Different cues behave with different tips. You can have say for example, A true graphite cue, no foam or wood filling. Try a bunch of different tips and find one that suits you and the cue. The tip that works great on the graphite cue, when put onto a wooden cue will be quit different. You may get more or less English, it may feel softer on the wood cue. When you get 3 people , same cue and try different tips ,You will get 3 different opinions on what they think is the best tip for that cue.We have found that you can quite good draw with a phenolic break tip and they are really hard. You can get good draw with a soft tip as well. Then other tips may not draw quite as well on that cue. But put that tip on a graphite or another front end and it works well.
I don't think there is a 1 tip fits all. Some cues do well with Moori med , or Tiger Hard, or Talisman medium, or hard, just to name a few that we have tried on different cues. Also the radius and shape on the tip has an impact. Some like nickel , some like dime, and others like a compound radius that is a blend of everything. It becomes alot of trial and error to find what works best for you and your cue.
For me on my graphite cue I like the Moori med or the superpro , On the wooden Cue I like the Talisman hard , tiger hard, Triumph with the backing.
Neil LIckfold