So as a new member of the forum this has been a really interesting thread. While I'm not new to pool I have not really played in 25 years (played a ton in college and bought a Schmelke and a Hubler back then that I still have) but on a lark, I bought my first home table and now want to get five or six really nice cues to display in my pool room.
Having said that I am a compulsive collector that has mainly fed that bug on limited edition movie posters. And I have four large flat files to show for 12 years of collecting. I continue to watch new collectors pour into the poster hobby drawn from popular culture and likewise, the value of some of my posters continues to climb. But in my 12 years doing this I have never sold a poster, but I also have never bought anything that I would not frame and hang in my home so I have a personal attachment to every piece of paper I acquired.
There is something truly amazing about watching a pool cue get crafted, my wife and I have watched several makers on youtube that have posted full videos of all the steps they went through in the construction of one of their cues. It's humbling to watch these folks do what they do and makes you appreciate the work all the more.
The tricky part in old cues and their inherent value has to be linked to something that transcends the moment. In my limited time exploring this craft I have seen some cues that were clearly lovingly made and may have even exchanged hands at values two or three times their original sales price but now pale in comparison to a cue that has more....flair. And by flair, I mean woods, joints, inlays, etc...
You have a very small smattering of cues that the makers transcended and achieved cult-like status, those cues may fluctuate in relative price but will always hold some of their value. It's the lesser-known makers who have passed on and the collectors who sang their praise are passing now too. Those are the cues that for new collectors like myself, give us an opportunity to enter into this hobby in a reasonable way and allow their work to be appreciated by a new generation.
I recently posted in the WTB section looking for my first high-end cue, I decided to try to buy a couple of examples of Jim Buss's work. I was attracted to Mr. Buss as a maker because of his life story, his career, where he has lived, made his cues, and a very real appreciation of his aesthetic.
I don't know if I'm paying too much for the ones that I will buy, I seriously doubt they will ever be sold for more than I wind up paying. I also don't care. Any cue I buy will never be as an investment or an alternative asset and alt asset investing strategies is how you wind up with NFT's and fucking bored monkeys...
TLDR: Honestly don't worry about the value of your cues, sell what you only marginally like so you can bring new blood into this hobby. And continue to create great threads like this one!