Yapp’s Controversial Tournament-Winning Shot in the 8-Ball World Championship … Was it a Foul?

Dr Dave your previous instructional videos in this area have helped immensely in determining "bad/questionable" hits on balls. Whether video was available, the reaction of the cueball following the path of the eight ball should have been the determining factor for the referee to call a bad hit. Here's where referee's training and general knowledge is most important in their roles as "judges." Thank you.

Super Billiards Expo 2026

Thanks for sharing your perspective on Mosconi Cup hopefuls and the idea of “numerous contenders.” I see it a bit differently, and that’s okay. We don’t have to agree on everything.

I don’t believe the majority of Americans in this event are truly chasing the Cup for ranking points. I understand you’ve been a strong supporter of the Matchroom and WNT over the years. I used to be as well. But when I started to notice what I felt was favoritism, it took some of the shine off for me. And then there was the WNT Filler prohibition, which I won't go into. You and I do agree on an aspect of the aftermath.

Even with increased prize money in U.S.-based WNT events, I’m not convinced it’s enough. A $40,000 first-place prize today doesn’t go nearly as far as it once did. Honestly, it feels comparable to $10,000 back in the ’80s. Meanwhile, the cost of living of hotels, airfare, gas, and just surviving on the road has skyrocketed. Living out of a suitcase isn’t cheap, and unless you’ve truly lived that grind, worrying about how to pay bills back home, not able to hold a full-time job due because of constant travel, going without health insurance, and sacrificing stability just to chase ranking points, it’s easy to underestimate how difficult it really is, especially for those fortunate enough to be looking at it from the comfort of an ivory tower.

Sponsorships in the U.S. often don’t provide real financial support either. Many players receive product instead of cash, which is why you see them selling and/or auctioning cues and equipment online to raise funds for expenses, and those sponsors only give product to top pros, not aspiring pros who pay their own way while keeping their bills up to date back home. And on top of all that, they still have to compete against the best players in the world, whether at home or abroad.

I could go on, just like you have, but I’ll leave it at this. We’ll have to agree to disagree on some topics. :)
If you're a "pro" tournament player doesn't that mean travel is a necessary part of your job?

Just get a job and be done with it if you can't afford it. I'd love to play poker full-time but I'd be living in my car and robbing car washes/laundromats to survive. So, I have a full-time job, it's really that simple.

Making $18,000/year as a pro player seems like a good way to end up destitute 🤷‍♂️

How Many of You...

...have dropped an expensive piece of chalk down the pocket of a Diamond table.

I have done it about three times and have been able to retrieve two. Now, I've kinda trained myself to be more careful but sheet-at happens. Just a couple of days ago a brand new piece of green Pyro came tumbling down the ball return -- so sad for someone but then I'm just around break even, lol.

Lou Figueroa
I haven't done it once. I try to place it in the middle of the rail.

kollegedave

Yapp’s Controversial Tournament-Winning Shot in the 8-Ball World Championship … Was it a Foul?

Two things I disagree with, you said if you were FSR you would be challenging the call, but his view of the table was blocked by Yapp who was directly infront of him as he played the shot so realistically FSR didn't know what happened so was never going to say anything. Wonder what he thinks of it now.

And you think the ref should have taken longer, but someone announced over the tannoy that Yapp was champion almost as soon as the black went in, so that opportunity was taken out of her hands. I feel like the person on the tannoy is partially responsible for it not to have been properly reviewed, pretty hard to roll back a decision after you've publicly announced the champion.

Yapp’s Controversial Tournament-Winning Shot in the 8-Ball World Championship … Was it a Foul?

in many situation like this, refs need to be able to anticipate the foul when players prepare for the shot.

we can see many of them are focused, cannot say they are not, but they dont or not able to anticipate the foul

for shots like jump shots, the anticipation of cueball hitting obstable ball or like finger touching balls, it is easier to anticipate than object balls close to each other or object ball close to rails and anticipating which was hit first

and that anticipation requires playing background, i think.
Do you think they should intervene - if only for a better look?

Yapp’s Controversial Tournament-Winning Shot in the 8-Ball World Championship … Was it a Foul?

in many situation like this, refs need to be able to anticipate the foul when players prepare for the shot.

we can see many of them are focused, cannot say they are not, but they dont or not able to anticipate the foul

for shots like jump shots, the anticipation of cueball hitting obstable ball or like finger touching balls, it is easier to anticipate than object balls close to each other or object ball close to rails and anticipating which was hit first

and that anticipation requires playing background, i think.

Filter

Back
Top