Relaxation techniques during a pool match?

...just "notice" your breathing, feel the temperature of your breath going in and out while you observe the cue ball....this is actually a high form of meditation and will put you into a zone if you do it properly. It will, like anything else, take practice, and patience.

The easiest method of meditation is indeed breathing but people seem to think it's an instant fix. Like anything else, it requires practice, in this case at least 2-3 weeks of intense and undisturbed practice to become reliable.

The technique is deceptively simple but is actually quite hard to accomplish if you don't already have a quiet mind or at least practice making it quiet.

1) Breathe in through the nose and drive it down into your abdomen.
2) Hold your breath for 3-5 seconds.
3) Release slowly, out through the mouth.
4) Count in your mind: "1"

A beginner can get to 21 after about a week of practice before your mind is off wandering and you forget to count. If you have to guess what number you're on, your session is complete.

PMR, or Progressive Muscle Relaxation is also a great method to relax yourself as well. I use a vocalization of, "relax" and the end of each muscle tensing to serve as an anchor. In a match I can say that word, "relax" and like any muscle memory I calm down quite quickly.

Combining breath meditation, PMR, and self-hypnosis will take a long time but you can be in "the Zone" quickly and easily with practice. But it takes time to learn and time to accomplish. This will serve you for more than just pool and is as addictive as weight-lifting or exercise.

Patrick Johnson started a thread a while back, "Roadmap to the Zone", or something similar where we all chimed in experience, techniques, and ideas. It would be worth reading through.
 
Even in our daily lives it's good advice for all of us, huh Petros? :)

Sure! Pool is like a "micrography" of life, isn't it?
Sometimes you can see the character of a person by the way she/he plays the game, and trying to reach top level is a real test for character, that's why competitive pool is good education for young people, teaching them how to think and work hard for every chance on the table.
 
simplicity is essential

The easiest method of meditation is indeed breathing but people seem to think it's an instant fix. Like anything else, it requires practice, in this case at least 2-3 weeks of intense and undisturbed practice to become reliable.

The technique is deceptively simple but is actually quite hard to accomplish if you don't already have a quiet mind or at least practice making it quiet.

1) Breathe in through the nose and drive it down into your abdomen.
2) Hold your breath for 3-5 seconds.
3) Release slowly, out through the mouth.
4) Count in your mind: "1"

A beginner can get to 21 after about a week of practice before your mind is off wandering and you forget to count. If you have to guess what number you're on, your session is complete.

PMR, or Progressive Muscle Relaxation is also a great method to relax yourself as well. I use a vocalization of, "relax" and the end of each muscle tensing to serve as an anchor. In a match I can say that word, "relax" and like any muscle memory I calm down quite quickly.

Combining breath meditation, PMR, and self-hypnosis will take a long time but you can be in "the Zone" quickly and easily with practice. But it takes time to learn and time to accomplish. This will serve you for more than just pool and is as addictive as weight-lifting or exercise.

Patrick Johnson started a thread a while back, "Roadmap to the Zone", or something similar where we all chimed in experience, techniques, and ideas. It would be worth reading through.

This seems complicated, from our experience simplicity is essential to reach "thoughtless thought," and "effortless effort". THE GAME IS THE TEACHER
If-a-thoughtless-thought-is-thought%7C2C-would-a-thought-thoughtlessly-think-of-thoughtless-thoughts-whenever-thinking-thoughts-are-thoughtless%7C3F-What-a-thought%7C2C-eh%7C3F-status.jpg
 
This seems complicated, from our experience simplicity is essential to reach "thoughtless thought," and "effortless effort".

You get back what you put in. Some people are happy with relaxation so breathing meditation is quick and simple. PMR and self-hypnosis are more advanced and require more effort.

I look at it this way; some people go to the gym to compete in body building. Some people go to feel better. Where you set your bar is up to you.
 
You get back what you put in. Some people are happy with relaxation so breathing meditation is quick and simple. PMR and self-hypnosis are more advanced and require more effort.

