The REAL problem with pool

The major hurdle with pool, IMHO, is there are about 6 different size tables, on which we play about 75 different games, with 100 different sets of rules..and that's not even counting snooker !

Until we get a viable governing body, (not the BCA, or some Pro players, with zero business experience) and accept ONE SINGLE GAME, (like golf, tennis, bowling and every other sport/game has done).. there is zero chance of ANYONE looking seriously at pool !... Bonus Ball should have been a lesson..It was just what we DIDN'T need !..Another game to confuse potential fan's and sponsor's !

The only game that will ever attract a diversified viewing audience, (outside of us hardcore 'pool nuts') is 8 BALL...Everybody already knows the game... It has been around for 80 years or so, and has out-lasted EVERY OTHER POOL GAME, for acceptance and popularity... And with some minor tweaking, it could be a very good game to play, at the pro level !

My favorite game, by far, is One Pocket !..But I am realistic enough to see that one pocket, 14.1, or even 9/10 ball, will NEVER be accepted by 'Joe Six Pack'... Or any other casual viewer's, that big money sponsors are hoping to entice !

Trudeau (and the IPT), may have made a lot of 'pool enemies' ...But like every other smart money project KT gets involved in, he DOES do his homework !...Guess which game he chose ?...If it were not for some unforeseen changes in the gambling laws, we might be playing some $1,000,000 1st place 8-ball tournaments, TODAY ! :rolleyes:

IMO that is like saying that fighting is suffering because you have boxing, kickboxing, Thai boxing, judo, jiu jitsu, etc.

Mma will never work, right, because the average joe can't even tell the difference between kickboxing and Thai boxing, they don't even know the rule differences in those two and now we are bringing in a new sport?

Boxing has been around for years and everyone understands it, the UFC should have went with those rules, right?

My point is BB is fresh, it is complex enough to satisfy and even excite the hardcore player if they were to give it a chance and play and learn the game, it is organized to be perfect for the sports gambling industry, & it is exciting enough and has enough dramatic moments to draw in the casual sports fan if marketed right.

BB is not the wrong game, it had the wrong management behind it.
 
My point is BB is fresh, it is complex enough to satisfy and even excite the hardcore player if they were to give it a chance and play and learn the game, it is organized to be perfect for the sports gambling industry, & it is exciting enough and has enough dramatic moments to draw in the casual sports fan if marketed right.

BB is not the wrong game, it had the wrong management behind it.

You might be right and there is only one way to find out. Anyone got a set of Bonus Balls? and a set of Rules?

I have Friday, Sunday game every week. Id like to give it a shot.

Has anyone talked to any of the Pro Players that played it?
 
Everyone seems to be skirting the issue here. In my view it's the economy that's emptied out the pool rooms. When the jobs went away in 2007/2008 a huge number of the pool players went with it. Think of it as trickle up economics. Do away with the Indians and there's no one left to feed the Chiefs.
Although I think Dick, makes some good points, I just don't believe that inventing new games featuring brightly colored balls is the answer, nor focusing on one that may, or may not, be appealing to the masses would be either.
Strengthen the dollar, create jobs, lower taxes, and reduce the deficit. If that doesn't bring them back, nothing else is going to.
 
You might be right and there is only one way to find out. Anyone got a set of Bonus Balls? and a set of Rules?

I have Friday, Sunday game every week. Id like to give it a shot.

Has anyone talked to any of the Pro Players that played it?

The game is awesome IMO. It's no gimmick game that is easy to master. You can't have any weaknesses in your game and expect to play at a high level plus you need to know a unique strategy.

You can play with regular balls and use a coin to keep track. Here is a post Nathan made explaining the coin

"Do you know coin trick? None of us actually use the scoreboard here at the studio, we all use coins.

