athecat,
I have not hit all the cues on the list so I am not able to make any comparisons, but I play with one of Ernie's original designs that I've owned for over 40 years so I can talk a little about Ginacues. I can tell you it is the best playing cue - for me-that I've ever put to a cue ball and I grew up in Chicago back when Rambows and Balabushkas were plentiful and I've hit many of them. I would assume that a Gina today is at least as good.
So put it this way, I would not drop him for the list. And that's without considering the collectability factor. Besides, you live just over the hill from Ernie's shop so you really could have a good interaction with the maker during the design and construction and end up with a cue truly custom made for you. Certainly you could meet with him and handle some of the sticks he has in the shop. You will not be disappointed.
DogsPlayingPool