Do you think is is better to core before or after the nose piece is spliced? It seems that the act of coring an already spliced nose piece may itself produce weaknesses that may show up in the future. Where as gluing up a nose piece with the core before splicing will be safer. The added points will intersect with the nose piece as well as the core in an interlocking manner making it a more integrated unit, not just a core and a sleeve.
I don't understand how coring afterwards would produce any weaknesses. Of course, I'm assuming accurate fits & proper gluing procedures.
On the other hand, it can be argued that a solid core with a decorative sleeve will hit more solidly & predictably than if V-grooved after coring.
And, coring afterwards allows good results with otherwise inadvisable combinations. For example, I used veneered holly points in an amboyna burl forearm. Not sure I'd want to try it the other way.
Or, it allows you to shed weight in an ebony forearm with ebony points.
I see plenty of valid reasons to do it this way & have yet to see a reason not to.
Not entirely, a half splice is a splice and when assembled into a handle it could even be argued it is more stable then a full splice. Now panographed points are another story, they are inlays and it could be argued they actually weaken the butt. I believe this was the opinion of Burton Spain.
Your right, "splice" implies joining pieces together such as, "Splice two pieces of rope together". That is not what is taking place in the construction on a short splice nose piece. It is an assembly of pieces.Not exactly, it is a lamination masquerading as a splice. A splice, whether
of wood, audio tape, film, or genes, is in fact, defined as joining two pieces
together end-to-end.
Nobody ever called a cue full spliced untill people used the term half splice.
As for inlays weakening the butt, I've heard that opinion, but never from
anyone who offered any data to back it up. So I consider it to be just
another case of "womans intuition".
As usual, YMMV, and probably will.
Dale