-> Each diamond represents 3 points, so you want to move your coin 10 diamonds to get to 30 points. Half diamond if you sink purple, and then onto the next diamond if you sink orange. That gives you 3pts, which is why your coin would stop under a diamond. Full diamond jump for the BB, since its 3pts on its own.It makes it easy, because if you come to the table and your coin is under a diamond, you automatically know you're on purple. If not, you're on orange. Same with your opponent, so its instinctive to always know what ball both players are on."

The rules can be found on the BB website.

It may sound complicated but once you start playing it will be easy to understand or it might help to watch some YouTube videos of the game after you have read the rules before you play.

Have fun.
 
Last edited:
Real Estate

You said pool was never considered a profession.
So, what do you suppose Mosconi did for a living?
Jimmy Caras?
Ralph Greenleaf?
Willie Hoppe?
Frank Ives?
Jake Schaefer?
(The list goes on)

As one example, Jake Schaefer was being paid a yearly base salary by Brunswick of $3000 in 1895. This equates to over $80,000 today. And of course this is before his winnings, sometimes up to $5k or more at a time.

You said pool was never a major sport.
In the context of your statement, you included pool as a sport.

Baseball leagues weren't even formed until the 1870s and every other sport/game came after that. 1776-1876 pool ruled. News of major matches was sent via telegraph all across the country live as it happened. Billiard news was frequently front page news in the papers. I'd say that's pretty major.

And even after 1870 pool was played more than any other game OR sport in the country for many decades. In 1920 there were 2000 billiard rooms in Chicago and over 3000 in New York. I'd say that's pretty major.Nonetheless, I understood the point you were getting at, just thought I'd set the record straight.

Im not sure what the percentage would be that would reflect how much was charged for pool time vs. how much rent is today for places of comparable space and value but.......

With all of the problems we have had in the Real Estate market. I would dare say there are a lot of spaces that have been empty for quite a long time. If I were a holder of such real estate I would be excited about the prospect of renting it to someone who wanted to make a payment every month, at least I would be making something.

What I see in my mind is organizing Seniors into doing it. Sort of make the pool rooms an extension of the Senior Center. A place for them to hang out and shoot the breeze, play pool and enjoy retirement. This kind of place doesn't have to have alcohol. Just tables, someone to watch the store......1 day a week.....and let other people have times they work/hangout as well.

As many used tables as are around it shouldn't be real hard to find them.

If rent is truly more affordable, tables available, and someone can bring in a chair or two, and an old refridgerator, then we can start negotiating how to heat the place....use those Amish electric stoves that run cheap. Maybe you have a fan in the summer and air conditioning if youre lucky.

Pool doesn't have to be Posh. It just need to be available and people will play it if its reasonably priced.

Sell a few sticks and cases. Do some tip replacement. Hang out with the guys. I don't see the reason to try and make things so pristine that you price yourself out of the market you have. Make it a hangout for old guys and tell them if the crowd gets rowdy, close up and go home. End of story

Make a place kids can study, then play pool, maybe the community college will put in some flyers about their 2 yr programs or the Military have posters about the Service.

Maybe it becomes a senior hangout, a place for kids....at risk kids.....which means kids living with parents earning poverty level wages...which today is one heck of a lot of people.........Maybe its a community outreach/ recreation center just like it was for a lot of us and maybe 8-ball is a good game for it, then later 9-ball, then when you need a new game Banks and One Pocket.

Maybe since there wouldn't be alcohol, it could become a place for schools to do Billiard Education. Elementary, HS or Colllege?

Maybe Communities could and would get behind something like this? Lots of communities don't have bars but this would be acceptable and Maybe Girls...would come.

There is plenty of games in pool to stoke ones interest.

There just needs to be more places to do it. I don't think It would cost a lot to put in an operation like this...what ...8 tables? x 3g a table put in=24k?

There is bound to be a few old guys in most towns that could cough up 24k. Bring a chair or two in and an old refridgerator and then have a new place to hang out.

