Could straight pool thrive with a gimmick format?

Matt_H

Member
I create this thread knowing full well that die hard straight pool players will think I'm trying to dilute their beautiful game. I live in the UK and am a UK 9 & 10 ball player currently on a self-imposed hiatus, mainly because I can't afford to replace my warped cues (this should change in the fall).

In the UK straight pool is basically a "drill", a way to kill an hour of a practice session or a way to get in stroke. With no tournaments to speak of the only measure of progress is one's highest run. It looks to have a stronger following in mainland Europe.

14.1 is my favourite disclipline, despite only playing a handfull of sets in my 46 years, and I believe it is too good just to serve as a practice tool. I wonder if an Ultimate Pool-style revamp could boost its popularity. Snooker continues to boom worldwide yet quicker tv-friendly formats such as The Shootout and The 900 have proved popular and hold their own (The Shootout now carries tour ranking points).

While straight pool is often considered to be the purest form of pool it is hardly the most spectator friendly. It must be played on 9 footers, and with bigger pockets used than those in the Appleton v Deuel Predator exhibition. A double-elimination style format could be played under the following conditions:
Best-of-three 30 minute sets.
Set winner determined by reaching target score OR whoever has the lead as time expires (whatever comes first).
20 second shot clock for first 20 minutes of each set, 10 second shot clock thereafter.
Three extensions per player per set.

Will something like this please the pursists? Probably not. But flag football is now an Olympic sport, 3x3 basketball has a world tour while cricket introduced T20 AND The Hundred. They are all shortened or simplified versions of very popular sports. My idea might not elevate straight pool to these levels, but it might get a few more people playing.
 
It must be played on 9 footers
Interesting idea.

In general I don’t like the idea of time limits but with a progressively shorter shot clock it might work avoiding slow walking if a player is far ahead. But one of the cool things about 14.1 is like baseball: you can be down 124-0 and still win with a 125-ball run. Well, maybe you can but I sure can’t lol.

Our local TAP league is experimenting with straight pool on 7’ tables but with 10 balls to help reduce clusters. Still 14 points per rack. I think it’s one point per ball, 2 points for the 5, and 4 points for the 10 (or sumfin like that.)

I like your idea but I am not sure it can be “sold”. Perhaps if you set up a league or tournaments, you can gauge interest.
 
Interesting idea.

In general I don’t like the idea of time limits but with a progressively shorter shot clock it might work avoiding slow walking if a player is far ahead. But one of the cool things about 14.1 is like baseball: you can be down 124-0 and still win with a 125-ball run. Well, maybe you can but I sure can’t lol.

Our local TAP league is experimenting with straight pool on 7’ tables but with 10 balls to help reduce clusters. Still 14 points per rack. I think it’s one point per ball, 2 points for the 5, and 4 points for the 10 (or sumfin like that.)

I like your idea but I am not sure it can be “sold”. Perhaps if you set up a league or tournaments, you can gauge interest.
7' tables are a rare breed in England, maybe limited to SAM coin-ops found in bowling alleys. They cost £1.50 a game so a half decent race to anything isn't cheap. Plus, chavvy kids dressed in black North Face tracksuits and Air Max trainers take 20 minutes to get through a rack of 8 ball.
I 'aint running 125 either, I'd probably offer you a handshake.
 
Last edited:
I’m not keen on aligning with the 900 concept, but I’ve thought about the English Billiards timed format. It keeps the tournament on schedule and if players are playing poorly it brings matches to a merciful end rather than trying to endure two players attempting to compile 500-1000 points in increments of 10 and 12.

The main downside is that if one player builds a commanding lead, the last 20-30 minutes is a bit of a slog since the losing player can’t catch up. Which has led me to wonder if there should be a mercy rule to keep things moving and interesting.

So for 14.1 you could do either 1 or 1.5 hour matches in the group stage, 2 hours in the knock out, and 2.5 or 3 hours or more in the final. It would also theoretically allow for runs greater than 200 depending on how quick they play.
 
