I enjoy DannyD and BillyI in the booth, together or apart. Knowledge, perspective and humor.
I don't care if a commentator makes the wrong call; they've got no better view of the table than we do. Does the 3-ball pass the 7-ball? Sometimes it looks like "no way" so the commentator bases his comments on that...but it turns out it does pass.
The only current players who do well in the booth are Earl, Schmidt and Deuel (I'm sure there are others who I just haven't heard). But most of the current players (i.e. played in the tournament, but were eliminated) spend most of their time making excuses about why they lost. Ya know what? I don't want to hear it, especially every five minutes, on-and-on-and-on. It gets old real fast. (Lots of respect for Deuel, who usually says "I played well. He just played better.")