My take on Day 2 of Earl-Shane

"CaliRed".

High Def Videos!!!
Silver Member
Earl came with some new equipment, some ear protectors. He wore them most of the night and also had ear plugs in, in addition to the ear muffs. This really helped out in the ranting at the crowd issue, that was prevalent in Day 1.

The worst of the antics that went on tonight, were the involving the cueball once again and the break. Almost every time Shane would break, Earl would wait until he was down in his stance and then fly out of his chair and check that Shane had the cueball behind the line. You could really tell Shane was getting upset about this. Sometimes he would get out of his stance, sometimes he would wait until Earl checked it, then pick up the cueball and put it back down after Earl had checked it. But you could really see the disgust in Shane at this shark move by Earl. Towards the middle of the match, Shane went out in the crowd and found Mike Gulassy (sp) and had a discussion with him, then Mike talked to Earl and Earl had a fit about that. That stopped it for a little while.

The other antic was that Shane would inspect every rack that Earl made and that ticked off Earl. Apparently it was ok for Earl to check Shane's cueball was NOT ok for Shane to check the rack.:confused: It also ticked off Earl when Shane would lightly touch the outsides of the rack to make them tighter. As you might have read in other threads, during a break, Earl went to this Gallagher equipment bag and pulled out the Sherlock Holmes edition of a magnifying glass and inspected the rack. He would do this several times thruout the night.:)

As far as the playing, Earl came out swinging in the beginning and won many of the first 20 games or so. At one point, Shane was down 18 games. Shane was having the same problem as last night, many balls close to the rail were giving him problems. He was also getting out of line again on many shots.

When Earl is shooting, he is very loose and very confident. He takes maybe 2 practice strokes and shoots. All shots are the same, no indecision or doubt in him making the ball. It is a little hard to explain, but someone watching can see the difference between the two players. I'm trying to find the right word to describe this and will use "doubt" for lack of a better term. When Earl shoots, all shots are shot without any doubt they are going in. When Shane shoots, there is doubt, especially on most balls along the rail.

I watched the entire Morra/Dominguez match, and it has the same feeling to it, with Shane. There is doubt in his demeanor when shooting a lot of the shots along the rail. And he does miss a lot of them. The pocket is rejecting the balls much more for Shane, then Earl. Shane shoots a lot of the shots along the rail softly, and misses them. Earl almost never shoots them softly. The ones that Shane shoots with some speed, same problem. Some of Shane's misses are because they are not in the heart of the pocket, but others seem like they are, and still come out.

Now I fell asleep for 2 hours about 10:45 - 12:45. Shane was behind by about 14 or so then and when I woke up, he was only down by about 6. Without even seeing the score, it was very apparent by watching Shane's demeanor at the table, that he was shooting like normal Shane. There was no doubt in his shots, his stroke was confident. It was night and day between what I had seen the last 2 days, and what I was watching then. Over the next couple of hours, I watched Shane get back down again by 11 or so, but there was still some confidence in his stroke.

In the pre-match interviews, when Justin asked what he was going to do differently tonight, Shane said "slow the game down". He was going to play more safes. Which has been a factor in why Earl is so much ahead. Shane will run 5 or 6 balls, get out of line and still shoot a difficult shot. A difficult shot is defined much differently on this 10 ft with the way the pockets are, then on normal 9 ft'ers. He would miss and Earl would clean up the last 4 balls.

Shane did not stick to that game plan very well. There were moments where he did do that, but for the most part, it is very hard for him to play safe when he has made those shots thousands of times before. If Shane was confident and not "scared" at those pockets, he would make the shots, but it's tough when you see Shane really bear down on a easy shot and then miss it. That will make you "scared" of the shots.

So to summarize.... Earl plays like he's playing on any other table, fast and loose. He is playing run out pool and shooting with a high degree of confidence. Earl is also playing excellent shape and rarely gets out of line. Shane on the other hand, is really struggling with the table. He played like regular Shane only for a few hours. He is gun shy of the pockets. He also gets out of line a lot.

If Shane can get that confidence again tonight, then he could make up those 10 or 11 games. It's going to be tough, but it could happen. If he stlll has that "am I going to miss this one" demeanor, then there will be no way he can win. I see Earl once again playing at a high level, so Shane's only chance is to run the balls and play safe if it's a tough shot. Tough shot is defined by this table, not his past history with the thousands of other tables he's played on, but THIS table.

Props to Earl for displaying supreme confidence and mastery of the 10 ft table. Props to Shane for not giving up and continuing to fight this table to try and master it. Also props to Shane for fading all the Earl antics. That is almost a full time job doing that.:D

Some various pics....