I look at it this way; some people go to the gym to compete in body building. Some people go to feel better. Where you set your bar is up to you.

Good point. There is no need to become a Zen master given today's technology. Probably the easiest way to learn these techniques is to use bio-feed back. A licensed professional can get you started and then you can DIY. The whole deal including equipment and a few sessions might cost $500.00 (on the high side). Anyone who wants to play their absolute best needs to learn these techniques as many other professional sports people have learned.

You can pretty much do the same things for yourself through reading on the internet and buying the equipment yourself for a $100.00. Once learned it will stay with you for a life time with some brush-up every few years.
 
The easiest method of meditation is indeed breathing but people seem to think it's an instant fix. Like anything else, it requires practice, in this case at least 2-3 weeks of intense and undisturbed practice to become reliable.

The technique is deceptively simple but is actually quite hard to accomplish if you don't already have a quiet mind or at least practice making it quiet.

1) Breathe in through the nose and drive it down into your abdomen.
2) Hold your breath for 3-5 seconds.
3) Release slowly, out through the mouth.
4) Count in your mind: "1"

A beginner can get to 21 after about a week of practice before your mind is off wandering and you forget to count. If you have to guess what number you're on, your session is complete.

PMR, or Progressive Muscle Relaxation is also a great method to relax yourself as well. I use a vocalization of, "relax" and the end of each muscle tensing to serve as an anchor. In a match I can say that word, "relax" and like any muscle memory I calm down quite quickly.

Combining breath meditation, PMR, and self-hypnosis will take a long time but you can be in "the Zone" quickly and easily with practice. But it takes time to learn and time to accomplish. This will serve you for more than just pool and is as addictive as weight-lifting or exercise.

Patrick Johnson started a thread a while back, "Roadmap to the Zone", or something similar where we all chimed in experience, techniques, and ideas. It would be worth reading through.

This may sound like a joke question but I assure you It is real.

Can you describe a quiet mind?

I constantly have thoughts racing through my head, often times they are thoughts I don't want, like a song stuck in my head, and I have often tried to meditate to "clear my mind" if you will because I have heard that meditation is used to quiet the mind.

Do I have the right idea of what quieting the mind is?
 
This may sound like a joke question but I assure you It is real.

Can you describe a quiet mind?

I constantly have thoughts racing through my head, often times they are thoughts I don't want, like a song stuck in my head, and I have often tried to meditate to "clear my mind" if you will because I have heard that meditation is used to quiet the mind.

Do I have the right idea of what quieting the mind is?

Let me take a stab at that.
To experience a quiet mind try this before going to sleep.

Stare at the back of your eyelids and try to see a black wall (like an old time black board).
Breath slowly and deeply.
Place all of your concentration on your breathing while you try to see a candle flame against that black board.

In a few minutes (5 - 10) you will see the candle flame flicker. If you get excited it will go away so you have to stay calm.

When you see the flame for a second or two you have experienced a quiet mind.

Now that you know what it is you can practice as often as you like in an attempt to reach a quiet mind for long periods of time.

The quiet mind has no thoughts in it, any passing thoughts are ignored while one sees the candle flame.

There are other ways to do it. The one described here was distilled by L. LeShane*, a New School for Social Research psych who spent many years attempting to distill the essence of Eastern practices for the Western use. His book, "How to Meditate" is a classic that is useful today for its clarity and conciseness.

* http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_LeShan
 
Last edited:
Let me take a stab at that.
To experience a quiet mind try this before going to sleep.

Stare at the back of your eyelids and try to see a black wall (like an old time black board).
Breath slowly and deeply.
Place all of your concentration on your breathing while you try to see a candle flame against that black board.

In a few minutes (5 - 10) you will see the candle flame flicker. If you get excited it will go away so you have to stay calm.

When you see the flame for a second or two you have experienced a quiet mind.

Now that you know what it is you can practice as often as you like in an attempt to reach a quiet mind for long periods of time.

