1990 US Open Sigel & Varner - 5 Inch Pockets

that is a basic true thing most dont understand. people with exceptional abilities in some way would be exceptional at any thing that used those abilities.
except for the elvis thing as his ability doesn't transfer to sports.
 
skogstokig said:
maha is shirking the thread now but the argument that modern players never saw tough conditions and don't have cue power is obviously untrue. that screenshot is from a match 3 years ago but i've seen even worse, with talcum all over the cloth and in piles on the rail. they still shoot lights out..
Click to expand...
This was a match in the Philippines. Carlo and (I assume) Efren. This isn’t a Matchroom event or WPA.

Modern players do not see the same conditions during professional events like the players in the 70’s and 80’s did . That’s a fact. Why any newby want to try to make it sound like that didn’t happen is beyond me.

In the 80s, nobody had a good handle of what good conditions were, so every table, every tournament was different. different pocket size, different cushions, different conditions,. The whole reason Greg Sullivan started Diamond (PBATE) was because there were no standards. You’re all too lucky to not grow up in that period.

If we magically transport Gorst or Filler back to the 80’s, they would also have to adjust their game to the weird conditions, just like anyone today who walked into a bar and tried to play bar pool on the terrible conditions they have there. It’s not like we’re all world champions in a bar room environment when the tables suck. We all have to adjust. But I’m sure Fedor and Joshua could adjust as well as anybody as they are world generational champions. But it’s not like they’re gonna step back there and suddenly dominate because everything was different! All you gotta do is go to any local weird bar to find out how different it is. Can you just? of course you can. But you gotta adjust!
 
Last edited:
markjames said:
if elvis took up pool instead of music and acting, he would have been one of the greats

if the javelin thrower who got the gold medal in the 500BC olympics was playing gorst in nine ball today it would be a close game

if einstein never became a physicist but took up straight pool, his pattern play would have been extraordinary

if efren was born in new york and became a taxi driver, his navigation through traffic troubles in midtown would be legendary
Click to expand...
Definitely not saying that
 
maha said:
didnt say the top new players would not almost immediately adapt to the old conditions. just that its different and you dont need a strong stroke.
Click to expand...

adapt? he grew up on tables like this. do you think if you grow up playing on tables like this (which is rougher than in literally any filmed 1980's US pro match i've seen) you get a "strong stroke"?

not that i give any credence to the notion that modern pro players from any country have weaker strokes than previous pros, but let's follow your logic
 
markjames said:
if elvis took up pool instead of music and acting, he would have been one of the greats

if the javelin thrower who got the gold medal in the 500BC olympics was playing gorst in nine ball today it would be a close game

if einstein never became a physicist but took up straight pool, his pattern play would have been extraordinary

if efren was born in new york and became a taxi driver, his navigation through traffic troubles in midtown would be legendary
Click to expand...
So what's your point??😉
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top