Recently hit a Pro and it is a sweet shaft. Crisp feel and fairly LD.
I think you made a mistake by cancelling your order so fast. Opinions are like....everyone had one. I have 2 McDermott's in my house with warped shafts. The only McDermott's I've ever had. I bought one for my wife and one for my brother around 5 years ago. I called the them and without the original receipts from the authorized dealer they would do nothing for me. Now I have two McDermott butts if anyone is interested. I've been using Meucci's since the late 80's. I have not owned any from the 95-present time frame. When I used to deal with Meucci at that time they repaired everything, no questions asked. I guess as confirmed by Bob's son who had a post here in the past there was a lot of quality control problems starting in the mid 90's. If you are used to the hit of a good pre dot Meucci, you'll never change your cue. A few years ago I went to a Predator P2 for one year. I just couldn't adjust. Recently I bought 2 84-6's. One for my collection and one for use. I couldn't be happier. There were definitely some inlay and ferrule problems but once you get use to the hit of a good Meucci, it's hard to ever change.
Know this is an old thread a and all, just want to put my 2 cents.
I have a meucci 21st -2 century cue with a black dot shaft. Bought it a few years ago, liked it, eventually changed to a p3. Well, the p3 got all weird on me and I lost something like 8 or 10 straight matches. So I decided to give the new pro shaft a try from budget billiards, they sent me a match for my cue with an ultra skin medium. Played lights out, loving the ultraskin, none of that glazing problems I had with kamui clear. Something was still missing so I attached the balance rite. Since then I have a few tournament wins. All I have to complain about are the cosmetics, finish wore down, cracks appearing in the sealed linen section, also turned the white part an ugly shade greenish. It's beat to hell, looks like a mess, but it's my shooter. The feel is not like any other cue, kind of flexible like, give it a shot, might love it like me or hate it