Nice Palmer

Its those things that make you go hmm hmm hmm ..

Anytime I see that a classic old time cue has been totally/partially restored, not saying that it is, but, there is too much room in my mind that it’s a replica as, in this day and age, there are skilled enough makers with knowledge/materials and experience to bring it off. Why does someone totally refinish/rewrap or alter the original patina of a cue that is from a certain era right before they go to sell it? You see what happens in the real world of antique collecting(Antiques Road Show for instance) when someone alters in any way a collectable? The price plunges dramatically. The one’s who verify the authenticity of a cue by providing paperwork are the ones with the resources/experience/knowledge to replicate a cue, not saying that they do. Irregardless of what anyone might think /say or print otherwise, I shy away paying the price of original cue prices from cues that have been in anyway-touched up/shafts replaced/restored etc. The ferrule appears too short. No offense to the seller.
 
That's a great cue !! That's the first one I can recall seeing with the snowflakes. It's a neat look. :smile: Not sure about it realistically pulling 5 figures to end it, though. I agree with 'canwin'. The butt cap doesn't look to be the correct material unless it's just a bad pic. The original ones always seem to pull the biggest money and the historical sales on those has been in the 5-6k range. We'll see how the auction progresses. Any Palmer fan would love to have it....a special version of the 'supreme' is really the nutz !!
 
Maybe

canwin said:
Anytime I see that a classic old time cue has been totally/partially restored, not saying that it is, but, there is too much room in my mind that it?s a replica as, in this day and age, there are skilled enough makers with knowledge/materials and experience to bring it off. Why does someone totally refinish/rewrap or alter the original patina of a cue that is from a certain era right before they go to sell it? You see what happens in the real world of antique collecting(Antiques Road Show for instance) when someone alters in any way a collectable? The price plunges dramatically. The one?s who verify the authenticity of a cue by providing paperwork are the ones with the resources/experience/knowledge to replicate a cue, not saying that they do. Irregardless of what anyone might think /say or print otherwise, I shy away paying the price of original cue prices from cues that have been in anyway-touched up/shafts replaced/restored etc. The ferrule appears too short. No offense to the seller.

IF it was a Balabuska or Gus, or even my old Rambow, I would agree. But alot of the times these middle of the road (in terms of value) "classic" cues, are pretty rough and frankly not attractive.

IMO refinishing a truely unattractive cue into a "restored" cue is a better option in some cases.

I have sent a number of cues to Scot at Proficient to refinish. He always does a nice job. I asked him what cues does he refinish the most. PALMERS.

Why? I think there are several reasons. One is Scots location in Pennsyvania, secondly is the age of those cues, it is about time for them to need some work, and finally these cues were kept as "collectables".

Ken
 
I agree that for the upper echelon original classics Balabushkas, G. Szams, Paradises, etc. that they best be left in original condition even if they show damage or wear so as to get a better basis to verify the authenticity/appraisal of it. Thx for clarifying.
 
Last edited:
Great looking cue. Scott at Sherbine did a great job. Lacking a second shaft is a little painful, but Rubino could rectify that situation in a hurry. Not a "standard" model 20. I like that, but someone looking for the true catalog example may not.

JV
 
Back
Top