Pool’s Most Fabulous Game
Hands down, pool’s most fabulous game is One-Pocket…but not for the reasons usually attributed to the game. Volumes have been written and much has been said about the virtues and nuances of One-Pocket. I will offer a different perspective venturing away from conventional wisdom.
What makes One-Pocket so fabulous is participation. Both players participate. Near equal participation heightens interaction and makes the competition better. Both players are continuously up out of their chair, addressing the table, and taking their shot(s). No one sits (for very long). Play is back and forth, and back and forth. An example of perfect competition is tennis where players take turns hitting the ball and in addition, each player influences his opponent’s shots. One-Pocket resembles tennis in this way. Fabulous!
Some further thoughts about participation: Pool culture holds the 526 ball run and the 11-pack as examples of perfect pool. I think differently. I think these are pool’s examples of perfect disasters.
All other sports have got it figured out. We do not. In baseball, you are going to get your 9 innings and 3 outs per inning. In basketball and football, at the very least, you are going get your chance after your opponent scores. In golf, you will tee-off 18 times and you will get to putt the ball in the hole 18 times. In bowling you will roll the ball 11 times for sure.
There is not one rule in Eight, Nine, or Ten-Ball that guarantees a player will actually get his chance to shoot (only to break). Does anyone think that we help our cause by having rules that provide for the chance of grossly lopsided participation? If everyone wonders “What’s wrong with pool?”, this may very well be it. Our favorite games could be fatally flawed.
We need to take a lesson from other sports. People must have regular and predictable opportunities to play during a match just like every other successful sport. Merely alternating breaks does not guarantee a player a chance to shoot. It only guarantees that he breaks. The “No Conflict Rules” guarantees a player will shoot.
http://www.goldcrownbilliardseriepa.com/noconflict.html
The net result is that the matches are much closer, the stronger player wins more often, and the weaker player gets to shoot more. Most importantly, our popular games are more fun. This is a win-win for everyone and the game.
I will run my third event using the “No Conflict Rules” in August.
There is a lot to disagree with in this post. Do you have something insightful or intelligent to say. Fire it up!