Of course there is rent.........so lets say its 600/800 a month of space that would normally bring more...so you need another 12k put back ......12k plus 24k means you need to have
36k in the bank....to get started......

a few successful old guys in a town...with nothing to do....need a new place that is their own........

We have the perfect time for it.

Rent can be found cheap and so can tables.. We need to just not be so posh about the places we play. Maybe someone donates some air conditioning.... Im sure something could be worked out in time......

So how much do you have to make to make it work?

You have to pay the rent.....and probably something for the help as well....if they own it...and they are owners then you don't have to meet Minimum Wage.....its a hangout and a fun place to be.

We need to own pool. Its likely not a business that is going to make a lot of money. Pool at a grass roots level had better have old folks and kids in it.

I will add this: If you don't call the people employees....and you have a real contract with them...that hang out there and keep the place open then you don't have to meet the Minimum Wage and you don't have to guarantee a wage at all. If you split up profits with the people who hung out in the place and kept it open you would simply 1099 them and that would make Uncle Sam happy. You would be owner and operator of a billiard club, that may or not make it.....but you have chances.....that it might. You can even sell this at a later date to the people that love hanging out in it and move and do another one.

I see this as a doable thing...for a lot of small towns.....anybody want to invest 40k?

There will always be people who go to bars to play pool and there will be more of them, the more places like this are put in.

Just my two cents worth? Anyone willing to give this a try?
 
Last edited:
You said pool was never considered a profession.
So, what do you suppose Mosconi did for a living?
Jimmy Caras?
Ralph Greenleaf?
Willie Hoppe?
Frank Ives?
Jake Schaefer?
(The list goes on)

As one example, Jake Schaefer was being paid a yearly base salary by Brunswick of $3000 in 1895. This equates to over $80,000 today. And of course this is before his winnings, sometimes up to $5k or more at a time.

You said pool was never a major sport.
In the context of your statement, you included pool as a sport.

Baseball leagues weren't even formed until the 1870s and every other sport/game came after that. 1776-1876 pool ruled. News of major matches was sent via telegraph all across the country live as it happened. Billiard news was frequently front page news in the papers. I'd say that's pretty major.

And even after 1870 pool was played more than any other game OR sport in the country for many decades. In 1920 there were 2000 billiard rooms in Chicago and over 3000 in New York. I'd say that's pretty major.

Nonetheless, I understood the point you were getting at, just thought I'd set the record straight.
Those rooms were gambling rooms and pool was the term used as to mean the pool of money pool tables were put in for patrons to have something to do in between horse races they were betting on

80k in less than a Union Plumber makes in NYC
Even the best in the world in any yr have made far less than top professionals outside of sports , never mind top sport players in real sports
That's why they have a term when asked how someone got good at pool the reply is a miss spent youth

However there can be money made obviously for some of the elite and maybe if run and governed properly it can become a better pro sport\ game than what it is now
But it needs to be condensed to the point where your either a pro or your not with pro only turnys and a few opens that players would have to qualify to get into
This will make it more elite and people will view it that way
Like I said the pro bowling tour is a good template for a starting point
After that is achieved than the can dream of golfers money
But you have to crawl before you can walk and pool is still in the crib

1
 
Last edited:
Some of the more memorable rooms I've visited -- like Comet and Mr Cues -- have had classic rock piped in and playing softly in the background. That's preferable to some of the stuff people pay to listen to at ear-splitting levels at many spots.

Lou Figueroa

Yes Comet had that. They also had $40 month practice all you want. They had more room between tables than anywhere. They had no crowd of uncouth guys. It was women friendly but no salads/food.. Plenty of parking. It was the one of the first places to close in the recent spate.

The atmosphere just didnt have anyone but pool players saying to themselves "Im in a cool place"
 
T


Trudeau (and the IPT), may have made a lot of 'pool enemies' ...But like every other smart money project KT gets involved in, he DOES do his homework !...! :rolleyes:


The other KT Projects were totally different-all crooked in some way BUT he knew how to run them. He knew nothing about pool but what Mike Sigel told him which was a bunch of crap aimed at getting Mike some pay days.

