I can't recall ever finding the tip to be the cause when someone says they are miscueing. I have found out of shape tips, or worn out tips, but not defective tips to be the cause.
I can't count how many times the stroke or mechanics are found to be the cause of the miscue.
Certainly tips are a personal preference. I get to hear those preferences from all areas of the country, and I am amazed at how localized it is. Some areas like soft Mooris, some like Snipers and some like Elk Masters.
Basically you have to try different ones and choose for yourself. But, before you fault a tip for causing miscues, let someone else play with it and see if they have the same problem. Don't tell them why you want them to play with it, let them find it out for themselves. If they miscue as well, then look at your tip.
Other than needing to be replaced because it's worn out, or badly out of shape, I don't think miscues really come from the tip very often. I mean, if it grips the ball on one shot, then why not another?