Cue warps in transit, who's responsible?

Rocket354

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
I recently had a transaction on here that has had some issues. Nothing about people being dishonest, but exactly as the title states, the cue warped in transit.

To avoid having people give potentially biased opinions (unintentional or not), I'm leaving out who's on either end of the transaction.

Person A purchases a cue from Person B across the country. Person B receives payment then ships the cue, which he knows to be straight. He ships it USPS priority in a sturdy box, but without insurance.

The postoffice gets the cue across the country in two days. However, there's an issue with delivery at the destination (which shouldn't have been) and they return the cue to Person B. Persons A and B talk about this and decide that the cue should just be shipped again to the same address, and Person A talks to his local P.O. to make sure this time it gets delivered.

Person B reships it, this time insured, and the cue arrives now at its destination without a hitch. Person A receives the cue, it looks great, and takes it out to shoot with it. He rolls it across the table and...the shaft is warped. The butt is fine.

Each party is trustworthy. Person B really did ship a straight cue, and Person A really did receive a warped cue.

So, who's responsible? And has anyone had any luck with the USPS getting them to pay an insurance claim for a warped cue?
 
Rocket354 said:
I recently had a transaction on here that has had some issues. Nothing about people being dishonest, but exactly as the title states, the cue warped in transit.

To avoid having people give potentially biased opinions (unintentional or not), I'm leaving out who's on either end of the transaction.

Person A purchases a cue from Person B across the country. Person B receives payment then ships the cue, which he knows to be straight. He ships it USPS priority in a sturdy box, but without insurance.

The postoffice gets the cue across the country in two days. However, there's an issue with delivery at the destination (which shouldn't have been) and they return the cue to Person B. Persons A and B talk about this and decide that the cue should just be shipped again to the same address, and Person A talks to his local P.O. to make sure this time it gets delivered.

Person B reships it, this time insured, and the cue arrives now at its destination without a hitch. Person A receives the cue, it looks great, and takes it out to shoot with it. He rolls it across the table and...the shaft is warped. The butt is fine.

Each party is trustworthy. Person B really did ship a straight cue, and Person A really did receive a warped cue.

So, who's responsible? And has anyone had any luck with the USPS getting them to pay an insurance claim for a warped cue?

The seller is always responsible for any item until it is delivered, and excepted by the buyer. No difference if you are dealing with a company / Corporation or an individual. This is the Chance a seller takes when items are shipped, especially cues during Hot weather. I recommend that when shipping cues during the summer or winter Over Night is the way to go, because there will be no issue. The only other thing is the shipper, if the package arrived undamaged the shipper is not at fault, and can not be held responsible unless the item was suppose to be shipped in a Temperature controlled environment and it obviously was not.

Hope this helps!!!
 
The shipper is responsible. Thereafter, the person that got the insurance I believe has to make the claim. Thereafter, the person that would've denied insurance would be responsible (not applicable in your case). I believe B has to make the claim since they purchased the insurance.

Proving warpage due to shipping would be hard to prove without some sort of extra red tape. Something like this cue was just received from the maker/refinisher/blah blah (somebody qualified to make that call) and was deemed to be straight and true.

I have had luck with both USPS and the USPO when it comes to claims. Good luck to you. Fortunately, it was just the shaft...
 
I am in agreement with manwon - sorry to hear it happened but I would expect the seller to refund full amount on request. good luck!
 
Sorry, I gotta go against the grain here and say neither is at fault. It's basically a 13mm dowel rod. Warping of something like that is a danger that exists. I don't think there are many cue makers out there that guarantees their cues against warping. It's a piece of wood and that's what wood does, it warps.

And before anyone shoots me down about cue makers guaranteeing their cues all you have to do is read the fine print in the Blue Book, for example Paul Mottey cues description says:

"Mottey cues are guaranteed indefinitely against manufacturing defects that are not a result of warpage or abuse."

This line is in the majority of the major cuemakers descriptions. I'd feel bad for the buyer but there's not really anything anyone can do about it. And you might as well hold you breath and count to a kajillion if you think the Post Office will assume responsibility for that, insurance or not.
MULLY
 
Last edited:
It is the sellers responsibillty to deliver the cue in the exact condition as described prior to delivery....The buyer purchased the cue based on the sellers description....there is no gray area here.....
 
