Balabushka on eBay - is it a scam?

plparker1

New member
http://cgi.ebay.com/Balabushka-Fancy-Authentic-Pool-Cue-w-Certificate-60s_W0QQitemZ120183294622QQihZ002QQcategoryZ21212QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

I have read some of the postings about this cue and that it is probably a real deal. If someone wins it, I hope that is true. However, I do have some reservations about the listing that might indicate it is a scam.

1. Of course, a brand new account is always cause for concern.

2. Some minor mistakes that indicate the person who wrote the listing might not be totally familiar with the English language. Misspelled words (colector, synonmys), incorrect capitalization of words, hyphenation of new-york city, improper puncutation.

3. The phone number listed uses periods to separate the area code and number. That is something not usually done in this country.

4. The phone number could be a virtual one that could be located anywhere in the world. I have a Vonage phone account and just checked to see whether I could get a phone number in the 786 area code and they are available with Aventura, Florida listed as one of the cities covered by the area code.

5. When you click on the letter of authenticity from Pete Tascarella, a new window or tab opens with a large picture of the letter. If you right click on the picture of the letter and try to save the picture, you will find that the title of the picture is "Pascarella_Letter122.jpg". The logo at the top of the Tascarella letter could be read wrong by someone not familiar with cues. I don't think that someone who professes to have owned a Balabushka and have taken it to a World Championship would not know how to spell Mr. Tascarella's name properly.

I hope that I am wrong about all this, but in case I am not someone could be out a lot of money. I would certainly recommend that anyone who bids on this cue take all precautions to make sure the transfer of the cue is secure. An escrow agent would be a good solution. If the seller refuses to make such an arrangement, it would be an indication that something could be wrong. Meeting with someone in person to make the transaction could be inadvisable. With this amount of money involved, anything could happen.

I am only posting this because I appreciate many of the pieces of information I have gained while reading this board and I would like to contribute my thoughts on this subject. Again, I hope I am wrong but there are enough points of concern on this eBay listing that I feel I must share my thoughts here.
 
I agree, but if spelling and/or bastardizing the English language was really a concern then one of the world's largest cue dealers probably would never sell a cue. :D In all seriousness, you have made some great points that should be taken to heart. These are all valid concerns and with I am sure that any responsible buyer would make sure they are protected on a transaction of this magnitude (i.e. pick the cue up in person and make payment; COD; through a local third party intermediary; etc.)
 
Why Have a Reserve?

If it were a scam, why have a reserve price? Especially one set over (I feel) the actual value of the cue? To protect his investment?

But let's say it is a scam, complete 100% scam the cue doesn't exist or the guy doesn't have it or he doesn't exist.

1) You win the auction.

2) You pay with PayPal funded by your credit card.

3) The cue is never shipped

4) You dispute the charge with your credit card company for "goods not received"

5) Your credit card suspends the disputed amount from your bill while PayPal "investigates" the claim. 2 months later, after PayPal doesn't respond to your credit card co.,
the suspended amount dissappears.

Where's the loss?

Kevin
 
You want insurance?

igotfelt said:
Is $296.00 for shipping a little on the high side?

The insurance starts to get a little expensive.

Kevin

BTW You don't want to ship something this valuable UPS, FedEx or DHL, they don't sell you real insurance. An item like this must go USPS Registered. You could get it cross-country Registered Priority Insured for 25K for about 100 bucks.
 
It also seems odd that someone who is obviously experienced in listing on ebay would have a zero rating. Sure looks like an account made for a one time sale.
 
Too much paranoia. Nobody with $$ is that stupid

Let's imagine for just a moment any one of us had the the kind of DISPOSABLE income to purchase this cue at whatever price.

1. Unless we are heirs to a throne we probably worked hard to get it.

2. We are smart enough to hang onto it.

3. And we have figured in enough expense to secure the transaction.

In other words, the winner if there is one, is not going to ship off bookoo bucks in any form to the seller without securing his interest.

He will fly down in person with a letter of credit from one of his personal bankers or a cashiers check good at any U.S. bank in Florida or take a few days off to play some golf in Florida and drive down in his Porsche.

Why? Because he/she can. Wouldn't you??

Nobody is so stupid in the high end of the financial spectrum that they are just gonna send off payment on this auction without someone completely in trust, to handle the transaction face to face. They take 3 day golf vacations that cost $3K-5K, $2K to fly down and back and pick up a cue is merely insurance.
 
Maybe he's busy?

our_auctionguy said:
Let's imagine for just a moment any one of us had the the kind of DISPOSABLE income to purchase this cue at whatever price.

1. Unless we are heirs to a throne we probably worked hard to get it.

2. We are smart enough to hang onto it.

3. And we have figured in enough expense to secure the transaction.

In other words, the winner if there is one, is not going to ship off bookoo bucks in any form to the seller without securing his interest.

He will fly down in person with a letter of credit from one of his personal bankers or a cashiers check good at any U.S. bank in Florida or take a few days off to play some golf in Florida and drive down in his Porsche.

Why? Because he/she can. Wouldn't you??

Nobody is so stupid in the high end of the financial spectrum that they are just gonna send off payment on this auction without someone completely in trust, to handle the transaction face to face. They take 3 day golf vacations that cost $3K-5K, $2K to fly down and back and pick up a cue is merely insurance.

Maybe he's busy making all that money and doesn't have the time to fly around the Country for a collectible. Why not just put it on his Platinum AmEx and wait for the seller to perform?

BTW. The gentleman who bought the Gus I offered on eBay for 55K is a member of this forum (I wasn't at the time) and he spoke with me on the phone twice and then just mailed me a cashiers check for the full amount. No muss, no fuss.

Kevin
 
The seller of the Balabushka sent me a couple replies

Dear our_auctionguy,

I am glad that my cue has gotten so much attantion! it is a very special cue, it is not a fraud, it is very real; let me know what the highest bid is in your contest? My cue is one of a kined it deserves this kined of attention.It will be a very sad day when I part with this cue I have it for over 30 years! Sincerely Stu.


- stuscapital46
My only comment is it will be a sad day when I will have to part with this cue that I Owen for over 30 years thanks for the attention my cue is getting & let me know how you make out good luck sincerely, Stu.PS I have been getting calls from over seas I hope the history of this cue stays in the US.
 
Back
Top