Thanks for the input.
Both appear too light for a match.
Digging around I found Brazilwood and Chakte Viga, but the grain just didn't look right.
I found an old post that had an old Dufferin catalog. The text was very blurry, but I was able to make out one cue not pictured that mentioned Pau Marfin. It kind of fits, but also a bit too light.
Thinking about not only the look, but the cost aspect as well, Sapele still fits better so far. I figure a full solid one piece of wood on a basic cue would not be an exotic expensive wood.
The wood does have some chatoyance which fits the sapele as well.