I agree on the craziness all the games but 8 Ball has more different rules than all combined. The only people that play it outside of league dont know or even care about the rules. A standard set of rules would help.

The IPT was not formed with any gambling idea in mind imo-That was the bailout excuse to save KT face.
 
If the people that play pool are diminishing at a rate of 10% per year (the theme of this thread***), it may as well be a secret.

Without TV coverage I would go out on a limb and state (with confidence) EVERY sport would regress at a rate of 10% per year. "Out of Sight, Out of Mind"



philosoraptor-meme-generator-if-absence-makes-the-heart-grow-fonder-then-why-out-of-sight-out-of-mind-4b9511.jpg

Pool was growing at a rapid pace long before TV was around
The APA certainly did not grow because of TV exposure I have never seen a APA add
Those numbers are not a true representation of where pool is at , they are more indicative of the shape of the economy , I would venture to say most extra curricula activities that take money are down by those numbers

I with much confidence would say pool goes as the economy goes
When people have more money they go out play more join leagues , go to turnys by more equipment and tables , hell they even gamble more
Many places have compensated by giving free pool nights and free pool with lunch or dinner just to keep there doors open
League give rewards for bringing in new players the same with some turnys
All this is done to try to keep up with the lost pool players
When the economy gets better across the country so will pool with or with out TV
It's already got much better turny wise in my area
I would expect the rest of the country to follow suit


1
 
I wonder what would happen if there was a scotch doubles league with teams composed of two couples. Two males, two females.

I am thinking here about attracting the younger crowd with all those raging hormones and a need to meet and socialize with like minded people.

Something like this could be the seed for creating interest and would perhaps yield some dedicated players, male and female.

Perhaps it would not have to be a league to get it started. Something like a Wednesday night mini-tournament.

It could be set up through the social media (face book and such) then there is a real need to meet and interact with live people. It works from two perspectives. Get the kids off the computers to interact in the real world.

Later when the match is completed they can rehash the who thing on their computers, meet new people and learn more about playing pool.

Could add some sort of fantasy football component where you selected a partner and or were assigned a partner, Hell I don't know but some way to change partners periodically.


I am sure it would need some tweaking, I am an old man and out of touch with the modern batch of young people.
 
Last edited:
I wonder what would happen if there was a scotch doubles league with teams composed of two couples. Two males, two females.
I am thinking here about attracting the younger crowd with all those raging hormones and a need to meet and socialize with like minded people.
Something like this could be the seed for creating interest and would perhaps yield some dedicated players, male and female.
Perhaps it would not have to be a league to get it started. Something like a Wednesday night mini-tournament.
It could be set up through the social media (face book and such) then there is a real need to meet and interact with live people. It works from two perspectives. Get the kids off the computers to interact in the real world.
Later when the match is completed they can rehash the who thing on their computers, meet new people and learn more about playing pool.
I am sure it would need some tweaking, I am an old man and out of touch with the modern batch of young people.


Gee whiz, Joe, that's sounds like the perfect way to save pool that doesn't need saving in the first place. Why don't we make it Nude Scotch Doubles and really have some fun.
You'll have to be careful though. You never know what those raging hormones will do to a person. One minute someone is shooting a three-railer for the win; the next minute they're all doing it on top of the pool table.
 
I wonder what would happen if there was a scotch doubles league with teams composed of two couples. Two males, two females.

I am thinking here about attracting the younger crowd with all those raging hormones and a need to meet and socialize with like minded people.

Something like this could be the seed for creating interest and would perhaps yield some dedicated players, male and female.

Perhaps it would not have to be a league to get it started. Something like a Wednesday night mini-tournament.

It could be set up through the social media (face book and such) then there is a real need to meet and interact with live people. It works from two perspectives. Get the kids off the computers to interact in the real world.

Later when the match is completed they can rehash the who thing on their computers, meet new people and learn more about playing pool.

