I always chuckle a little at these threads. If you can't get the cue in your hands to try it out, you'll never know if it's for you or not (just my opinion there). All of the makers you mentioned make excellent cues, and since I don't know your playing style, or what games you play, or how often, or on what kind of table, or in what conditions, I can't recommend any one over the other. I loved my Capone and one of the two Scruggs I owned, had a Frey which was nice but not for me.
I guess what I'm saying is, all factors must be considered, and as such, I'd have to recommend the cheapest option that fits your requirements (looks, playing, availability). Why spend a mint if you're not even sure which you'd like?
-s