I know this is none of my business, other than it was posted on a public forum. If the shill accusation was made through PM's it was a private matter and the content of PM's should never be quoted or discussed on a public forum. This is why they're called "Private Messages". If Asiadad started a thread calling you a shill, then you'd be justified in publicly demanding an apology. The whole thing could have been handled through PM's, no one knew of the accusation until you made it public. Had you simply ignored the PM, nothing would have come of it. Sorry, I just can't stand it when people air their dirty laundry just for drama effect.