The quiet mind has no thoughts in it, any passing thoughts are ignored while one sees the candle flame.

There are other ways to do it. The one described here was distilled by L. LeShane, a Harvard psych who spent many years attempting to distill the essence of Eastern practices for the Western use.


It sounds as though a quiet mind is a focused mind?

With enough practice is it possible to get rid of the annoying racing thoughts, not just while practicing meditation but throughout the day? I find it harder and harder to concentrate without distracting thoughts lately.
 
This may sound like a joke question but I assure you It is real.

Can you describe a quiet mind?

I constantly have thoughts racing through my head, often times they are thoughts I don't want, like a song stuck in my head, and I have often tried to meditate to "clear my mind" if you will because I have heard that meditation is used to quiet the mind.

Do I have the right idea of what quieting the mind is?

If you are awake, you will have all kinds of thoughts (roughly 68,000 per day). The trick is quieting them to the point where you aren't distracted by random what-if's, second-guessing, self-consciousness, etc.

Describing a quiet mind? Peace. Tranquility. Emptiness. It's that same intense focus on tiny details without the annoying chatter that people describe when they're, "in the Zone".

Getting your mind quiet is an ongoing practice. Fighting back against the conscious mind doesn't work. You can't have that internal talk that says, "Stop thinking about that song!" You have to learn to allow those thoughts to flow and distance yourself from them, like background murmured conversations. That's what meditation teaches. It's not fighting, it's acceptance.

Joe W, and Lawrence K are experts in their field and I hope both chime in to provide their views on your question as well.

Edit: I see Joe has already replied. ;)
 
Satori, I suspect that you would find Leshane's paperback book, "How to meditate" quite useful.

See
http://www.amazon.com/How-Meditate-Self-Discovery-Lawrence-LeShan/dp/0316880620/ref=sr_1_2?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1376580460&sr=1-2&keywords=How+to+meditate

Cherith Powell and Greg Forde, "The Self Hypnosis Kit." (about $18.0) could also be useful after you have read Leshane. The kit is a book and audio tape that will help you learn self hypnosis for many different things. Both of these authors are highly respected professionals.

see
http://www.amazon.com/Self-Hypnosis-Kit-Discover-Hypnotherapy-Improve/dp/0670865303/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1376580133&sr=1-1&keywords=the+self-hypnosis+kit
 
Last edited:
Thanks to both of you. I'll get that book Joe.

Actually pool is an activity that brings the quiet state of mind to me. Outside of pool I am quite high strung though. To the point where natural conversation is often difficult, I just cant stay with a conversation very long. I cant stay focused. It is amazing how I can focus at all on pool but for some reason pool is the opposite and easy to focus on for long periods of time.

I have been diagnosed with ADHD but the meds don't help and I don't like the side effects. I was hoping that meditation could bring some relief.

The way I see it is if I can focus on pool then I should be able to focus in other areas of my life.
 
Last edited:
The easiest method of meditation is indeed breathing but people seem to think it's an instant fix. Like anything else, it requires practice, in this case at least 2-3 weeks of intense and undisturbed practice to become reliable.

The technique is deceptively simple but is actually quite hard to accomplish if you don't already have a quiet mind or at least practice making it quiet.

1) Breathe in through the nose and drive it down into your abdomen.
2) Hold your breath for 3-5 seconds.
3) Release slowly, out through the mouth.
4) Count in your mind: "1"

A beginner can get to 21 after about a week of practice before your mind is off wandering and you forget to count. If you have to guess what number you're on, your session is complete.

PMR, or Progressive Muscle Relaxation is also a great method to relax yourself as well. I use a vocalization of, "relax" and the end of each muscle tensing to serve as an anchor. In a match I can say that word, "relax" and like any muscle memory I calm down quite quickly.

Combining breath meditation, PMR, and self-hypnosis will take a long time but you can be in "the Zone" quickly and easily with practice. But it takes time to learn and time to accomplish. This will serve you for more than just pool and is as addictive as weight-lifting or exercise.

