue Author...Sometimes
Gold Member
Silver Member
Z-Nole said:
Oh yea, maybe that’s it. Did it come up earlier in the match?
Click to expand...

"A beautiful match from the Leende EUROTOUR in the Netherlands had:
Shane Vanboening / USA vs Corey Deuel / USA - 2019
9 Ball / race to 9 / Alternate Break / Three Points Rule with 9 on the Spot."

It's in the description.
 
td873

td873

C is for Cookie
Silver Member
Cornerman said:
"A beautiful match from the Leende EUROTOUR in the Netherlands had:
Shane Vanboening / USA vs Corey Deuel / USA - 2019
9 Ball / race to 9 / Alternate Break / Three Points Rule with 9 on the Spot."

It's in the description.
Click to expand...
Dangit Fred - always reading the rules and descriptions and whatnot. It's 2020, we're supposed to get offended at everything --> not read the dang ingredients!!!

-td [ha!]
 
Patrick Johnson

Patrick Johnson

Fish of the Day
Silver Member
TX Poolnut said:
That shot on the one ball... Damn son! Even Earl was impressed.
Click to expand...
I think it was a good choice because he had some latitude in where the 1 needed to hit the 8. The carom angle to the pocket is just about right for a rolling half ball hit on the 8, which is the hit with the most room for error on either side.

pj <- trivia r us
chgo
 
Z

Z-Nole

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Cornerman said:
"A beautiful match from the Leende EUROTOUR in the Netherlands had:
Shane Vanboening / USA vs Corey Deuel / USA - 2019
9 Ball / race to 9 / Alternate Break / Three Points Rule with 9 on the Spot."

It's in the description.
Click to expand...

You’re an engineer. Of course you read that stuff! Me, not so much.
 
Z

Z-Nole

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Patrick Johnson said:
I think it was a good choice because he had some latitude in where the 1 needed to hit the 8. The carom angle to the pocket is just about right for a rolling half ball hit on the 8, which is the hit with the most room for error on either side.

pj <- trivia r us
chgo
Click to expand...

I don’t read instructions very well, or ever, but I did see that shot option before Shane hit it.
 
jsp

jsp

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
TX Poolnut said:
That shot on the one ball... Damn son! Even Earl was impressed.
Click to expand...
That was a great shot. And Earl's commentary put a smile on my face...giving tribute to the Magician by saying, "He pulled an Efren Reyes there."
 
M

maha

from way back when
Silver Member
however assuming it was just how you said op. then who would get the win. i believe and in the poolroom after the next opponent has shot then the game goes on from there. its up to the other player to be the referee and see the mistake and make a ruling.

in a tournament i dont know how the ref would rule. he might make the game a do over. but that isnt fair either. or let it stand as both players accepted the table as it was.
 
Cornerman

Cornerman

Cue Author...Sometimes
Gold Member
Silver Member
straightline said:
While it's on this, is there any buzz term for a bad break like uh, bad break?
Click to expand...

Non-conforming or non-compliant, as far as the 3-point rule goes. Some of us try our best not to use the word "illegal," as that suggests a BIH infraction.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top