Videographer gripe

Would you go to any sport and view it through a paper towel tube?
Hell no!!! My main gripe with watching videos of pool tournaments is
that the videographers think it's artsy fartsy to crop in tightly on some
shots so that when the ball is hit, you are prevented from seeing the
tracking of the cue ball. I think that most of us would to prefer to see
all of the play that takes place during a shot. Stop the zoom in and zoom
out crap and let us see the whole table during the shot process and
not just the zit on the side of the players face.
💯
Also, watching the full motion of the players arm during the execution of shots is really missed.

A common source of frustration for myself and other lovers of pool who I speak with.
 
As an example of player technique information, in post #7 at 36 seconds of the video there is a great shot of the break stroke, then at 41 seconds it switches to a different angle, and at 43 seconds it goes to another angle. I think that sequence is beautiful but I also think in subsequent breaks they could give an extended view of one of those angles with a little technical detail of form and performance.
 
Commentary is tough. I love when JJ is in the booth, as does everyone else I think. But not all can do it like him so I make due.

The camera angle thing kills me though. I do appreciate free streams and I give my super chat donations and shit to help the cause but I think we should all bombard csi with messages asking them to reevaluate their camera work.

The camera changes angles at the absolute worst time, pretty much every time someone’s shooting. And always when they’re shooting a shot with tricky position where you really wanna see the cue ball. Nope. Look at this pocket while waiting for the ball to show up. What?!? Noooo. Noooooooooooo!!

I’m pretty sure it’s csi that does it. I’ll have to pay attention to that before I start my bitching
He is the first one I mute. He speaks in a monotone voice, like Keanu Reeves, Chris Collingsworth, puts you to sleep. Boring as hell to listen to, no emotion, nearly a change in tone. He loves to hear himself talk, never comes up for air.
99% of the time I watch on a large screen TV, muted, with music on. I take it off mute for maybe a minute to hear the balls clicking, and that's it, back on mute. I'm fine watching, don't have to hear commenting.
The last 10 ball stream felt like I was watching it through binoculars from the wrong side.
I appreciate it all, send donations, will never say I can do it better, I know what I like, and don't like.
 
Instead of complaining, stream your own. The technology is good enough that you can stream from your phone, and hundreds, if not thousands will watch.
 
Instead of complaining, stream your own. The technology is good enough that you can stream from your phone, and hundreds, if not thousands will watch.
That's not really a legitimate response. What you are proposing is precisely the reason so much streaming sucks right now.

Thousand different people all doing it their own way. We need KOZOOM and it needs to sell showing rights.
 
I don't care if they zoom in to show the setup. Oftentimes it lets me know what the shooter is thinking and provides a preview of what to expect from the shot. But before the stroke, switch to a shot that shows contact with the cue ball, its contact with the object ball, and the path of the object ball and the cue ball rollout. And if you can't manage it live, always have a wide backup shot that shows the whole table so you can replay.
 
I don't care if they zoom in to show the setup. Oftentimes it lets me know what the shooter is thinking and provides a preview of what to expect from the shot. But before the stroke, switch to a shot that shows contact with the cue ball, its contact with the object ball, and the path of the object ball and the cue ball rollout. And if you can't manage it live, always have a wide backup shot that shows the whole table so you can replay.
And for Pete out loud! give us a replay as soon as the shot finishes, instead of making us watch the player walk around.
 
Accu stats and upstate al do a great job. I understand what you are saying. Too much of that this past few days.
 
They do this in most sports. I hate it too...

Football: When the quarterback has the ball, you can't see any of the wide receivers when they go down field.
Baseball: When the pitcher has the ball, you can't see any of the outfielders.
Hockey: When the puck is near one end of the ice, you can't see the goalie at the other end.
 
This might not be of interest to pool players, but Kozoom has started live streaming 3C past matches to which they have added commentary (the steam also includes pool matches but I haven't watched any of them). The commentary is particularly good when the commentators are Tjorborn Blomdal and Bert van Manen. They do as good a job as any cue sport commentators I've heard. And as one of THE top guys for 40 years and one who would get a lot of votes for GOAT, Blomdahl has and shares a tremendous amount of knowledge on some aspects many players never get to, position play and kiss avoidance (something near to my heart as my screen name shows. The production values are outstanding, as Kozoom has been videoing matches for a long long time.
 
Streaming for most part is bush league, the only stream I have personally viewed that were any good was Accustats.

OnTheRail that Fastlenny did was typical bush league production. He tried hard, but not something I would pay to watch.

Want quality you need more then one static camera. Plus crap audio.
 
Last edited:
Ability to use split screen would be a big help. As far as commentary, you would think there was no game going on. Stay focused. I don't really care what they would do as they constantly predict wrong. Just comment on the action.
I like when the old timers tell stories or talk about the players' histories. Bill Incardona and Grady Matthews were funny to listen to. At least 75% of pool is self explanatory and you can see where everything is. I do like when the announcers talk about some of the nuances of the game but for me they are largely there to break up the silence. They also don't need to make sure there is no silence, just not too much.
 
💯
Also, watching the full motion of the players arm during the execution of shots is really missed.

A common source of frustration for myself and other lovers of pool who I speak with.
Yes, a lot of lower budget streams have no light beyond the table or are framed so tightly that you can only see the table itself.
 
Back
Top