This is the whole reason why in the summer you should use Express Mail only. $10.00 difference in shipping can avoid a lot of headaches. I will go even further I do slow down quite a bit on my buying/trading in the summer.
 
mullyman said:
Sorry, I gotta go against the grain here and say neither is at fault. It's basically a 13mm dowel rod. Warping of something like that is a danger that exists. I don't think there are many cue makers out there that guarantees their cues against warping. It's a piece of wood and that's what wood does, it warps.

And before anyone shoots me down about cue makers guaranteeing their cues all you have to do is read the fine print in the Blue Book, for example Paul Mottey cues description says:

"Mottey cues are guaranteed indefinitely against manufacturing defects that are not a result of warpage or abuse."

This line is in the majority of the major cuemakers descriptions. I'd feel bad for the buyer but there's not really anything anyone can do about it. And you might as well hold you breath and count to a kajillion if you think the Post Office will assume responsibility for that, insurance or not.
MULLY

Good post Mully, I certainly do not agree with it completely. But it easier for the sell to require over night shipment and full insurance, whether the buyer agrees or not. In fact I would go as far as to say that, this should be factored into the sellers sale price of the cue. This way, unless the cue is damaged in shipment, and that means the box is damaged, and the shipping company notes this damage for insurance purposes the seller is always the responsible party. Even when damage occurs since the seller shipped the cue, he is also responsible to refund the buyers money and handle the insurance requirements.

The seller my opinion has all of the responsibility in any transaction, until the buyer receives and inspects their purchase, and agrees that it is as described.

Have a good night Mully!
 
how long has it been since you've had the cue? let it rest a couple of days and it might work itself back to normal.

I had this happen to me a couple of yrs ago. The cue came to Texas from Minnisota, during the summer. 60 degrees in MN, 100 degrees in TX. It only took 2-3 days priority shipped, but the shaft showed up very warped. But i Knew why, so i let it rest for a week, and it straightened itself out.

A cuemaker told me a long time ago that if wood is gonna warp you cant do anything about it. But if you have a good piece of wood thats not meant to warp, then if it warps under extreme conditions, there is a great chance that it will straighten itself out after a while.
And thats exactly what happened in my situation.
 
Because of the USPS snafu, there was basically 11 days the cue was in transit, as it had to go cross country three times.

I think waiting a few days is a good idea.
 
Nevermind.. I'm too tired to write it up. heh

Seller gives buyer money back and your left to decide on how the shipping costs will work between you two. Without going into further detail on that.. Basically sums it up..
 
Last edited:
The seller is responsible for making sure the buyer is satisfied (as always), but I doubt the insurance would pay out on a warped shaft if there is no obvious damage to the box that shows it was mishandled. Believe it or not, shafts warping somewhat over a long trip like that fairly common. We've received cues shipped from afar where the shafts looked warped. In a few cases, pretty bad, and then after sitting for a few months in their new climate the shafts straightened out to where they rolled virtually straight. Cues are made of wood and they tend to move....especially shafts.
 
snowmon34 said:
It is the sellers responsibillty to deliver the cue in the exact condition as described prior to delivery....The buyer purchased the cue based on the sellers description....there is no gray area here.....


You know...when you consider this fact alone...you come to realize that in any transaction...the only individual whom is ever at risk...is the seller. The buyer is protected beginning to end by the law. That being said...the ONLY way for a buyer to truly protect himself is to do the following:

1) Insure the cue FULL value. No short cuts.
2) Insist on overnight delivery at the purchasers expense. The less time in transit, the less time cue is exposed to the elements.
3) Extensively photography the cue prior to shipment, and where possible, take a short mpeg video (available on nearly all digital cameras) of the cue rolling on a table.

These 3 things ensure that the cue left your house as described...thus keeping seller integrity intact. It also covers the sellers ass...whose is the only one on the line. These, going forward, will be my standards. Those who disagree with them will be free not to do business with me. I also do not ship cues internationally...ivory or not.
 
Insurance Will Not Cover It....

The Loss Is On The Seller, Not The Buyer.

The Buyer Purchased A Straight Cue, The One He Got Was Warped, Therefore The Deal Is No Good.

It Sucks, But That Is Part Of Selling Cues. I Just Lost 500 Dollars, And A 250 Dollar Shaft In A Deal, Trying To Make It Right For The Buyer. That's The Way This Stuff Goes Some Time.
 
Back
Top