Which cloth for me?

Grilled Cheese

p.i.i.t.h.
Silver Member
Ok, first off I've used the search feature and read at least 30+ threads on cloth here in this sub forum. It was very helpful and I learned a lot, but I have questions that I didn't find answers for. I'm not being a lazy bum here looking for the easy way out.

My objective is to recover my table and try and match the conditions of the pool room I frequent as best as possible. Those conditions are quite speedy. It doesn't have to be perfect because I cannot recreate their conditions, but right now the difference is large. I don't mind a slight difference and I accept that I may not have a choice anyway.

Currently I have regular Simonis 860. It's about 1/2 through it's life. It plays like mud. Really slow. The reason why has to do with my conditions. In summer, with the AC cranking, my house can be anywhere from 76 at best to 79 degrees at worst. Mostly sits around 78. Humidity isn't extreme, but higher than the pool hall and compared to most of the rest of the country, it's moderate (I'm in Florida). That's why the table plays very slow. You have to really power the ball to get around the table. The bright side is, it really works out my stroke and I have good control. Unfortunately, at the pool hall the ball is flying all around and it takes me time to tune into the speed every visit. I almost have to resort to putting the ball. Regardless of my pool hall which is speedier than others, I'm still slower than the others.


At the moment I don't know what cloth the pool hall uses. But I do know it isn't Simonis for a fact. I can tell it's not Simonis and the owner also confirmed it to my good friend. But he doesn't tell everyone because there's that expectation that only Simonis is good. There are a lot of "Simonis Snobs" there, but they cannot tell it's not Simonis LOL. Everything is dandy as long as they keep thinking it's Simonis.


Other rooms have 860HR and it plays faster than 860, but still not as fast as what's in the room I frequent. The speed is pretty fast. However, it's not thin like 760. This cloth is thicker. I used to play on 760 up north and it's like your hand is on the slate. Anyway, this cloth has held up very well, has very few burn marks. I suspect it might be 3030 from what I've read here. If it is, it's my first and only interaction with it so that why I can't identify. I will ask the owner who I'm friendly with when I get the chance.

With my warm and humid conditions, which should I go with? Let's say they've got 3030 - should I get 760? If it's 860HR (it's not) should I go with 3030? Just an example to describe my thinking. Or don't even think about it and go with 760 since in my conditions nothing else will come close to being fast?

The only thing I fear is going with 3030 or 760 let's say and because they are higher nylon count they do well in the humidity and I end up too fast. I don't think that's likely, but it's hard to judge.

My understanding as far as speed goes, based on personal experience and adding in input from this forum goes like this from slowest to fastest:

860 > 860HR > 3030 > 760


Any input would be greatly appreciated. Thanks fellas.
 
...
My objective is to recover my table and try and match the conditions of the pool room I frequent as best as possible. ...

My understanding as far as speed goes, based on personal experience and adding in input from this forum goes like this from slowest to fastest:

860 > 860HR > 3030 > 760

Any input would be greatly appreciated. Thanks fellas.

Pretty hard to duplicate something when you don't know what it is. First order of biz is to determine what cloth the room uses.

The speed-o-checker you posted is correct.

At the temps you mentioned humidity is going to be an ongoing problem. A dehumidifier should help regardless of which cloth is used. Some will go to 760 and hope this offsets the humidity situation resulting in 860 conditions. It may to a point but controlling the humidity is the best solution. That along with a tight initial install and proper/frequent cleaning of the cloth and balls should help achieve consistent conditions for home play.

Tip - look under both sides of the table in the room and you may catch a marking on the cloth edge.
Both Simonis and Tour Edition are marked with the name/style.
 
Last edited:
If I don't see the room owner tomorrow, I'll just look under the table. Hopefully whomever did the tables didn't cut it off. (the mechanic who does these tables is terrible, but cheap. You get what you pay for, don't even get me started on the rails.)

Dehumidifier is probably going to be a no-go. I've also read through using the search feature that people with humid conditions use 760 and get 860 type play. If that is true, it would be acceptable. If that's 860 conditions in drier climate. I worry not to make the table too fast if that's possible, but reading around it seems that it's extremely unlikely due to the temp/humidity levles.

I'll find out what cloth is used the the pool hall and report back here tomorrow.
 
If I don't see the room owner tomorrow, I'll just look under the table. Hopefully whomever did the tables didn't cut it off. (the mechanic who does these tables is terrible, but cheap. You get what you pay for, don't even get me started on the rails.)
....

You should find 1 side with a finished edge - the other side typically being trimmed. Bring a flashlight.
 
if your 860 is "playing like mud" it may be loose.

i put some Championship Tournament cloth on my table and i loved it. it was, cheaper, tougher and faster than simonis 860.
 
