Why break for the 8 in APA

And the most butt hurt replies seem to come from folks who aren't in it.
Why even play APA in the first place. In 40yrs of playing pool the most nitty/butthurt arguments i've ever seen/heard of have been in APA related play. No one wants to improve, they are scared shitless they might actually have to play someone that's an iota better than they are.
The OP wants clean tables he can run. Don't we all. My suggestion is quit, and then go on complaining about the league for the next 40 years.
 
And the most butt hurt replies seem to come from folks who aren't in it.

The OP wants clean tables he can run. Don't we all. My suggestion is quit, and then go on complaining about the league for the next 40 years.
i was in the APA and hated it ... i didnt like waiting around to play, didnt like taking score, dont like playing on 7ft table (just not enjoyable). i would rather walkin matchup and then gtfo ... let who won the money make the score ... lose /get better and do it again ... win / great see how much you can make. you get more out of it this way.

if i want to go to las vegas... im not letting that decision ride on the outcome of some lame APA event
 
And the most butt hurt replies seem to come from folks who aren't in it.

The OP wants clean tables he can run. Don't we all. My suggestion is quit, and then go on complaining about the league for the next 40 years.
I played in multiple leagues over the yrs. All were petty and nitty to some degree but the crown jewel of nittiness is easily APA. People that couldn't run four balls if their life was riding on it would get into fights over some of the most chickenshit rules squabbles like "where does the 8b go if a mousefart makes it fall it in". ;)
 
Last edited:
I've played in a few different leagues, including APA. Most people don't run out in all of them. Without these leagues, there will be no pool in America.
League/barbox pool has 'dumbed down' pool in this country beyond belief. No other country plays on them thus the US's inability to compete on the world stage on 9ft tables. I know, most league bangers barely know 9fts exist but little tables are the reason. Think the US's horrible track record in the MC the last 20yrs is just bad luck?
 
League/barbox pool has 'dumbed down' pool in this country beyond belief. No other country plays on them thus the US's inability to compete on the world stage on 9ft tables. I know, most league bangers barely know 9fts exist but little tables are the reason. Think the US's horrible track record in the MC the last 20yrs is just bad luck?
I'm not saying it's why we aren't better on the world stage, that seems obvious. I'm saying that league pool IS American pool. Without it, most pool rooms would close down and the whole game would likely shrivel up and die. It hasn't "ruined American pool", it IS American pool.
 
I played in multiple leagues over the yrs. All were petty and nitty to some degree but the crown jewel of nittiness is easily APA. People that couldn't run four balls if their life was riding on it would get into fights over some of the most chickenshit rules squabbles like "where does the 8b go if a mousefart makes it fall it in". ;)
We must have different definitions of a nit. I've run APA leagues for a long time, and by far (and I mean FAR) the nittiest ones are the ones that also play other leagues. The rest just want to have a good time, and nitpicking rules (that's where "nit" comes from, right?) just isn't a good time for them. There are plenty of players in the other leagues who aren't nits, but most of the nits come from that crossover crowd, at least in my experience. Maybe it's just sheer size that makes it appear more prevalent - if it's 1% across the board you'll see it 10X as often in a league that's 10X larger.
 
And the most butt hurt replies seem to come from folks who aren't in it.

The OP wants clean tables he can run. Don't we all. My suggestion is quit, and then go on complaining about the league for the next 40 years.
That’s not it. I can run an ugly table too. When you play your girlfriend/wife with a weak break long enough you get pretty good at working in tight areas. I’m just trying to get opinions here.

Anybody else have the predator break speed app on their phone? The app works great, but doesn’t always give accurate readings when it’s noisy in the hall. My break avg is around 24mph according to it. Most others that I have clocked have avg around 16-18mph. A couple of my buddies got around 20mph. How accurate is the app? Maybe that’s why I make the 8 without trying

there is an 8 ball break from the middle that works just as often as the side one and you get a better spread. Sometimes you do scratch on that one if you are off a little, but everyone seems to use the side one.
 
Last edited:
That’s not it. I can run an ugly table too. When you play your girlfriend/wife with a weak break long enough you get pretty good at working in tight areas. I’m just trying to get opinions here.

Anybody else have the predator break speed app on their phone? The app works great, but doesn’t always give accurate readings when it’s noisy in the hall. My break avg is around 24mph according to it. Most others that I have clocked have avg around 16-18mph. A couple of my buddies got around 20mph. How accurate is the app? Maybe that’s why I make the 8 without trying

And On another note there is an 8 ball break from the middle that works just as often as the side one and you get a better spread. Sometimes you do scratch on that one if you are off a little, but everyone seems to use the side one.
In my experience, the way that I break, hitting the side break too hard causes me more problems. I medium speed break gets me better results at getting the 8 moving. For me. Your mileage may vary, heh heh.
 
I have been breaking second ball in 8 for 40 years.