Patrick Johnson started a thread a while back, "Roadmap to the Zone", or something similar where we all chimed in experience, techniques, and ideas. It would be worth reading through.


Excellent post! Describes the mechanism very well. Just remember, it's like building aerobic capacity - it takes practice and the more you practice the more you build a "yes-set" and muscle memory.
 
The deep, slow breathing is a great start to "re-center" yourself.

I do this too. Deep breathes in though the nose out through the mouth and concentrate on my the breathes. It's a great way to get refocused. If you practice meditation some that's a big plus. After a while you get to where you can re-center yourself quite quickly. Eventually your supposed to be able to maintain a constant calm no matter what the situation......I haven't reached that point yet!:thumbup:
 
Here is a simple trick that helps settle yourself down.

Grab a chair, close your eyes and "watch" the game with your ears. After a while, you will be surprised how close your mind can be to the table game.

(This does NOT work if the juke box is on.)
 
Go out for a smoke break, go around the corner of the building where no one will see you...and just becareful not to lose track of it.
 

Attachments

  • 1.jpg
    1.jpg
    4.1 KB · Views: 301
This thread right here is what makes this forum priceless. I just wish there were more priceless threads over the "keep moving, nothing to see here" threads (sadly, most of my threads and posts fall under that category as well). Thanks for the link to Mika Immonens' blog post, another priceless read.

Dopc.

Edit: removed way to much unrelated material

Agreed.

My inability to do this cost me a match last week.

I was playing a stronger player than myself. He was slightly ahead of me after the first rack, then I ran the next rack, broke and got a few more. The table was set up so I could easily run much of this one, too.....until I dogged an easy one. Lost focus.

And it got me out of my game, completely. Playing as well as I could, to not being able to run 3 balls....because I couldnt get my focus back.

I will read Mika's blog later, thanks for the link, and all the other good advice here, folks.
 
the average person has between 30k and 50 Thousand thoughts a day.

This may sound like a joke question but I assure you It is real.

Can you describe a quiet mind?

I constantly have thoughts racing through my head, often times they are thoughts I don't want, like a song stuck in my head, and I have often tried to meditate to "clear my mind" if you will because I have heard that meditation is used to quiet the mind.

Do I have the right idea of what quieting the mind is?

According to studies by "so called experts," the average person has between 30k and 50 Thousand thoughts a day. Mediation can cut this average down substantially, however, most people can't do what it takes. Until experimenting with meditation few people will ever "real eyes" how out of control their mind truly is.....The Alpha is the Teacher'
 
According to studies by "so called experts," the average person has between 30k and 50 Thousand thoughts a day. Mediation can cut this average down substantially, however, most people can't do what it takes. Until experimenting with meditation few people will ever "real eyes" how out of control their mind truly is.....The Alpha is the Teacher'

What do you mean "most people can't do what it takes?"

Are you referring to capabilities or persistence?

What does it take?
 
Last edited:
Meditation, a Mental Cleanse - More than Many May "Real Eyes"...

What do you mean "most people can't do what it takes?"

Are you referring to capabilities or persistence?

What does it take?

Do you want my standard answer or the Truth??? :groucho:

I believe it takes the understanding that our own mind works against us. I started out doing 20 minute sessions with anapana mediation*** and it was very tough. The tough part was coming to the realization that my own mind had a mind of it's own. :yeah:

This stuff all sounds silly unless you've actually experienced it, the "most people that can't do what it takes" are the ones that can't sit in a quiet, dark atmosphere for an hour straight and deal with their own mind. It will make the saying "easier said than done" quite clear, it's MUCH easier said than done, as a matter of fact, few can do this for any period of time. I made myself do it for an hour a day for three weeks and it make an incredible difference in the way I perceive and deal with life and life's terms.