Ok, first off I've used the search feature and read at least 30+ threads on cloth here in this sub forum. It was very helpful and I learned a lot, but I have questions that I didn't find answers for. I'm not being a lazy bum here looking for the easy way out.

My objective is to recover my table and try and match the conditions of the pool room I frequent as best as possible. Those conditions are quite speedy. It doesn't have to be perfect because I cannot recreate their conditions, but right now the difference is large. I don't mind a slight difference and I accept that I may not have a choice anyway.

Currently I have regular Simonis 860. It's about 1/2 through it's life. It plays like mud. Really slow. The reason why has to do with my conditions. In summer, with the AC cranking, my house can be anywhere from 76 at best to 79 degrees at worst. Mostly sits around 78. Humidity isn't extreme, but higher than the pool hall and compared to most of the rest of the country, it's moderate (I'm in Florida). That's why the table plays very slow. You have to really power the ball to get around the table. The bright side is, it really works out my stroke and I have good control. Unfortunately, at the pool hall the ball is flying all around and it takes me time to tune into the speed every visit. I almost have to resort to putting the ball. Regardless of my pool hall which is speedier than others, I'm still slower than the others.


At the moment I don't know what cloth the pool hall uses. But I do know it isn't Simonis for a fact. I can tell it's not Simonis and the owner also confirmed it to my good friend. But he doesn't tell everyone because there's that expectation that only Simonis is good. There are a lot of "Simonis Snobs" there, but they cannot tell it's not Simonis LOL. Everything is dandy as long as they keep thinking it's Simonis.


Other rooms have 860HR and it plays faster than 860, but still not as fast as what's in the room I frequent. The speed is pretty fast. However, it's not thin like 760. This cloth is thicker. I used to play on 760 up north and it's like your hand is on the slate. Anyway, this cloth has held up very well, has very few burn marks. I suspect it might be 3030 from what I've read here. If it is, it's my first and only interaction with it so that why I can't identify. I will ask the owner who I'm friendly with when I get the chance.

With my warm and humid conditions, which should I go with? Let's say they've got 3030 - should I get 760? If it's 860HR (it's not) should I go with 3030? Just an example to describe my thinking. Or don't even think about it and go with 760 since in my conditions nothing else will come close to being fast?

The only thing I fear is going with 3030 or 760 let's say and because they are higher nylon count they do well in the humidity and I end up too fast. I don't think that's likely, but it's hard to judge.

My understanding as far as speed goes, based on personal experience and adding in input from this forum goes like this from slowest to fastest:

860 > 860HR > 3030 > 760


Any input would be greatly appreciated. Thanks fellas.

You may be looking at the wrong reason for the speed of the tables in the pool room, it could be the cushions that are causing the faster playing tables than yours, what kind of tables are in the pool room?

Glen
 
if your 860 is "playing like mud" it may be loose.

We can rule that out because my cloth is on very tight. You can push on it with your fingers firmly, and it will not bunch up or stretch. When you get down to bridge a shot, like when you are stretching for a shot with an open bridge - the cloth does not move around the hand.



You may be looking at the wrong reason for the speed of the tables in the pool room, it could be the cushions that are causing the faster playing tables than yours, what kind of tables are in the pool room?

Glen


Actually, my cushions are faster. I have a Gold Crown III. They have Robertsons (Black Max) with f'ed up cushions. If I could rate them as fast, medium and dead...mine are a medium, theirs are a medium dead. Even though the cloth is pretty fast, having to move the ball around multiple rails is made tougher because of the slower cushions. On my table, it's the opposite. The cloth really slows the balls down quite a bit, but the cushions have good rebound. Still, the greater factor I feel is the cloth. The difference in cushions is there, but it's less significant than the cloth in my situation. When cushions are eliminated from the equation, the balls on those tables roll wayyyy more. Say I have a ball in the middle of the table, and I'm on the side rail. Shooting it into the side pocket. At the pool hall, I can hit it light and it will roll to the pocket using true pocket speed. If I try that same speed on mine, the object ball will stop anywhere from 2/3 to 3/4 of the way there.

That's one of my concerns with possibly going with too fast of a cloth. With my cushions being faster - I don't want the table to be crazy. I haven't used 760 in humid conditions to get a feel for how much it slows down.

Up in NY I played on some GCI's with 760 and fast cushions and it was dry weather. You barely hit the ball and you can go 3 rails. No stroke necessary. You can practically roll the OB to the pocket and get the CB anywhere. That's my definition of fast rails, fast cloth. That to me is almost unplayable for games like 9 ball or even 8 ball. The old timers like it for 14.1 so they can poke stroke everything and move the ball like a pro when they make those down table shots. To me it's like pinball.