It is all about reading the rack, and getting a solid hit on the second ball. If the 8 ball goes in that is gravy. For me, I break better this way, and have more chances getting a ball on the break.
Coming late to the thread and figured I wouldn't be the first to rely on the second ball break in 8 ball on a bar table. A break favored by the Grand Masters of the game. With the game of 8 ball being , "The Old Man's game" go figure. 🤷‍♂️
Mosconi taught it so, I learned and perfected it. Had a pretty good percentage on making the 8 ball but that's only the bonus. The bread and butter is the more delicate maneuvers required to navigate the clustered balls. Giving the knowledge and skills advantage over sheer fire power. 9 ball is the young man's game. 🤷‍♂️
 
In my experience, the way that I break, hitting the side break too hard causes me more problems. I medium speed break gets me better results at getting the 8 moving. For me. Your mileage may vary, heh heh.
I like to kill em. But there is a problem with breaking hard too. If you break hard with top the cb can fly off the table especially if the head ball is off. It’s also a way to intentionally fly it off towards the guy/girl racking if he/she keeps leaving it off……..that’s always fun.


For us middle breakers that don’t like complaining-if the head ball is off on the left side break just right of center and vice versa with draw for optimal results. That’s if you have a hard break.
 
League/barbox pool has 'dumbed down' pool in this country beyond belief. No other country plays on them thus the US's inability to compete on the world stage on 9ft tables. I know, most league bangers barely know 9fts exist but little tables are the reason. Think the US's horrible track record in the MC the last 20yrs is just bad luck?

It’s not the leagues that are the problem, if all the people arguing over whether or not the cue ball grazed a rail before pocketing the object ball down at Jim’s Corner Tavern joined a league, the American Pool scene would be a better place.

The belief that playing safe is “sissy pool” is far more damaging than anything the APA can do, as it makes even watching pro-pool incomprehensible to bar players, especially 9-ball where “slop counts”

As far as bar boxes go, if you’re allowed in the bar you’re too old to go pro anyway.
 
For us middle breakers that don’t like complaining-if the head ball is off on the left side break just right of center and vice versa with draw for optimal results
Reminds me of the times my opponent thought they were bad racking me but actually gave the 8 ball a better chance to go straight to the side. Just a little gap between the first and next ball on either side. I always inspected and accepted every rack. Well back when the 8 ball break had a kitty. 🤷‍♂️
 
Hi I’m just looking for opinions on this. To me breaking for the 8 is just a hinderance. Why do so many people break for the 8 in APA?

It just seems worthless to me. I don’t break for the 8 and still broke it in 4 times over the past two sessions. Seems like most of the people breaking for it will end up flooding one side of the table with balls. And when the 8 doesn’t fall most of those players don’t have the capacity to deal with the cluster. So why do it? Is it for the patch/chip. Or for the free win from time to time? Or do you like playing on garbage tables all the time?

I’m under the impression that it’s just a waste of time. I feel like it will go in occasionally anyway and if it’s for a chip, doesn’t getting a break and run chip feel better? It does to me.
I can understand doing it for a grand slam though. I guess that would be a good reason. But it’s also the only one I can think of.


Like I said. Looking for opinions on it. I gave mine. Not trying to start an argument. Just wondering what the mental process is that makes people think it’s good to break for it.

All the reasons why a 2nd ball break is a smart choice in APA can be found via the videos and info here:


Enjoy!
 
Dialing in the 8 ball break.
In the course of tournament play the rack and table tendencies can be learned. Rack areas can take a set and close observation can be rewarded.
My favorite 8 ball victory in a race to 4 on 8 foot bar boxs came with 3 nearly made the 8 on the Break. My opponent was honest and giving a good rack. I had played a couple of early matches on the table. The tables that tended to make a wing ball would get a harder break. The break and run was in play. Tables that were stingy with balls on the Break got a medium speed. Clustered balls were My Briar Patch. 😉
So the 3 near missed 8 balls started with the first break going just slightly long. The second break got an adjustment in where I struck the cueball. Just a little bit lower but I overadjusted and the 8 hit the rail just short. So my 3rd break had the perfect strike to the cueball and the 8 was heading right into the heart of the pocket. Just inches from the pocket another ball intercepted and kept it on the table. 🤷‍♂️ I still won the match and went on to win my first "Big Boys" tournament.
 
Reminds me of the times my opponent thought they were bad racking me but actually gave the 8 ball a better chance to go straight to the side. Just a little gap between the first and next ball on either side. I always inspected and accepted every rack. Well back when the 8 ball break had a kitty. 🤷‍♂️
or when they don't get the rack squared up, tilted a little in one direction...my eyes get real big when I get a good look at the whole second ball 😉

I never put the cue ball down where I intend to break from until they're done racking, leaving it near the back rail.
 
or when they don't get the rack squared up, tilted a little in one direction...my eyes get real big when I get a good look at the whole second ball 😉

I never put the cue ball down where I intend to break from until they're done racking, leaving it near the back rail.
I loved the times that they offered to fix, after I had made a brief inspection. Without prompting they would ask if I wanted them to "fix it?". They could probably see the twinkle in my eye as I was preparing to break a rack that I knew. 🤷‍♂️
 
I got roasted by Vitaly Friday. I’d break for the 8 against him. lol.

Worst part was I didn’t know who he was so I went for a tight cut on 1 off my first break instead of rolling out and missed it. But at least I had a nice little safe battle with him for a game in the short set(straight race to 4). Alternating break 10 ball he broke and ran twice, I missed twice. That’s all she wrote…
 
Last edited:
Back
Top