I have no idea how this thread got away from us like it has.
I may have gotten up on the wrong side of the bed yesterday and may have just interpreted the tone as somewhat elitist and that Charlie should not tell the people on AZ what happens here.
Dennis, my comment of "I'm not backing down on this" was purely from a personal standpoint, meaning that I'm not apologizing for feeling the way I do on this. My bat, my ball, my rules? That implies you think I'm making some kind of policy at Amsterdam on this - maybe you misunderstood?
I have the impression that you have been involved in Amsterdam Straight Pool for quite a while and to me, you are the voice of Amsterdam. At least an informal voice of the Amsterdam Straight Pool League here on AZB.
If someone's performance in a rather informal game is going to become fodder for the internet, I have no problem with that. I just think he should be made aware of it beforehand. If you don't let him know, then you don't know how seriously he was taking the game. I don't know; maybe everyone else always bears down in a league match or a friendly game, but I don't. I'm not saying I never do. I'm just saying, if I know the match is going to be discussed on the internet, then I will make sure to play hard.
Dennis, it is your call whether you write about your games with the hundred ball runner in your league. All I'm saying is that reporting the score with him, when you don't even know if he was taking the match seriously, isn't something I'd do. Also note that when I say "taking the match seriously", I don't mean that he was taking you lightly. I mean, sometimes a guy is dead tired, or has work on his mind, or is drinking, or is fighting with his girlfriend, and he's content to just sit back and knock some balls around.
I really don't even understand what is controversial about any of this.
Isn't this just common etiquette to let a guy know that? I don't even understand how this is controversial.
I guess I don't really agree. If someone sees you playing X and asks how you did, can you tell that someone? If someone asks if there were any high runs, can you tell that? In our non-league games that happens routinely. In our leagues that happens routinely. In our tournaments, that happens too.
If people are free to discuss their matches, I think they should be free to discuss them on the internet.
I actually think it is good for the game to get some discussion of games, results, runs out in the world. The owner at Red Shoes asked me to put something out there about some of the 14.1 tournament results and I did. I talked about how someone was playing Hunter close until he pulled away. I threw in something about a big run the player may have had in the previous week. A bit of puffing but good for the game I think.
In the example I gave above, I may have painted the match a little closer than it actually was. The reason could be to make the other player feel better about his game and more enthusiastic about improving. It might make another non-player think the gap is maybe not so big between the pros and the league players and maybe I can reach my goals. Even if in my heart of hearts, I know, and Hunter knows that the gap will never be closed, it gives others something to strive for.
These others then may become the fans of 14.1 that fly out to New Jersey to watch the real pros do it right. They pay to spectate and help keep 14.1 going. I think in the long run, it helps the top players.
Now that I know Charlie will be writing about my game with him, I'm going to be playing my hardest. That doesn't mean I will even win - but at least whatever happens, I can be comfortable that I was given fair notice. I will know that he will be writing about a game, win or lose, where we were both trying our hardest.
He may have a target on his back now and that is too bad.
Let me reiterate, as I think my point somehow got lost.
- Charlie was very respectful in how he wrote about Chris.
- I think Charlie should be able to write about the games.
- I do not think he needs to ask permission.
- I just think he should let his opponent know that he might discuss it on the internet.
- I think that if he doesn't ask permission, he's perfectly entitled to discuss the games, and even the names, just without the scores.
I think it's great what Charlie wants to do with writing about the games.
- Steve
So maybe it is the scores and how it looks to the untutored eye.
Dennis
p.s.
Steve: I love what you have done for the game and what you continue to do for the game and I love the way you play the game. From my perspective, I just think it does not hurt 14.1 in general, to get this stuff out there. It gets more people talking about 14.1, trying to improve, believing they can do it, and helping in various ways support the game.
JMO