By the way, I'm not a "Buddhist" and have no interest in it as anything but a useful tool to strengthen and train my mind.......it is very powerful and will make anyone that tries come to terms with some things that they may not be ready for....enter at your own risk, some things in life we may not be quite ready for. ;) And for those that are.......

HERE"S MORE ON THE SUBJECT FOR THOSE THAT ARE INTERESTED: http://buddhist-meditation-techniques.com/anapana-sati-buddhist-meditation/

*** “The Method (How To): Sit cross-legged or on a chair in a quiet room. (No background music – silence is the utmost important).

Close your eyes softly or keep them half closed Place your left hand with palm facing up on your lap and place your right hand (palm up) on top of your left palm. Bring your attention to the upper lip or below the nostrils.

Observe the breathing in and breathing out in the fixed area of the upper lip or below the nostrils Maintain your attention in this area and gently bring your awareness back to this area if you are distracted.

NOTE: If you are not able to maintain your awareness in the fixed area, you can count one and one while breathing in, two and two while breathing out until ten and ten and start again. Or follow your breathing in and out. If you are too overwhelmed take ten deep breaths (conscious breathing) to calm your mind and bring your awareness back to the fixed area.

Make sure to return to regular breathing after the conscious breathing. Be a neutral observer. Notice the temperature of the breaths, sensations below the nostrils or upper lip, and the rhythm while simply observing them.

The Frequency and Duration: Week 1 – 15 minute meditation – 2 times per day (morning and evening) Week 2 - 30 minute meditation -2 times per day (morning and evening) Week 3 – 1 hour meditation – 2 times per day (morning and evening) Detailed Steps:

The Anapana Sati mediation can be done in 4 different ways: sitting (cross-legged), walking, standing or reclining. For the beginners it is advised to start with a sitting meditation. The Buddha indicated that suitable dwelling might be an isolated empty space (or meditation hall, or your room), the foot of a tree, the forest. In our urban situation, a room or even a balcony would be sufficient.

The posture should be overall relaxed in a cross-legged position. You can use some little pillows to support your knees if your knees don’t touch the floor. You can also sit in a comfortable chair. It is very important to keep the body upright to allow the energy of flow naturally and ensure no problems with postural misalignment.

Though you could start with a 15-minute meditation you would gradually extend to 1 hour or 2 hour meditation intervals and the right posture is important to avoid any muscle aches.

The Yoga students might prefer half lotus or full lotus positions. For the purpose of the meditation is not important that you sit in a full lotus position. Rather, the erect spine and concentration on the fixed area are of the utmost importance. The hands are gently placed on the lap with the back of the right hand resting in the open palm of the left hand.

The eyes can be half closed or closed softly. The closing would allow your eyes not wonder and be easily distracted. The main focus is to have a fixed attention on the in-breath and out-breath above the upper lip or below the nostrils.

The breathing is a natural autonomic process and therefore is used as a tool to cultivate concentration and mindfulness. As you become mindful of where incoming and outgoing breath comes and leaves at the nostrils, you will cultivate Anapana Sati.

During the meditation it is important to bring your awareness to this location and observe the quality of the breath, the sensations on top of the upper lip or below the nostrils as a result of the in-and-out breathing. Be mindful of the temperature of the breath and the natural rhythm of the breath.

Note the perspiration, cold, tingling sensations as the breath touches the upper lip. Naturally, your mind, like a monkey mind, may be jumping around and trying to take your awareness to any other part of the body in the form of subtle aches or itching.

It will try to highjack your concentration by tempting you to delve in to thoughts of the past or what you have to do in the future.
It is important that you gently bring your awareness back to the in-and-out breath around the fixed area. As a beginner, it might be difficult to keep your awareness of the breath in the fixed area.

Don’t worry about it. Do your best and if your mind strays, gently bring your awareness to the fixed area. Some people find it easier to use counting: for example as you breathe in count One and One, as your breath out count Two and Two and so on until you reach Ten and Ten and start counting again. This might help to calm down your mind and keep your focus on the fixed area while observing your breathing. Another way of focusing your attention is to fully concentrate on the beginning and the end of the each breath. In some cases, even counting one to ten might not be enough.