I am sure it would need some tweaking, I am an old man and out of touch with the modern batch of young people.

I was actually thinking the same thing Pool needs a site like FB or match .com
In fact how about. Match up pool . com

Use the tool most used my today's generation , the phone and the computer ,

1
 
Gee whiz, Joe, that's sounds like the perfect way to save pool that doesn't need saving in the first place. Why don't we make it Nude Scotch Doubles and really have some fun.
You'll have to be careful though. You never know what those raging hormones will do to a person. One minute someone is shooting a three-railer for the win; the next minute they're all doing it on top of the pool table.

Don't know if it needs saving for us old folks but it could use some help for the new kids. And what I have vaguely suggested here is incorporating a few social trends to address more than one possible social problem.

From your sarcastic comments it would appear that a few creative ideas to improve the game are unwelcome. OK, I'll go away.
 
Actually it was, for nearly 100 years, THE most important game played in the U.S.



I can name many players who would heartily disagree.
They were paid a yearly salary, plus their tournament winnings, plus half the door receipts, plus bets. They made damn good money.

........

The problem is not as simple as TV, or women, or alcohol, or smoke, or whatever...
It's a multi faceted issue that begins with money, and ends with money.

That said, I can tell you with confidence that the biggest hurdle for pool is gaining a reputable media outlet of some kind. Something other than print (and text). And something that doesn't cost the patron anything to enjoy.

TV is one, radio is one, and the internet has the potential to trump both of them if done right. But, don't be lulled into believing that a gimmick such as a weekly show or a movie will make a difference in the long run, because the problems run deeper than that.

At the core of the problem is information. The general public and even regular pool players can't tell you, with few exceptions, the name of more than a few major players.
They can't tell you what and where the major tournies are. They can't tell you more than a few cue makers, they don't know the difference between billiards and bosh.

The general public doesnt know the games, the rules, the shots.
They don't know the difference between a horse blanket and good quality table cloth.
(They still call it felt)

And the industry at large suffers the same ailments. They have no place to advertise and inform the public of their wares other than print and banner ads on specialty sites and in publications that the general public never sees.

When players win tournaments, does the papparazi beat a path to their door for an interview? No, they take their check (hopefully) and simply go home. They might, if they're lucky, see a photo or two of themselves online and a paragraph here or there, but that's it. There is very little "fame" to aspire to or gain anymore.

Football fans can tell you the rules, the players, who is injured, who got caught drinking and driving, who the coaches are, who got drafted, what time the game starts, and where its being played, and maybe even how many people attended the game...because the information is there, reliably, and they don't pay one cent for it. They point the remote, turn on the radio, or click a mouse and there it is.


The information is there, i just goolgled Billiard and 20 million hit came back; People interest in the game is what is missing. To average person pool is very boring game same thing gets repeated over and over again no magic there for someone to look forward to, no record to break, no buzzer beaters and to avg people they think it is easy game, heard many new viewers comment "i can do that" . Simple differentiation is snooker, people know 147 is extremely rare yet doable, they look for it every time they watch or big break, huge incentive to the game, straight pool comes close, but because the fun ends and you have to re rack again, or 61 other pool games the fun ends by just looking at the score, no cheer leaders, short skirts, or ....!!, just pool.
Sorry it ain't going to cut it when you have 1000 competitive shows at your finger tip. To all media outlet, they need viewers 1st.
 
I wonder what would happen if there was a scotch doubles league with teams composed of two couples. Two males, two females.

I am thinking here about attracting the younger crowd with all those raging hormones and a need to meet and socialize with like minded people.

Something like this could be the seed for creating interest and would perhaps yield some dedicated players, male and female.

Perhaps it would not have to be a league to get it started. Something like a Wednesday night mini-tournament.

It could be set up through the social media (face book and such) then there is a real need to meet and interact with live people. It works from two perspectives. Get the kids off the computers to interact in the real world.