Being an old school, life long 14.1 player, and the only game I really play, the one thing that absolutely drives me into orbit when watching matches, is the damned shot clock...especially when that obnoxious warning beeper starts sounding...Straight Pool, is a true game of focus, concentration and strategy, that in my opinion should never have ANY time constraints between shots...it's just counter-intuitive to the very nature of 14.1...
 
Being an old school, life long 14.1 player, and the only game I really play, the one thing that absolutely drives me into orbit when watching matches, is the damned shot clock...especially when that obnoxious warning beeper starts sounding...Straight Pool, is a true game of focus, concentration and strategy, that in my opinion should never have ANY time constraints between shots...it's just counter-intuitive to the very nature of 14.1...
On the other hand.....

I didn't see it -- and I certainly wouldn't have watched the whole thing -- but I believe in one of Charlie Williams' World events, there was a five and a half hour match. I think it was to 150. Worse than one pocket. ;)

If you're going to have a competition, you need to stay on schedule, attract a paying audience, and not drive viewers and players away by boring them to death. Mosconi, Butera, Orcullo, and Shaw have shown us that you don't need 50 seconds per shot.

A game clock like in chess -- not a shot clock -- can solve the snail problem. I think a 20/10 shot clock could still be playable, but it would eliminate maybe a quarter of all players. A problem is that it requires staff to run it.
 
On the other hand.....

I didn't see it -- and I certainly wouldn't have watched the whole thing -- but I believe in one of Charlie Williams' World events, there was a five and a half hour match. I think it was to 150. Worse than one pocket. ;)

If you're going to have a competition, you need to stay on schedule, attract a paying audience, and not drive viewers and players away by boring them to death. Mosconi, Butera, Orcullo, and Shaw have shown us that you don't need 50 seconds per shot.

A game clock like in chess -- not a shot clock -- can solve the snail problem. I think a 20/10 shot clock could still be playable, but it would eliminate maybe a quarter of all players. A problem is that it requires staff to run it.

Yeah, unfortunately I was there. It was SVB vs Max Eberle. Thankfully Max scratched on a side pocket breakshot needing less than a rack (5 balls I think) or we'd have had to endure an 8 hour final match. It was painful.
 
OK how does this format sound.

30 minutes duration with 15 minutes per man. (Use a chess style clock) and if you run out of time, your opponent then gets ten shots without interruption.

9 Ball plus 1 colored ball. Balls set up in a 9 ball diamond with the colored ball on the center spot of the table.

Sink nominated ball is one point.

Any shot you use the cue ball - colored ball - and sink the nominated ball counts as three points.

As soon as a ball in potted, it is respotted. There are always ten balls plus the cue ball on the table.

Sink the cue ball the points made on that break go to your opponent.

Sink the colored ball and you lose all your points in that game.
 
OK how does this format sound.

30 minutes duration with 15 minutes per man. (Use a chess style clock) and if you run out of time, your opponent then gets ten shots without interruption.

9 Ball plus 1 colored ball. Balls set up in a 9 ball diamond with the colored ball on the center spot of the table.

Sink nominated ball is one point.

Any shot you use the cue ball - colored ball - and sink the nominated ball counts as three points.

As soon as a ball in potted, it is respotted. There are always ten balls plus the cue ball on the table.

Sink the cue ball the points made on that break go to your opponent.

Sink the colored ball and you lose all your points in that game.

As well as your explanation being very confusing, it also bears no resemblance to straight pool that I can see.

What exactly does (what I highlighted above) mean? If you both get 15 min. then when time is up you stop. How can you run out of time?
 
Being an old school, life long 14.1 player, and the only game I really play, the one thing that absolutely drives me into orbit when watching matches, is the damned shot clock...especially when that obnoxious warning beeper starts sounding...Straight Pool, is a true game of focus, concentration and strategy, that in my opinion should never have ANY time constraints between shots...it's just counter-intuitive to the very nature of 14.1...
Well, straight pool requires much, much, much, much, much, much less thought than chess, but at least in chess, they are not inclined to use the "it's compicated" argument to accommodate/forgive lethargically slow play.