My favorite cloth and cloth speed is 860HR. It's faster than 860, a bit slower than what is at the pool hall. It plays fast, but not so fast where the game of 9 ball is uncontrollable. Although I'm mostly an 8 ball player. It's perfect. A great all-around cloth that does it all well. Can play the wide open games, and can still play 14.1 just fine. BUT...that is in better climate controlled places. Even though it's HR, I have a feeling it won't play so well at home. And I only play on it at pool halls I rarely frequent. Trying to match the one I frequent. Not trying to get perfect. Trying to get somewhat close.


Sorry for being so long winded. I'm just pouring out how I rationalize it in my head. How I try and estimate.

I'll find tomorrow what cloth they have. Like I said, it feels thick like 860, but plays somewhere between 860HR and 760 in my guestimate. It's been on for almost a year and has very few and light burn marks. Whatever it is, it has survived longer and is in better shape than what they've used in the past. The color has also held up very well. Here's a perfect example. My medium-hard break always marks my 860. At the pool hall, it doesn't mark the table. Or the burn mark is so light I don't notice it.

A close friend of mine who used to play on the Florida Pro Tour came in to visit me. He never plays there. He was shooting some balls around and said, and I quote "What the f*** is this? 760?" ...so it is faster than 860HR which is what he plays on almost all the time. I felt better as then I knew it wasn't all in my head :p
 
cloth

if your 860 is "playing like mud" it may be loose.

i put some Championship Tournament cloth on my table and i loved it. it was, cheaper, tougher and faster than simonis 860.

_
Properly installed and properly maintained simonis will wear,play fast and more consistent than any cloth..period..
-
Rob.M
 
... Dehumidifier is probably going to be a no-go. I've also read through using the search feature that people with humid conditions use 760 and get 860 type play. ....

A good dehumidifier is the first choice for people with climate problems when a/c alone is not effective..
Had a loose cloth situation with a pool room in Chitown. Told them to turn on the a/c - problem solved.
When all else fails the "760 gets you 860 speed" may work but there's no guarantee. Humidity will affect 760 as well.

Once you determine what cloth the room has we can discuss further.
Which ball set are you using?
Frequency and manner you clean the cloth/balls?
I'd also like to see a pic of your table and a closeup of the cloth grain.
 
Last edited:
Once you determine what cloth the room has we can discuss further.

Milliken Super Pro :banghead:

I never even heard of it. That's why I was guessing 3030 or possibly even some kind of Gorina. With the exception of this Milliken SuperPro in this specific instance, all I've ever played on was 860, 860HR and 760. I knew it wasn't Simonis, just didn't know what other brand it was.

Which ball set are you using?

Super Aramith Pro.

Frequency and manner you clean the cloth/balls?

Fairly often. I'm not obsessive to clean them daily, but they always have a luster. They always look new like the day I got them. They don't have that dull look that dirty balls get.

I'd also like to see a pic of your table and a closeup of the cloth grain.

I couldn't get a pic. But to me the grain of the cloth is tighter or more dense than Simonis.
 
I looked up the Milliken SuperPro cloth and it too is a 70/30 Wool to Nylon blend. Don't know if that alone is the factor for humidity resistance. That's the same percentage blend as 860HR, 760, and 3030...
 
I wasn't aware there was a 760HR.

Me either....And no one has told their website if they have.:)

A full range of the finest cloth for every game and speed.

Simonis 760™ - The original worsted blend

Simonis 860™ - The American standard

Simonis 860 HR™ - A true hybrid

Simonis 300 Rapide™ - The world standard for carom

Simonis 4000 English Snooker - True directional nap Snooker cloth for snooker only
 
Last edited:
I wasn't aware there was a 760HR.

News to me too - and I talk to the pres of Simonis NA all the time.

Anyway - the super pro at the pool room is in the same ballpark as 760 and 3030. There's nothing really humidity-resistant about any of them - but all faster than 860. You say your cloth is tight, top ball set and you clean the cloth so hard to say why your 860 is slow - maybe you're just used to the faster cloth at the room. Either way if you want pool room speed then it would seem the super pro, 760 or 3030 would be the way to go. JMO.
 
The 760 is more of a humidy resistant "HR" kind of cloth because of the 70/30 wool/nylon blend, but as far as what the "HR" high resistant today, it's not because it'll show the break lines and rack marks still, where the "HR" of today won't. But the 760 is more designed to play 14.1, 8 Ball, banks, or snooker, where the track lines are not so established in the surface of the cloth, and when speed is needed.

The Mil Super Pro cloth is faster than Simonis 860 because it's thinner, which gives less resistance to ball roll. If you felt the two together, you clearly feel the difference.

Glen
 
Back
Top