Don't know if this will interest but here's what I've done for the last year. I wrap the handle are with self fusing silicone tape. One roll will get you at least 2 applications depending on how long you make it.
It doesn't last forever but if you wipe/clean it occasionally you'll get a while out of it.
If you're interested search on "Nashua Self-Fusing Silicone Tape" on amazon.
I really think the different opinions on this subject come from people having different skin. My skin is pretty dry, especially in the winter. Someone that has more moisture in their skin no doubt would hate this, I think it's just right.
Anyway, it's a cheap thing to try, it's like 7 dollars on amazon for a roll.