The Germans have a saying that goes something like this, 'a new broom sweeps better'. It is used in the context of decribing the belief that new things are better simply because they are better. As we, and the Germans, know this is not true all the time but we want to believe it when trying or contemplating something new.
As to why you can love the hit of different cues; they all have something to love. In truth most good pool cues work within a close range of performance with the differences being very subjective.
I have owned cues that one day I loved and the next day I couldn't play with. I think a lot of how a cue plays has to do with the shooter's frame of mind and physical actions. This is speaking of cues that are made well with no obvious issues to keep them from working.
If I am clear headed and feel good, and am stroking well then it seems as if most cues feel really good to me. But if I am not feeling well then I tend to get really picky about the way the cue hits.
Still there are cues that stand out for me no matter how I feel. Every Gilbert, every Joss West, almost every Scruggs I have owned or shot with has been great each time I picked them up as far as I can remember. The only Scruggs I touched that I didn't like was my friend's ivory jointed 3/8x10 pin one. It was a great performing cue but it always felt odd to me.
Anyway, I long for the days when I was in love with my McDermott D-1, smoky grey stain, black irish linen wrap. I had no idea about the plethora of cues out there. And in fact back then in 1988 there weren't such a wide variety out there. No idea about the billiards biz. I was just a player with a cue that worked great for me.

I do remember though that I was quite envious of my friend's Joss and later another player's Schon. For many years those were the cues I wanted to acquire and I did. I bought my first Schon from Danny Barouty. Instead of repairing my car I bought the cue. The first night I had it I took the bus to the poolroom and won enough to pay for the repair to my car.
Anyway, the thing with switching cues is that we are all searching for the "perfect hit". So when you pick up another cue and immediately you do something that you feel you aren't able to do with your regular player you definitely get that magic feeling we are all looking for.
At least that's how I experience it.
