Royce,
Thanks for your reply. I just want everyone to know that you have been a great guy to deal with over the years. The first time I ever spoke to you was maybe a year after OB got started. You must have talked to me for almost an hour about wood!! You clearly have a passion for your business!
So...what I was really asking about is not the height of the collar but the thickness. First off, I definitely think *threading* the collar on is the way to go. Much better mechanical connection. I'm talking about this: say you are looking at the face of the joint. You would see a black phenolic circle about 0.840" in diameter. Inside this circle would be a smaller circle of wood, and inside that would be the hole the pin goes in. What I noticed is that a little while back, the ratio of collar to wood increased. I suppose if you are threading them, you need a bit of meat there to work with. However, on the new Plus shafts, it seems this has increased even more, to the point that the entire face of the joint appears to be phenolic.
I'm sure this is physically stronger. A part of me thinks it is best, however, to have as much wood to wood contact in the joint. I don't honestly have a scientific reason for this except my experience I related in my previous post. Given my experience so far, I'm sure there is a good reason for it. Just curious...my perception is that there are basically 3 steps to this change: original OB shafts, later model original shafts, and now the plus shafts. It seems from pictures like 3 different thicknesses. It sounds like you are telling me there are only 2. If this is the case, then perhaps the picture is just throwing me off a bit. In any case, I would strongly prefer a threaded collar!!
Thanks again for the info and any further clarification you can provide. I am dying to get one of the new Pro Pluses ASAP!!!
KMRUNOUT
(Kerry McAuliffe...so you know who you are talking to!)