Later when the match is completed they can rehash the who thing on their computers, meet new people and learn more about playing pool.

Could add some sort of fantasy football component where you selected a partner and or were assigned a partner, Hell I don't know but some way to change partners periodically.


I am sure it would need some tweaking, I am an old man and out of touch with the modern batch of young people.

JoeW,
I thought so too but I haven't thought of the 2 ladies/2 guys thing. That does sound good. Im sure you could draw partners and play it out and people would make friends, meet girlfriends and it would become popular.

Id like to see this in the form of a tour. I bet people would really flock to it.

In 15 months I might do it.
 
I wonder what would happen if there was a scotch doubles league with teams composed of two couples. Two males, two females.

I am thinking here about attracting the younger crowd with all those raging hormones and a need to meet and socialize with like minded people.

Something like this could be the seed for creating interest and would perhaps yield some dedicated players, male and female.

Perhaps it would not have to be a league to get it started. Something like a Wednesday night mini-tournament.

It could be set up through the social media (face book and such) then there is a real need to meet and interact with live people. It works from two perspectives. Get the kids off the computers to interact in the real world.

Later when the match is completed they can rehash the who thing on their computers, meet new people and learn more about playing pool.

Could add some sort of fantasy football component where you selected a partner and or were assigned a partner, Hell I don't know but some way to change partners periodically.


I am sure it would need some tweaking, I am an old man and out of touch with the modern batch of young people.

A friend of mine came up with a similar idea but it involved guys paying to play and girls not paying...in this scenario....guys went to a table and would have shots or pool skills to show the girls....this lasted 10 min or so then you would switch and it became a sort of Speed Date thing. The idea was guys met girls...maybe something clicked....no obligations. I like the idea of making Pool something ladies.....wanted to do.
 
Pool was growing at a rapid pace long before TV was around
The APA certainly did not grow because of TV exposure I have never seen a APA add
Those numbers are not a true representation of where pool is at , they are more indicative of the shape of the economy , I would venture to say most extra curricula activities that take money are down by those numbers

I with much confidence would say pool goes as the economy goes
When people have more money they go out play more join leagues , go to turnys by more equipment and tables , hell they even gamble more
Many places have compensated by giving free pool nights and free pool with lunch or dinner just to keep there doors open
League give rewards for bringing in new players the same with some turnys
All this is done to try to keep up with the lost pool players
When the economy gets better across the country so will pool with or with out TV
It's already got much better turny wise in my area
I would expect the rest of the country to follow suit


1

It is not true, nowadays there are more options to choose from and cheaper. I bet you if pool halls make it free to play pool not many people will show up. Our generation is lazy do not want to move, just remote control, COSTCO packaged food, and have it made.
 
Don't know if it needs saving for us old folks but it could use some help for the new kids. And what I have vaguely suggested here is incorporating a few social trends to address more than one possible social problem.
From your sarcastic comments it would appear that a few creative ideas to improve the game are unwelcome. OK, I'll go away.


You're right, Joe. That was a bit sarcastic, and I apologize. I woke up on the wrong side of the bed this morning, and ran into a wall.
I still like the part about the naked pool players, though. :)
 
Last edited:
It is not true, nowadays there are more options to choose from and cheaper. I bet you if pool halls make it free to play pool not many people will show up. Our generation is lazy do not want to move, just remote control, COSTCO packaged food, and have it made.

Im going to disagree with you on this one. Darts are free and people come and have a great time. Darters Ive seen drink more and are more appreciated than the pool players which blows me away. You would think someone would get it. One just costs a tad more to maintain but they are customers just the same.
 
sexiness in sports

You're right, Joe. That was a bit sarcastic, and I apologize. I woke up on the wrong side of this bed this morning, and ran into a wall.
I still like the part about the naked pool players, though. :)

There's nothing wrong with sexiness in sports. ;)

638944671_d9afd77f91.jpg
 
Back
Top