I do believe the first It's George Cases were real Leathers.
When I visited Mike Roberts and Bill Schick in Sherevport, (Back in '93?)they had the case makers in the next room from the cuemakers.. They had Elephant, Ostrich, Eel, and Smooth leather.. Blue Ring Tail Lizard, the Brown lizard.. etc..
I bought 2 Smooth Black Leather cases.
These were the 1st generation It's Georges'.
The one on e-bay photo looks like the old ones( short lip on the end caps and SS Rivits).. Could be real...
If anybody knows Don Weathersby (Spelling) ask him, He was with Mike and Bill in those days..
Wasn't Mike going to start up the George case again?? A few year back??