We have competition that is heavily APA. APA players who wanted to play out of our room were forbidden to. A few teams quit based on principle.
Our room has 90 percent of the old timers and the better big table players. It's a room like days gone by. When guys want to improve, they get off the small tables and play better players, with or without handicaps. Beating a housewife just isn't the same. Pool rooms should have a hierarchy based on ability on the table.
You pretty much personify why pool is (arguably) dying in the U.S. Your views defy logic. If you want pool to grow, you want more people to play. Leagues are the perfect way to get new players to play. You're just bashing APA because you don't like the tactics of some local APA guy and it's hurting your pool hall business. Don't wrap it up into "what's good or bad for pool", because you don't seem to know about that.