Honolulu 8-ball
A friend and I made up a game we call "anything but" (a regular shot).
8-ball by whatever rules float your boat.
The difference being absolutely no "straight-in" shots are allowed. Each and every legally pocketed ball must be made by means of either:
- bank
- combination
- carom/kiss
- kick shot
- some combination of above
Invented during slow bar times wanting to streatch the quarters.
-------------------
Also, in the BCA rules book there is the similar game called Honolulu. Someone breaks. Call any ball in any pocket; score one point per legally pocketed ball; the first player to make eight points wins.
I'm dreaming about/maybe planning on organizing a Honolulu 8-ball tournament. I thought I invented the game, but it looks like great minds think alike!
I'm trying to figure out a good standardized rule set. I'm thinking "ball in hand twice" for balls hit straight in, and "ball in hand three times" if the last ball from a group is hit directly in. I also think it might be fun to allow direct masse shots where there is a clearly obstructed shot.
No kicks or banks off one rail into the pockets adjoining that rail.
Any ball can be hit first, including the eight ball. If any ball is hit, there is no foul (don't need to hit a rail).
If a ball is hit in directly, it is not a foul if any other ball (except the eight ball) is pocketed on the same shot, including the opponent's ball(s). It is also not a foul to hit an opponent's ball directly in.
Don't need to call pockets - you continue your turn, if you legally pocket a ball from your group without committing any fouls.
If you hit in the last ball(s) from your group and also hit the 8 ball in on the same shot, you win - it doesn't matter the order that the balls go in, so long as it's the same shot.
Personally, I find 9 ball kind of boring, and 8 ball gets boring when the players are too highly skilled. Bank pool is OK, but it's pretty technical, and it can't be played on bar tables, and it limits creative strategies. When played on a bar-box, a player with crazy-good pool intuition could beat a great shooter at Honolulu 8 ball, so it opens up a new game to players who have a different skill set than your typical 9-ball expert.
9-ball is a good game for perfectionists, but Honolulu 8-ball is a good game for billiards artists... and for pool players who are running out of quarters at the bar.
Would you (or anyone) have any recommendations to add/subtract from these rules? So far, this rule-set seems to yield the most interesting game, and allows for a lot of creative strategizing that is very different from more traditional games like 9 ball or 8 ball. The easy shots that come up tend to disappear as the game progresses, and there are a lot of chess moves involved, like positioning balls close to pockets to set up combos and caroms on your next shot.
(Yes I know I'm commenting on an 11 year old thread - so sue me).