So, in a nutshell, JFLO rcvd a shaft that was "loose", most likely from being cross threaded. Thus, JFLO sent it back, and JIm says not only will I fix it, but will build you another shaft. How am I doing thus far?
And then JFLO gets the cue back, and there is only ONE shaft, NOT two as promised. And the ONE has a "roll".
One that I would NOT be to pleased with from a custom cuemaker... heck, my Players that I use as house cues for my friends/family in my basement don't roll like that, and that's after being in my basement the last 10 years.
So, the solution is pretty simple. Jim owes ONE shaft to JFLO, and a straight one would be nice. Thus, JFLO would have the 2 shafts he was promised and at least one of them is very straight and would most likely satisfy JFO. JFLO can use the "bad" shaft in the dive bars, and just be a needed back up.
So, how about Jim. One shaft, a tad "smoother" now, and you are good to go, and JFLO is back to being a happy customer that he should be, and snowman will be happy as well that you did this, and future customers will see you step up to the plate, which many in the past here refused to do.
C'mon, lets get this done, it's not personal, it's business. I've heard some good things about you and only two negative things... this is the second negative thing I've heard, eventually the reputiation is won or lost through perception, not reality sometimes.