Pics 1 and 2, are examples of tough shots that have Shane gun shy. Any shot involving the object ball within being froze to 4 inches or so out from the rail, is giving Shane fits.

Pic 3 is the tension that happens when Earl is racking and Shane comes over to inspect it after he's done

Pic 4 is a rare moment of levity, after they got done for the night. Earl came over and shook Shane's hand. Shane doesn't say anything, just smiles. That smile could very well be fake, IMHO:D

Pic 5 is what happens when you get home field advantage. Kinda like you might expect Bruce's dressing room looks like in Jersey, and the opening act The Streaming MuffDaddys looks like.:wink:
shane1.jpg
shane2.jpg
shane5.jpg
shane10.jpg
shanebarstool.jpg
 
interesting

Thanks for that very detailed and insightful analysis and account.....
I haven't seen any of this, but from what I've read, it seems Earl's big edge is the 10 ft. table. I have played on one of those old tables before, and it is SO different from the 9 ft. table that Shane is probably used to. I have to think the results might be very different if they were playing on a 9-footer.
 
Good write-up. I loved the pictures taken from Print Screen. It is nice to see Shane smile, and it is also funny to see Earl's "thrown." :thumbup:
 
Hmmm

That's a darn good observation from last night......can't wait for tonight...
 
uh huh

Good write-up. I loved the pictures taken from Print Screen. It is nice to see Shane smile, and it is also funny to see Earl's "thrown." :thumbup:

That is funny; there seems to be a symbolism here.....If this is Earl's "home court", that is some psychological prop.....as if Earl is "royalty" and Shane is just one of the common folk.....Most every other matchup I've seen has the same chairs for both players......I wonder how this disparity came about?
 
I remember seeing Shane useing the bridge 3 times maybe 4.
As far as Earl watching the cue ball on the break I believe most of that was about Shane fiddling with about 90% of the racks. Witch sort of started irritating me just watching Shane do it. That was the whole reason behind the magnify glass. It was like Shane was sharking Earl with that.
 
I agree with your observations. A small thing that I noticed, but I think it's extremely important; Shane has been ending his practice sessions with a miss. I think he should end his practice session with a decisive center of the pocket shot to start off on a positive note rather than a bit of a defeatist attitude. With Earl during the practice session, he finished with several center of the pocket shots. Credit to Shane in hanging in there and cutting a bit of Earl's lead from a high of 18 games up to 10 games up, and looking forward to the battle this evening. ;)
 
Almost every time Shane would break, Earl would wait until he was down in his stance and then fly out of his chair and check that Shane had the cueball behind the line. You could really tell Shane was getting upset about this. Sometimes he would get out of his stance, sometimes he would wait until Earl checked it, then pick up the cueball and put it back down after Earl had checked it. But you could really see the disgust in Shane at this shark move by Earl.

Nice writeup! :)

At this critical juncture of the match, it's important for Shane to stay focused and not give Earl an opportunity to shark and distract him. When breaking, Shane should move his cue ball 1/4-inch further behind the head string. The slight cue ball adjustment won't impact his break but may reduce the number of times Earl tries to shark him.

Go get 'em, Shane! :cool:
 
Nice observations Cali...

My thoughts: This is an epic matchup. Sort of good against evil. Huge props to TAR. In a day and age of overpaying for just about everything....this is the best 25 bucks I've ever spent.

Earl: I really think the majority of his nonsense is strategic sharking. I do think he's nuts....but I think he gets a pass on alot of his bull$hit because people attribute it to his lack of sanity. I think its mostly premeditated strategy. No one in the pool world would get away with the crap Earl does. Which is a shame because he is certainly in the conversation of one of the greatest pool players ever. Unfortunately Earl's legacy will be stained/defined by his poor sportsmanship and just being a flat out A$$.

Shane: What a class act. Sick pool skills...I could throw superlative after superlative in trying to describe Shane and still fall short. American pool couldn't be represented any better. Earl has pushed about every button he could....and shane has remained unflappable. I'm not sure whats better his stroke or his mental toughness.

Lastly: I didn't tune in last night till around 10pm. I told the girlfriend after dinner " I'm going to at least check out the score of the match between Shane and Earl" We start watching and she starts rolling at Earl and all his antics. We ended up watching it till she left at around midnight(of course I watched it till completion) This morning she call and her first question was "How did Shane and Earl end up" ? "I think I'm hooked on this pool thing.

All the above aside this has been a incredible event. Hopefully the completion tonight is as good as the first two parts. Go Shane!!!!
 
