How much do you think the Revo improved your game - 1 ball, like you mentioned earlier? That’s a massive difference. What was your previous cue, and what specifically about the Revo makes you better? I’m sorry, but I’m skeptical, and I’d like to know the reason that you play better with one cue vs. another - what are the properties of the cue that translate into better play.
I want to have good equipment, but I never thought about it like “playing with this cue, I’m a ball better than playing with that cue.” Sure, if the cue is broken or the tip is falling off, that makes a difference. And yes some cars are faster than others, I’m not saying there is no difference between any equipment in any domain lol. But between two decent, modern cues, like a wood Predator vs. Revo? I’m really skeptical that it can make someone play perceptibly better.
There are probably a lot of factors that could make this true I imagine. A slightly imperfect hit on a shot, accidentally imparting some left/right, creating some deflection. A non LD shaft could deflect enough to miss the shot. Is the guy better really? He is the person who made the poor contact. He was able to make the shot though and continue his run. Even if this is a relatively rare occurrence in said person's game, it is feasible he could be more consistent with a LD shaft in general.
One thing the Revo made me start doing is playing the cue ball closer to center. With the less deflection it certainly seems like my consistency has improved and I can still move the cue ball very well. With the amount of shots I have poorly adjusted though because of years of wood shafts, any accuracy gained is probably a wash until I really get used to the stick. It is hard to say if my overall accuracy has increased.
One thing is has definitely improved is my ability to hold the cue ball on the break while really putting some power into the shot. (I think it is just a function of LD, even when I really slam the balls and miss my contact point, the deflection is not so bad that my hit misses the spot I was aiming badly.) Before I would lose the cue ball often, occasionally even thinning the head ball and flying the cue. While I don't keep actual stats, it has been a huge improvement in my game. Squatting the cue and making a ball very often gives me much better chances, especially compared to the times I used to break them well and give my opponent BIH.
One thing people have touched on is confidence. That could be another factor. If due to the reasons stated above, I feel more confident, I will likely play better. Seems like there could definitely be merit to this, I know when I am stroking very smooth and free and seeing the ball well, the game because much easier.
All of these things are flaws in my game that I am continually working to improve, but the shaft has definitely made me see positive results. I imagine that if I had never played with a wooden shaft, some of the mental adjustments for a long drawing english shot wouldn't exist.
Do I think it has realistically made my game better? Only slightly for the reasons stated, but they are problems I can and will overcome anyway. Having a shaft that I don't clean, don't repair dings, and don't have to test for warping coupled with what I assume will be a longer lifetime than any wooden cue makes it worth spending a few extra dollars. I have had a shaft warp, and I have had a shaft split. Those two sticks alone were close enough to the price of a REVO that buying one seems to be a no brainer. If 10,000 hours later it is still a quality product that has done everything it says it is supposed to in terms of durability, then a nickel per hour seems totally reasonable.