It was the pace of play that, more than anything, caused the end of the straight pool era in the mid-1980s. Many players had already shifted most of their attentions to 9ball, even by then. Pool had its first shot at major coverage on TV (yes, I know it had occasionally been on Wide World of Sports) and because of its lethargic pace, straight pool would not do for TV.

Some of the purists at the time suggested that any game selected for TV would have to be call shot but for two reasons, their voices were drowned out: 1) call shot made any pool game slower, and b) snooker, a game not requiring the calling of shots, was starting to make it big in the UK. Nine ball was a fast game without call shot and it fit the bill at the time.

The purists can have it any way they like, but its long-term inability to address slow play is what caused straight pool to gradually fall off the map as a competitive discipline.
 
Well, straight pool requires much, much, much, much, much, much less thought than chess, but at least in chess, they are not inclined to use the "it's compicated" argument to accommodate/forgive lethargically slow play.

It was the pace of play that, more than anything, caused the end of the straight pool era in the mid-1980s. Many players had already shifted most of their attentions to 9ball, even by then. Pool had its first shot at major coverage on TV (yes, I know it had occasionally been on Wide World of Sports) and because of its lethargic pace, straight pool would not do for TV.

Some of the purists at the time suggested that any game selected for TV would have to be call shot but for two reasons, their voices were drowned out: 1) call shot made any pool game slower, and b) snooker, a game not requiring the calling of shots, was starting to make it big in the UK. Nine ball was a fast game without call shot and it fit the bill at the time.

The purists can have it any way they like, but its long-term inability to address slow play is what caused straight pool to gradually fall off the map as a competitive discipline.
I can make a cue ball with an actuator inside of it. You get 30 seconds before the actuator moves a weight to unbalance itself.

Take as much time as you want, but the slower players get wobbly cue balls that don't roll straight.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sjm
I can make a cue ball with an actuator inside of it. You get 30 seconds before the actuator moves a weight to unbalance itself.

Take as much time as you want, but the slower players get wobbly cue balls that don't roll straight.
Bring it on!
 
I like this idea, especially since 14.1 just isn't pulling in new players like it used to. I love the game, and honestly I'm a pretty slow player myself when I'm working out patterns, but I still think a timer would help a lot. My idea is similar to what @CageyCraigey brought up, though I'm not 100% sure if this is exactly what they had in mind.

The way I'm picturing it is basically a chess clock where both players get equal time, say 15 minutes each. You alternate innings like normal and your clock runs down while you're at the table. Once your 15 minutes are up, you can't score points anymore. The only exception is if you're in the middle of a run when time runs out, you still get to finish that run.

After your run ends, the other player keeps going until their clock runs out too. Even after your time is gone, you still come back to the table whenever they miss. You won't get any points, so you're either playing safeties or running balls just to take away their layout and leave them tough, but to prevent wasting time, it can be a 30 second shot clock for you. That way there's still real strategy even for the player whose clock is out, and overall the matches stay a lot shorter and more interesting.
 
A game clock like in chess -- not a shot clock -- can solve the snail problem. I think a 20/10 shot clock could still be playable, but it would eliminate maybe a quarter of all players. A problem is that it requires staff to run it.
I think a chess-like clock is the way to go if a clock is implemented. Start with, for example, 10 minutes + 5 seconds per shot for each player. Once a player's clock runs out, they can't score anymore, they can still foul, pocketing any ball is treated the same as pocketing the cueball, and they get only one shot per inning, with a ~10 second shot clock. Presumably, the player whose clock runs out first would play safe every inning once their time ran out.

Unlike chess, a players clock would not start immediately after their opponents's clock stops. As long as any ball on the table is in motion, neither player's clock would be running. This could be problematic with only two people playing. A third person or AI automation would be helpful.
 
I think a chess-like clock is the way to go if a clock is implemented. Start with, for example, 10 minutes + ...
There are simpler, easier ways to use a game clock for 14.1. I've described before how game clocks were used in two 14.1 leagues around here. For more info, search on "chess" in my posts.
 
Back
Top