That shot can be made with any stroke type or any shaft type, with appropriate aim. A swoop or swipe stroke is no more effective at applying english than any other stroke type with equivalent aim. For more info, see the
swoop/swipe stroke resource page.
Dave,
You suggest that "Old Timers", players like Tom Ross, effectively use the swoop stroke but Jayson is a spring chicken. I'm just wondering how many other SPRING CHICKENS use an effective swoop stroke and whether or not you are missing some of the benefits to a swoop stroke? If young guns like Jayson are using it, can there be some benefit that you haven't discovered?
I think the swoop/swipe stroke is something many people tend to do naturally, but what comes naturally isn't always the best approach. For example, significant elbow drop, wrist flick, grip tightening during the stoke, and "body english" also come naturally to some good players, but that doesn't suggest these approaches offer inherent advantages. I have to admit that I swope/swipe on occasion (and drop my elbow more than I should on certain shots, and lift my head early, and fail to have my vision center perfectly aligned, and tighten my grip a little on some shots) by accident when I am being sloppy or lazy with my technique, because these things come naturally to me also (i.e., I do them if I haven't practiced properly in a while, or if I am careless). Regardless, anybody can master any technique (or lack of technique) with enough practice. But to me, the real question is whether the swoop/swipe stroke provides useful advantages not achievable with a potentially more-reliable and more-consistent straight stroke. After much analysis, experimentation and observation over many years, I am totally convinced the answer is no. I am also aware that not everybody agrees with me.
As outlined on the
resource page, a swoop/swipe stroke can offer advantages to some people, and those people can use a swoop/swipe stroke effectively, especially if it comes naturally to them; however, it is no more effective than a straight stroke, which will be much more accurate and consistent for most people (with the same amount of practice). I think most people (even many swoopers) who carefully read the entire
swoop/swipe stroke resource page and try the experiment described and demonstrated will agree with me. Tom Ross agreed with me after we spent lots of time on this question. Did that make him stop using his swoop/swipe stroke? No, because that is what he had practiced for 30 years, and he was good at it. However, he or I would certainly not recommend it to a student who hadn't already spent many years mastering it.
Regards,
Dave