Nice observations Cali...

My thoughts: This is an epic matchup. Sort of good against evil. Huge props to TAR. In a day and age of overpaying for just about everything....this is the best 25 bucks I've ever spent.

Earl: I really think the majority of his nonsense is strategic sharking. I do think he's nuts....but I think he gets a pass on alot of his bull$hit because people attribute it to his lack of sanity. I think its mostly premeditated strategy. No one in the pool world would get away with the crap Earl does. Which is a shame because he is certainly in the conversation of one of the greatest pool players ever. Unfortunately Earl's legacy will be stained/defined by his poor sportsmanship and just being a flat out A$$.

Shane: What a class act. Sick pool skills...I could throw superlative after superlative in trying to describe Shane and still fall short. American pool couldn't be represented any better. Earl has pushed about every button he could....and shane has remained unflappable. I'm not sure whats better his stroke or his mental toughness.

Lastly: I didn't tune in last night till around 10pm. I told the girlfriend after dinner " I'm going to at least check out the score of the match between Shane and Earl" We start watching and she starts rolling at Earl and all his antics. We ended up watching it till she left at around midnight(of course I watched it till completion) This morning she call and her first question was "How did Shane and Earl end up" ? "I think I'm hooked on this pool thing.

All the above aside this has been a incredible event. Hopefully the completion tonight is as good as the first two parts. Go Shane!!!!

I'm so glad earl toned it down all though he's still out of line.

It can't be forgiven what happened on the first day.. that was disgraceful.

I'm glad to see shane hit a gear finally on that table, heres to tonight!
 
I was thinking the same thing about the two differant chairs,I think Earl brought his own chair.
 
I remember seeing Shane useing the bridge 3 times maybe 4.
As far as Earl watching the cue ball on the break I believe most of that was about Shane fiddling with about 90% of the racks. Witch sort of started irritating me just watching Shane do it. That was the whole reason behind the magnify glass. It was like Shane was sharking Earl with that.

Exactly right...Shane IS pulling a move touching the balls after Earl racks.

Earl has asked Shane 30-40 times not to touch the balls, yet he still continues to do so.
 
Very insightful analysis. Thanks for taking the time to post it. I always enjoy your posts.
 
Very insightful analysis. Thanks for taking the time to post it. I always enjoy your posts.

thanks, I appreciate that. I know I risk that a lot of my posts aren't read, due to me not being a 2 or 3 sentence poster:D

We live in a twitter and text society, where anything longer then 140 characters loses many people's attention span:) I've seen many posts that have said as much..."if it's more then one paragraph (Artie B excluded), I'm not reading it":)

But I have things on my mind and I'm a fast typer, so brevity isn't my strong point, unless I'm trying to extract information from users when troubleshooting a IT Technical issue. Then I ask very short concise questions and want short concise answers.:D

Don't forget to get the final day to see how this great matchup ends up!

$15 for the final day... link is up now to purchase so you're all ready at 6:00 EST, when the pre-game feed is available.

http://www.theactionreport.com
 
I thought Earl was on his best behavior last night. I really don't think he can do any better. I noticed Earl wouldn't check the cue ball on the break until after Shane started touching his racks. The way I've always played, if it isn't rack your own, you don't touch the rack. You can make Earl rerack until he tells you to do it yourself but you can't touch it. I think that really bothered Earl.

I almost get the feeling Earl is laying off on Shane to make it close and a good show. Shane dogged a couple of balls early on and Earl would one stroke it and miss right after. Whenever Shane would start shooting better Earl would turn it up a notch to keep his lead. It just didn't seem like he wanted to blowout Shane but I'm probably imagining that.
 
After the talk with Mike, Earl did chill out on checking the cueball for a while. Shane said "I can see the line now", and after Mike talked with Earl, Earl looked at Shane and said he was sorry and wouldn't do it anymore.

Later, Earl became very frustrated with Shane messing with the rack. Earl said, "I'm not cheating, I wouldn't do that." You could tell it wasn't the rack it was that he felt Shane was questioning his integrity.

After many racks of adjustment, Earl said," Godammit if he's gonna do that then I'm gonna keep doing this (meaning check his cueball on the headstring)." From that point on he started doing it again, but it looked like Shane wasn't as bothered by it. Probably because he had found a button for Earl to counteract his feelings about the cb placement so it made him feel better (just speculation).
 
Hi Cali, thanks a million 4 all the insight and the photos.

I don't have access 2 the PPV so your commentary brings the event 2 life...

I think someone at another posting mentioned this table might B a conversion table , would U know about that?
 
Back
Top