Try taking ten deep breaths in and out (so-called conscious breathing) to calm down your mind from any distraction and/or irritation. Then, come back to regular breathing and simply observe the in-and-out breathing in the fixed area.

Use conscious breathing as a temporary tool to calm your agitated mind. Being earnest in your meditation schedule is the most important aspect at the beginning. To ensure that you meditate at least 15 minutes, set an alarm clock, stop watch or oven timer to let you know when the meditation is over.

Our minds come up with thousands of reasons for breaking the meditation since the mind is bored and wants to keep us entertained. Using a timer free you from having to think, “How long have I meditated?” While some meditation techniques suggest having a background relaxing music,

Anapana Sati Meditation is best done in a quiet room to allow you to observe the breath going in and out in the fixed area. As you meditate regularly and maintain the mindfulness of breathing, the breathing will become more and more subtle and tranquil. Your overall body will become calm and relaxed.

The numbness in the leg will disappear and you will become comfortable. “The mind then becomes free from the five hindrances — sensual desire, anger, drowsiness, restlessness and doubt. As a result one becomes calm and joyful.” (Venerable Mahathera Nayuane Ariadhamma.) I experienced a sense of spaciousness and equanimity during Anapana Sati meditation.

Everyone has different experiences and it might take different amount time for each person to achieve equanimity. Be assured you will feel equanimity if you keep meditating. S.N. Goenka during his video discourses for his students indicated that 3 days (30 hour meditation schedule) allows each student to achieve mindfulness and concentration and allow the students to start practicing Vipassana for 7 more days.

If you are not doing the 10-day Buddhist retreat, you will determine yourself when you are ready to move from Anapana Sati Meditation to Vipassana (Insight Meditation). It might take 30 hours cumulatively or less or more. It is not important how much time you have meditated. Rather, I would suggest a benchmark for you to know when to graduate to Vipassana (insight meditation).

If you are able to maintain awareness of breathing above the upper lip or below the nostrils for 1 hour for at least 1 week (5 one-hour meditation sessions), you are ready to graduate to Vipassana meditation. If you are not ready yet, do not be discouraged and continue Anapana Sati meditation a bit longer. The meditation is not the end, but the journey and everyone walks his/her own path. If you find that it is difficult to do meditation by yourself, find a meditation buddy or a few buddies creating a community (‘sangha’).

This could help you to be disciplined and do meditation regularly. It is often recommended to do the meditation at the same time in the morning and/or evening. Though it is not the actual requirement of Anapana Sati meditation, doing it at the same time daily helps you to develop a sense of discipline and accomplishment.

As you become proficient doing Anapana Sati meditation you will be able to be mindful of your breathing at any time and anywhere and you can do Anapana meditation while walking, standing, or washing dishes.“”

Read more about Anapana Sati Buddhist Meditation for beginners - (How To Meditate) on:
http://buddhist-meditation-techniqu...ource=INK&utm_medium=copy&utm_campaign=share&
 
Thanks for the response C.J.

Buddhist... Christianity... I am torn.

I have seen believable evidence which support both but which path should I take?


Below is a great article by Dr. Tan
________________________

Can one be Christian and Buddhist at the same time?

The average Westerner finds the popular images of Buddhism and Eastern mysticism extremely appealing – the meditation which seems to promise a retreat from the stress and strains of life, the ‘quietness’ and apparent inner peace that appear to offer a refuge from the frenetic pace of life, and the seemingly inner spiritual depth and harmony that provide an anchor in the storms of life. Contrast these with the popular images of much of the approach to God and worship in the Western church. At one end of the spectrum, you have the cerebral, coldly formal, extremely wordy and ritualised worship; at the other end of the spectrum you have the extremely emotional and shallow worship which focuses on the experiential, the fleeting and the here and now. The task oriented and competitive nature of much of Western life seems to be have been assimilated into the way we practise Christianity.

