Is this a Southwest?

JCIN said:
I get a kick out of the dude calling himself a collector and having what appears to be a real SW but he isnt for sure about this one.LOL

It could be one.....go ahead and bid in just in case. Funny.
\


It appears he is a collector in the finest tradition of PT Barnum. Collecting suckers money at the gate!
 
From the seller:

First of all, I have an extensive knowledge of cues. Last night was the first i'd heard of tai-can cues, and i was told it is a new company making SW look alikes. This cue is old. I own 3 SW cues and there is no difference between the others and the one listed
 
Hal said:
From the seller:

First of all, I have an extensive knowledge of cues. Last night was the first i'd heard of tai-can cues, and i was told it is a new company making SW look alikes. This cue is old. I own 3 SW cues and there is no difference between the others and the one listed


So he owns the only 3 cored SW's ever made?
 
AngryPanda said:
The guy claims he is a collector. how could he not know what he originally bought. Gotta wonder

He gave it away himself with the use of the word "possible"... and the fact that there is no reserve on the auction.
 
Confusing as hell. He states the cue on the right is the one for sale, but shows the one on the left as the for sale piece.

The 'bottom' pic, the one on the left is definitely wrong. The inner borings and dimensions are all wrong from what I can tell, and it looks sloppy as hell.

The brass pin is also very bright for a pre-date as is the flat face of the wood within the Jcollar. The gap at the bottom of the wrap is suspect as well.

Yeah, he's never heard of TaiCan cues, until he found out this one is a fake...
 
Last edited:
This guy should be reported to ebay for a bogus listing...As pointed out he used the word possible to cover his ass, but its clear the lister is purposely misleading the ebay community.....I feel sorry for the person with the opening bid, but than again is the bid legit?
 
Salamander said:
Looks like the seller has reeled in a sucker.

This is probably why the seller selected the private bidder auction. That way no one can alert his fish.
 
This is what I believe to be a pre-date Southwest cue. I own a few and this has the same ringwork, pin, and feel of my others. I included a picture of it with one of my others and as you can see they are the same. It has a grained ebony forearm with 6 tulipwood points. The wrap is black with white specks. One shaft has a good amount of wear and one has almost none. I have too many cues right now and need to get rid of a few. Check out my other auctions!

Lol. Too bad for the buyer that he decided to keep the real southwests.
 
Last edited:
Southwest

Hey I know this guy, and I'm in no way saying this is a SW, but he does collect cues. He isn't as flaky as he's being made out to be. Maybe he got the bad end of a deal on this cue before, I don't know, but I will ask him when I see him. He does have a few Black Boars and other high end cues, so he should have known better before he bought this one. At least he isn't calling it a SW and asking 2k for it. I do know that if someone buys it they will get it without having to involve the police as he isn't the least bit shady.

Jay
 
JJsooted said:
Hey I know this guy, and I'm in no way saying this is a SW, but he does collect cues. He isn't as flaky as he's being made out to be. Maybe he got the bad end of a deal on this cue before, I don't know, but I will ask him when I see him. He does have a few Black Boars and other high end cues, so he should have known better before he bought this one. At least he isn't calling it a SW and asking 2k for it. I do know that if someone buys it they will get it without having to involve the police as he isn't the least bit shady.

Jay

At the very least he is making a STRONG insinuation that it is a Southwest, who sells a cue without finding out what it is?, especially if he thinks it might be a SW, makes no sense, if it is a SW he is losing a ton of money and if it isn't he is gaining a pissed off customer.
 
bigshooter said:
At the very least he is making a STRONG insinuation that it is a Southwest, who sells a cue without finding out what it is?, especially if he thinks it might be a SW, makes no sense, if it is a SW he is losing a ton of money and if it isn't he is gaining a pissed off customer.
Well, you are correct. I am not supporting him, just saying that he is legit in the sense that if you pay for it, you will get it. I dont belileve it to be a SW either.
 
The pic's are bad, but it sdosent look like a SW to me, the joint, pin dimensions look to be off a bit and everything else that has been said here I agree with, Some body got screwed or is about to get screwed. Its a bad deal no matter what.
 
knock off, you might get $400 with some not so great pictures. real, your guranteed to get many times that so why not send it off to laurie. wonder if he did send it off and if it is not a southwest he is losing no money by not telling anyone and the authentication is paid for now.
 
Well, it sold for $610. I've been communicating with the seller from the start of the auction. He could never explain to me why he would list what he believed to be a cue potentially worth $2500-$3000 for an opening bid of just $400, just so he wouldn't have to send it to Laurie to have it authenticated. He said that his wife was complaining that he had too many cues and had to get rid of some. Right, that really sound convincing, doesn't it. Tai-Can cue, I'd bet. I've gone on eBay HK and ordered a couple of them. Both are SW knock offs. One is a duplicate of a wrapless SW. This thing has some of the prettiest birds eye maple. I'll post some pics when they come. Maybe my wife will pester me to sell them, since I have too many cues. PS They don't sell for $150 in Hong Kong, but $335 + shipping.
Regards,
Dr. C
 
I've seen a few of these cues listed before. Think they are called Tai-Can or something like that. Good looking cues for around the $225 area new.

Added:
Nobody would list the cue for $400 with no reserve if they really thought it was a SW.. They would most likely send it in to Laurie for $50 and find out for sure. Unless they already knew. Then that type of person would list it as a possible for $400. :-)
 
Last edited:
Back
Top