To the untaught Christian, Buddhism appears to be an antidote to the above. Does it not seem eminently sensible, and wise even, to incorporate the best elements of Buddhism into Christianity? This, however, is unfounded optimism and ultimately leads to a practice of Christianity that bears little resemblance to historic Christianity. Only in its terminology and outward forms will it be vaguely Christian; our Lord Jesus, however, would not recognise it, or his apostles.

Some key differences

There are a large number of schools of Buddhist thoughts; Zen (meaning ‘meditation’) Buddhism is the most popular manifestation of Buddhism in the West. Classic Buddhism, however, teaches a number of key concepts:

• Life is transitory, without substance (illusory) and filled with suffering. All life is, therefore, meaningless and without purpose.
• All human beings are trapped in the endless cycle of birth, death and rebirth (reincarnation).
• Every human action carries consequences, if not now, then in the next life; good deeds, therefore, bring about a better reincarnation than bad deeds. Yet, what is done is done and cannot be undone; you cannot be forgiven or released from it.
• This suffering is overcome by the ‘eightfold path’: right understanding, right thought, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness and right meditation.
• Redemption is the complete departure from the endless cycle of birth, death and rebirth and release from self into nirvana, a state of nothingness and silence. Nirvana is the impersonal ultimate reality; whether or not this state is conscious is not defined

These teachings are glaringly and fundamentally different to the Christian gospel:
• There is no God in Buddhism. Christianity, however, presents a living, personal, holy and almighty God who created the world from nothingness (not into nothingness).
• In Buddhism, the world and human self are nothing but an illusion; the ultimate reality is the absolute emptiness of the great void. Contrast this with the physical reality of Jesus Christ, mankind and God’s creation.
• The Christian concept of sin, as a violation of God’s holy nature and laws, is non-existent in Buddhism; there is, therefore, no need of a Saviour. There is no final accountability to a holy God on the judgment Day. Karma, the cosmic Law of Cause and Effect, is the ultimate impersonal and merciless judge.
• Self-effort, with guidance and help from certain priests and teachers, is the key to salvation. Jesus’ death on the Cross for our sins, providing the only means of reconciliation with God, is unnecessary and pointless to the Buddhist. There is no savior in Buddhism; the Buddha said he could not help anyone; he could only point the way.
• Buddhist meditation aims to achieve release from suffering and the endless cycle of death and rebirth; according to Buddha, meditation is only ‘a raft with which one can reach the opposite shore: emptiness’. Christian meditation focuses on God and its aim is to achieve fullness and oneness with Christ, not emptiness without Christ.
• Heaven is the Christian’s ultimate destiny; the Buddhist, however, aims for nirvana, a state of nothingness and emptiness. Nirvana is the state where there is neither being nor non-being. Hope, then, does not lie in God’s mercy, love and grace; it lies in non-existence.

Can both Christianity and Buddhism be true?

Some will take the position that all truth is relative. Taking that to be true does mean that they have to believe that there are absolute truths! If they do not believe absolutely that ‘all truth is relative’, then we can safely ignore their assertions.

Others will take the ‘pragmatic’ approach that it doesn’t really matter whether two things are compatible; what is important is what works. This is precisely where the orthodox Christian must insist on the uniqueness of Christ. The reason the God of the Bible is fundamentally opposed to other religions is because they do not work! God’s intolerance of other religions is not based on spite and pride but on both truth and compassion.

The truth is that there isn’t another way to salvation or reconciliation with Him; He has truthfully and lovingly told us so! He is holy and ‘…too pure to look on evil’ (Hab. 1:13). We cannot, therefore, approach God in any way we desire; Cain made that error in the early days of human history. We do not choose the grounds of reconciliation with Him or dictate the terms. Jesus Himself declared that He is the way, the truth and the life, and no one can come to the Father except through Him. If that is true then other ways cannot also be true.

If there was another way to peace with God, why did God the Father, in love and compassion, send His Son Jesus Christ to die for our sins? If other ways in fact work, then God the Father has made a catastrophic error in sending Jesus to a horrendously painful and unnecessary death. If God can make a mistake of such enormous scale, then He is not worthy of belief. Again, if other ways do work, then Jesus was deluded (to think His death was necessary to save mankind), stupid (to die so unnecessarily), mad (thinking of Himself as the Son of God and Saviour) or bad (leading millions and millions of Christians astray)!

That is not to doubt the sincerity of the adherents of other religions, or that other faiths do contain some universal, self-evident truths, or that their beliefs may enable them to somewhat cope with this often cruel world. Christians do not have the right to compel others to embrace their beliefs or to belittle other religionists’ worth as human beings made in the image of God. But any way that excludes Christ’s saving grace cannot work for the simple reason that none of us is capable of living in accordance with his own chosen moral and spiritual standards, let alone God’s. God judges us in accordance with His own holy nature and laws; who among us can save himself and face the all-knowing and holy God with any degree of confidence?

Every genuine Christian respects the adherents of other faiths, and seeks to love them as his neighbour. We have, however, to make a decision on Christ’s claim to be God and to be ‘the way, the truth, and the life.’ As C. S. Lewis aptly put it, ‘A man who was merely a man and said the sort of things Jesus said would not be a great moral teacher. He would either be a lunatic - on the level with the man who says he is a poached egg - or else he would be the Devil of Hell. You must make your choice. Either this man was, and is, the Son of God, or else a madman or something worse…. let us not come with any patronising nonsense about His being a great human teacher. He has not left that open to us. He did not intend to.’

The man who would be bishop

And so to the bishop-to-be who claims to be Christian and Buddhist. In light of the above, integrity would demand that he chooses one or the other. God has decreed that we must not bow down before other gods. Every ‘free’ human being has the right to choose, but call the choice by its right name. It is most disrespectful to both devout Buddhists and Christians to call oneself both at the same time; it shows a shallow understanding of the fundamentals of both religions. I was once a Buddhist but I am now a Christian; I was never both. Indeed, I now understand I cannot be both.

Some might insist that it is only the mechanics of meditation that is adopted and not the theology or worldview of Buddhism. To say that is to miss the entire point of Buddhist meditation. According to theologian Martin Goldsmith, ‘meditation is the basic Zen means towards that realisation of the Buddha-nature which lies in each of us. While it remains that we do not exist, the Buddha nature in us does (according to Zen Buddhism).’ Mr. Forrester understands that and therefore makes no dishonest or deceitful pretensions about being a Christian who merely utilises the meditative aspects to advance his understanding of Christ and His way.

Yet, no one who reads Mr. Forrester’s search for spiritual depth and meaning in his life can do so without feeling empathy for him. In the corner of our hearts we may even secretly admire his audacity. Western Christianity has lost so much of its awe, reverence, and mystery of God; the ‘into church and out of church’ and then leaving it all behind for another week, does not satisfy. The pursuit after personal significance and transient joy has led Christians to seek the outward expression, rather than the inward expression, of our faith in Christ. We have forgotten how to be quiet and alone with God; the ‘quiet time’ is anything but. One can be extremely orthodox in theology and yet be extremely dry spiritually.

Notwithstanding, Christ-less Christianity, ungrounded in Biblical truths, will neither lead to God nor to truth. We ought to be very circumspect how we choose; when we choose a path that excludes God, or includes Him only in the condescending margins of our lives, we get exactly that. We, in choosing little ingredients from here and there in the supermarket of faiths and philosophies, only find that we have chosen to be our own god. The essence of hell is that God lets us be. Again, as C. S. Lewis put it, ‘God cannot give us happiness and peace apart from himself, because it is not there. There is no such thing.’

________________________






I truly am torn.Maybe my inner turmoil is the result of straying away from God?

Life is not easy. If only we knew for sure what the truth is.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top